3 ms·
> As soon as you create a search engine, someone will figure out how manipulate the results. I see this sentiment a lot. Are there any actual examples of this
by marginalia_nu 5y ago
> As soon as you create a search engine, someone will figure out how manipulate the results.
I see this sentiment a lot. Are there any actual examples of this happening, or does it merely propagate on the basis of sounding true?
- dflock 5y agoThe example is the way that the dominance of Google changed the web. It's "manipulate the results", by way of "be careful what you wish for" - if there's money to be made in pandering to a search engines whims, then that will happen at scale and that content will swamp the good stuff that you wanted in the first place.
- marginalia_nu 5y agoGoogle is arguable exceptional, in that they are in a position to shape a significant amount of web traffic. Their largest competitor doesn't even have 1% market share.
- dflock 5y agoI agree with this - Google is so dominant and so large, that it distorts the entire web. But I think this is probably just a historical accident, more or less. This is just [Goodharts Law](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Goodhart%27s_law https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Goodhart%27s_law) write large: > When a measure becomes a target, it ceases to be a good measure. So, when you try to measure content quality in some way, that becomes a target, and starts to distort the quality of the content. I think this applies equally in any niche, at any scale where people find it worthwhile. If you have a niche search engine that has different content requirements, and it becomes worthwhile to SEO niche content for that engine, then it will happen, eventually. I think it just has to become worthwhile (and then for this fact to become known) - but that threshold is going to vary a lot, in different niches, times, places, etc... There are plenty of people (~everyone?) gaming/SEO'ing the search on Amazon, Etsy, Ebay, etc... for example, by doing niche & platform specific SEO on their listings on those platforms. I also think that people's definition of "worthwhile" differs too. For the broad SEO industry, it monetary. For people making posts on HN or Reddit, it's Karma, or Discussion or something - and people will optimize their content towards that, just for "fun". Actually, I think this applies pretty boardly to making _anything_, more or less, once you have someone or something evaluating/measuring your output? How _harmful_ this is, depends on what's being optimized for; scale & rewards probably change how "hard" the optimization arms race gets - as well as how many people are affected.
- rchaud 5y agoThe Panda update Google made in 2010 or so removed enormous volumes of spam websites that contained entirely machine-generated content, usually linking to shops selling counterfeit goods like Prada bags and Jordan sneakers. And that was when Google was over 12 years old. There was a time I only saw listicles on Cracked.com. Now most of Page 1 content on Google is structured like that, and most are low quality blogspam.
- marginalia_nu 5y agoI don't think these types of conclusions can be drawn based on Google, as they are in an exceptional position, with nearly complete market dominance as well as an economic incentive against cracking down too hard on ads.