4 ms·
OAuth is hardly Google only, it's part of RFC7628. There are very good reasons why a simple password login isn't necessarily what you want for your email protoc
by jeroenhd 5y ago
OAuth is hardly Google only, it's part of RFC7628. There are very good reasons why a simple password login isn't necessarily what you want for your email protocol. IMAP and 2FA are often at odds, for example, usually leading to vulnerable application passwords that bypass security requirements out of necessity.
I don't think many email clients support OAuth2 (Thunderbird does, but that could be Gmail specific?) but the concept isn't inherently bad, in my opinion.
I don't really see the problem with OAuth2 itself, the email space is just very very slow at accepting new standards. Dovecot and UTF8 email addresses still don't play well together, for example. The lack of proper on-the-fly application registration for mail servers is annoying, but supporting them should be easy enough if the mail service isn't run by complete doofuses.
- superkuh 5y ago>OAuth is hardly Google only, To be clear, I never said OAuth2 was google only. I said the standard OAuth2 is so much not a standard that an implementation written for Google's imap+OAuth2 will not work for any other email provider's imap+OAuth2.
- yxhuvud 5y ago> Thunderbird does, but that could be Gmail specific No, it definitely works on Office 365 too.