3 ms·
Users should not be subjecting all of their correspondents' communications to US warrantless surveillance anyway; Google is doing the world a service by making
by sneak 5y ago
Users should not be subjecting all of their correspondents' communications to US warrantless surveillance anyway; Google is doing the world a service by making their service harder and harder to interoperate with.
Gmail and other huge centralized points of censorship and surveillance must be destroyed. If you are a user, move away. If you are a developer, do not support these closed systems.
- morganvachon 5y agoI agree wholeheartedly in principle, but the reality is that it's nearly impossible to escape Google getting their hands on yours and your correspondents' messages at some point. So many businesses (and third party email providers!) use Google's services on the back end, and many relays out there are owned by Google/Alphabet even if it's not readily apparent, that the only way to even attempt to avoid them is using encrypted email. Unless everyone you communicate with (including companies, governments, and other organizations) is willing to only communicate via encrypted email as well, it's a lost cause.
- sneak 5y agoNo, the perfect is the enemy of the good here. "Email is insecure anyway and Google is big, therefore it's ok to give the adversary 100% of the plaintext" is not sound logic. This is not some principled stance, it is a clear and practical command: stop using these services. If your personal email address ends in @gmail.com, you are doing it wrong.
- morganvachon 5y agoI'm not saying you shouldn't give up Google services; I did. I'm just saying the unfortunate reality is that you'll never fully escape them.
- tptacek 5y agoMoving your data out of US jurisdiction doesn't shield it from US warrantless surveillance, but rather maximizes its exposure. The USG ostensibly requires due process (a warrant, whatever) to obtain information from US servers. It does not require any due process to obtain data from foreign servers. Coercively obtaining data from foreign servers is literally the chartered job of the NSA (of all signals intelligence agencies around the world, really). This is a super common misapprehension people have about data locality and surveillance, and it's no surprise that marketing plays off it ("keep your mail in Switzerland, so it's subject to Switzerland's strict privacy laws!"). There are other reasons to house things in Switzerland (or the Lesser Antilles or wherever). I'm not saying you should use GMail (unless security is a concern of yours, in which case you should use GMail).
- sneak 5y ago> The USG ostensibly requires due process (a warrant, whatever) to obtain information from US servers. This is no longer true, as Ed Snowden showed us. This is literally the point of their secret interpretation of FAA702. Pretending otherwise is nonsensical. The USG, just like the CCP, gets whatever data they want, about anyone, from servers in their own country, without due process. Anyway, my comment was not about jurisdiction, just about surveillance. Regardless, Google obviously has the plaintext if you use Gmail. You don't want that, either. The USG will probably only use it for a subset of things; Google has no/few limitations on the use once you voluntarily give them such a huge trove of data about your life, travel, vendors, and purchases.
- tptacek 5y agoI don't think you're totally following the logic. Stipulate that whatever legal process there is in the US for NSA (or any other intelligence agency) to get data is performative and easily bypassed. There is no legal process whatsoever for NSA to obtain that data from foreign targets. If you're worried about the Five Eyes SIGINT agencies, "foreign" servers are strictly less safe.
- sneak 4y agoForeign servers don't have an API for NSA to download a zip file of your account data without a human being in the loop, like Google does for FAA702. There's also the issue where Google itself is mass surveillance.
- unjustified 5y agoDo you honestly think that using Gmail protects me from the NSA? If the NSA wants into my computer, it's in. Secret services swap their data, so they can all read my santa letters. There is the viewpoint that one should prefer one's own jurisdiction regarding storing data (I know you don't like Schneier but he e.g. holds that viewpoint). I use an email provider from my country. If a judge from my country wants to persecute me, they have to complete a legal request which is tested by my provider. If I used an email provider from Switzerland or the US, is that also the case? Also, it's important to think of the economical aspect. If i financially support providers in my home country that lobby for better privacy laws and don't engage in surveillance capitalism like Google does, isn't that creating a good alternative that can also be properly regulated? Plus, it's one dependency less from a (more than) half MAGA country. So your recommendation makes sense if you are a citizen of the USA, but not everyone here is. Addendum: what do you actually mean by "security"? For me, that is also "being able to access my email account whenever I want" and that this account doesn't get closed, even if I do shit on the internet, whoever that decides. Google shouldn't have the right to say "these actions are uncool so let's kick this guy" (never happened to me, but I don't even have a contract with Google!, they have the right to cancel my account whenever they want.).