3 ms·
Some context that's missed in the title. "Plunging enrollment" and a "seismic hit" is their way of describing an overall 2% decline in enrollment. The article s
by somenameforme 5y ago
Some context that's missed in the title. "Plunging enrollment" and a "seismic hit" is their way of describing an overall 2% decline in enrollment. The article states that there are around 50 million students in the US public education system, and total enrollment has declined by 1.2 million. The article also provides very little in the way of non-anecdotal data. Digging through the article we get:
- Big declines: California, Denver, Albuquerque, Oakland
- Increases: Florida, "rural resort areas" (which have seen "surging enrollment"), private schools.
Given we're talking about a 2% decline, and the sort of places we're seeing declines in contrasted against where we're seeing gains, I think there's an explanation here that is so obvious that it goes without stating. Oddly enough that explanation is entirely ignored by the article.
My perception of US public schools has shifted radically over the past 10 years, and especially in the past couple of years. It had nothing to do with COVID except insomuch as COVID may have facilitated greater awareness of the educational curriculum.
- akomtu 5y agoI see two obvious explanations at least: housing and education. Housing includes the cost of raising kids: few can afford this in places like CA. Education includes the ideology push that parents are fed up with.
- armitron 5y agoCalifornia public school system is so atrociously bad that everyone with the means to do so should consider alternatives. You are doing a tremendous disservice to your kids otherwise. I took my kids and left the state years ago and there hasn’t been a single day where I don’t feel certain I made the right decision.
- jasonboyd 5y agoAtrociously bad by what metric? I was born and raised in Florida, as was my wife. We are both frequently impressed by how advanced our kids are, scholastically speaking, compared to where we were at that age in Florida. Edit: We now live in California and our kids have only attended (public) school in California.
- murderfs 5y agoDid you self-select into a public school that only has rich students? The average for California is depressingly bad: e.g. https://edsource.org/2022/californias-detailed-test-data-gives-it-an-advantage-for-the-road-ahead/669450 https://edsource.org/2022/californias-detailed-test-data-giv... The response by the state is to propose lowering standards for basic math classes, while removing the option of higher level math classes for advanced students.
- candiodari 5y ago> ... while removing the option of higher level math classes for advanced students. ... And in what I'm sure is a complete coincidence, the proportion of "very intelligent" or "disharmonic intelligence profile" or "savant syndrome" kids in youth services/youth care has gone up significantly. They now outnumber kids that committed crimes. They make "the Serway" available in Juvie these days, so obviously some very intelligent teenagers are committing crimes these days (probably because education is actually better in Juvie than in Youth Services) They're replacing advanced placement classes ... with straightjackets and bars. Social workers probably consider this a good thing too.
- alimov 5y agoFunding and proper use of funds, educator salaries, and a few other things should certainly be looked at. You can take your kids out of public school if you have the means, but they will be working with / living around people that went to public schools. I think the public school system needs better funding / resources and should be supported.