4 ms·
Rising gas prices may be to blame for economic doldrums
- jseliger 15y agoRead the linked paper by James Hamilton too: http://dss.ucsd.edu/%7Ejhamilto/Hamilton_oil_shock_08.pdf http://dss.ucsd.edu/%7Ejhamilto/Hamilton_oil_shock_08.pdf . It may turn out that we simply can't do anything about macro economic performance without working on energy problems. This kind of information has been circling among economics bloggers for quite a while but hasn't made much way into the mainstream.
- pohl 15y agoAmory Lovins has an old TED Talk on a plan to get out from under this problem. http://www.ted.com/talks/amory_lovins_on_winning_the_oil_endgame.html http://www.ted.com/talks/amory_lovins_on_winning_the_oil_end... More recently, he gave an excellent talk at Berkeley. Don't miss this if you liked the TED Talk. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U_EKZvb7gc8 http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=U_EKZvb7gc8
- sunstone 15y agoThis is also predicted in the book "Why Your World Is About To Get A Whole Lot Smaller" by Jeff Rubin. Mr. Rubin is an ex chief economist of an investment bank who quit his job so he could publish the book. Recommended.
- trebor 15y agoY'think? Most east coast Americans eat salad that comes from the west coast. Now, driving ~2,600 miles in a truck with an efficiency of ~12mpg will cost $736 at $3.40/gal. That's just transportation of SALAD. Add that up for everything we ship around, and you get large expenses that "spread out" over every consumer. I am convinced that if we ate locally for more and had lower gas prices most this financial crisis, except with the stupid mortgage crisis, would evaporate.
- saalweachter 15y agoThe US DOT limit on tractor trailers is 40 tons. If your average salad-carrying tractor trailer is hauling 10 tons of salad, and the average serving size of salad is 1/2 pound, then you will haul 40,000 servings of salad per tractor trailer. In this case, your stated fuel costs will add about 1.8 cents to the cost of each salad.
- trebor 15y agoI personally think the cost is 3x that (I doubt a fully loaded Semi gets 12mpg), but when you tack that on top of everything you buy it does affect market prices. I think the biggest cost is in commuting/personal travel. I drive ~19mi to work, 5x weekly, and get 33.55mpg on average (highway&town). This costs me about $19.28/wk just commuting; driving to church 3x costs me $13.37/wk; going to a Bible study in the same area costs me $5. This is $37.65/wk just for scheduled driving in a given week, or about 4% of my net income per pay period (at $3.40/gal which is lower than average prices here at home). Dropping gas prices to $3.27/gal costs me $36.26/wk (barely no change). But if that dropped more steeply, say to $2.50, it'd be $27.71 or 2.95% of my net income. I think that a major drop like that would free up ~2% of everyone's net income. Most people would spend more which would help our consumption-based economy; hopefully others would save it rather than spend it and turn our negative savings rate around.
- polymatter 15y agoBut its presumably cheaper[1] to grow salad in the east coast and pay that $3.40/gal than it is to grow the same salad in the west coast. Otherwise a smart farmer would make salad in the west coast and saturate the west coast market with his own offerings. There are great arguments for eating locally. One of the main reasons for those agriculture tariffs that stop poorer countries flooding the markets with cheap produce, which allows local farmers to compete. Otherwise your salads would be even more ridiculously sourced from China or something. [1] admittedly it could still be more expensive but happen anyway due to comparative advantage that I can't explain well enough this late.
- saalweachter 15y agoThis sounds like after-the-fact rationalization of do-nothing-ism. Conventional, classic macroeconomics has been spot on in predicting this crisis as it unfolds. Why do we need this extra hypothesis?
- lcargill99 15y agoDuring the original oil shock, consumption dropped by as much as half. Was there a corresponding drop in quality of life? I would say no. There is massive shadow-marginal inefficiency in transport, and the signals are always masked for political reasons. It is much more likely that the Scott Sumner hypothesis - the oil bump in '08 caused a "false" signal of inflation that the Fed misread as real inflation, and subsequently tightened the money supply - is true. He will go so far to say that this may have caused the meltdown itself. I am a big James Hamilton fan, and I think I see where he's going with this ( we need to expand the money supply ) but this particular correlation is at best a strawman. It is interesting, but it's pretty clear to me that demand-destruction for oil is its own good. It always comes back to Hayek - the knowledge problem will be with us always - but Hayek didn't have much to say about deflation.