5 ms·
Isn't entire point of stablecoin that you can redeem it for the face value at any time? Not being able to redeem it seems like violating the contract or changin
by Ekaros 5y ago
Isn't entire point of stablecoin that you can redeem it for the face value at any time? Not being able to redeem it seems like violating the contract or changing the rules while game is running...
- phire 5y ago
- cowtools 5y agoWell, the users did agree to the code when they bought $cryptocurrency
- phire 5y agoAre all the users programmers, are they fluent with the language and frameworks? Could they even read the code if they wanted to? Even if they could read the code and understand that there is a mechanism in place that allows designated humans to pause redemption, the code says nothing about when and how this mechanism should be used. The user might reasonably expect such a mechanism would only be used in an emergency, like the network has been hacked, or there is a bug. They might expect that it would never be used for the financial advantage of the network operators simply because the coin has depegged and redemption is acting as expected.
- coding_unit_1 5y agoYou've neatly captured why TradFi regulation is a thing.
- reedjosh 5y agoUsers that don't understand these things shouldn't jump into the market and buy the hottest thing. They should probably stick to long lasting products like BTC, ETH, or XMR. > The user might reasonably expect such a mechanism would only be used in an emergency A de-peg event is an emergency if there's not enough real value to back it. The USD was depegged from gold in the seventies for very similar reasons. In both cases the printer got ahead of the backing. Today we use a currency that survived a de-peg event due to military backing.
- ibejoeb 5y ago> Are all the users programmers, are they fluent with the language That's a fair criticism, but isn't it the status quo in the industry in general? Surely most people with stakes in the markets don't truly understand the regulations or the innate dynamics of them.
- ipnon 5y agoWhat makes central bank currencies special is that institutions like the Fed can "mint" or "burn" dollars whenever they please to maintain the "peg". In reality they're targeting a 2% floating rate of inflation, and the "minting" is done by making loans to banks that are motivated by economic stability instead of profit. Crypto stable coins don't have this luxury because this mechanism is founded upon trust in the central bank's governance and the underlying government.
- School-Cotton 5y agoCorrect. You’ve discovered one of the many disadvantages with cryptocurrencies relative to traditional finance.
- stickfigure 5y agoAlso the advantage! Sometimes central banks screw up the minting process and severely damage the currency (see: Argentina, Venezuela, Zimbabwe). Historically, currencies are a mixed bag and we should be glad there is more than one.
- Fnoord 5y agoRight, and you can add Russia to that list most likely, but I live in a relatively stable country.
- Spivak 5y agoI’m sure in the contract it says they have the right to “delay” redemption. Really is amazing that the crypto world is finally discovering bank runs. We’re truly living like it’s 1929.
- izzydata 5y agoYea, but to me it sounds like the same problem as a bank run. If everyone tried to retrieve their money from the bank at the same time they wouldn't have enough money.
- salawat 5y agoCorrect. These exchanges are banks, which are reliant on statistical multiplexing. There is quite literally zero difference between the sets of failure states that "stablecoins" are vulnerable to. ...which makes you wonder: why the cryptographic overhead at all? Oh wait... Because places want to be banks, without adhering to the regulations thereof...
- throwanem 5y ago> statistical multiplexing "Fractional reserve."
- trompetenaccoun 5y agoThat's true for banks but it's not a similar mechanism in any way. You should look into the term 'algorithmic stablecoin', these are basically a scam and don't work, which is why they keep losing their peg. There are other examples long before the media started paying attention and people in the crypto space have warned about this for ages. Of course, some might call fractional reserve banking a scam as well but what these algorithmic stablecoins are doing isn't the same thing as the credit creation by private banks. It's more like they tried to create a "decentralized" central bank. I put that in quotations because the ones I know aren't actually decentralized either, they just use such buzzwords to trick traders. Not all stablecoins work that way. There are more reputable ones like DAI or USDC. Actually the first stablecoins were all collateralized, the shananigans started in 2017 during the last bubble and now there are even more of these scammy projects because the market has grown so much. Adoption brings in a lot of newbies with money, and that in turn attracts charlatans of course. You can get a feel for what level of education the general public has when even in a tech forum most people don't understand anything about the economics and mechanisms of all these projects.
- sumeno 5y agoThe big stablecoins have terms of service that say they don't guarantee you can ever redeem them.
- djbusby 5y agoWhat!? how is there a TOS on a coin? Maybe TOS on a gateway site?
- E4YomzYIN5YEBKe 5y agoA coin is code and the code for pretty much every stable coin allow the creator to prevent coins from being sent to/from blacklisted addresses. Tether freezes $150 million in USDT https://cointelegraph.com/news/tether-freezes-150-million-in-usdt https://cointelegraph.com/news/tether-freezes-150-million-in... Circle Confirms Freezing $100K in USDC at Law Enforcement's Request https://www.coindesk.com/markets/2020/07/08/circle-confirms-freezing-100k-in-usdc-at-law-enforcements-request/ https://www.coindesk.com/markets/2020/07/08/circle-confirms-...
- aabhay 5y agostable coins with redemption must be centralized at the point of fiat exchange.
- FabHK 5y agoThere are 1. purely algorithmic stable coins (on-chain), such as UST. Voodoo, if you ask me. Can be decentralised. 2. (over)collateralised stable coins (on-chain), such as DAI (not DEI, which is at issue here). Collateralised by other crypto, smart contracts, and what have you. Can still be decentralised. 3. collateralised stable coins (off-chain), such as USDC or (allegedly) USDT. Those are collateralised by good old USD (or treasuries or commercial paper). Those need a central authority that holds on to the USD (or whatever form the collateral takes). So, makes sense that they have TOS.
- jMyles 5y agoThe "entire point"? What, in your mind, does redemption mean for an algo stable? Obviously, as we've seen, algo stables are subject to their own engineered ponzinomics, but I don't think redemption is "the entire point", or even a cognizable concept.
- DebtDeflation 5y agoYes, a true "stablecoin" would be 100% backed by deposits in a known and verifiable money market account and able to be withdrawn into USD or other real currency on demand at a 1:1 ratio. None of the things called stablecoins today meet this very simple set of criteria.
- FabHK 5y agoDoes USDC not fit that description?
- DebtDeflation 5y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/USD_Coin https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/USD_Coin >The wording on the Circle website changed from the previous "backed by US dollars" to "backed by fully reserved assets" by June 2021. >USDC reserves are regularly attested (but not audited) by Grant Thornton, LLP This is the same bullshit that Tether has repeatedly pulled.
- FabHK 5y agoAh, thanks for the info. I thought Coinbase was more reputable.
- noneeeed 5y agoWhat's the difference between "attested" and "audited" in this context. That really sounds like a linguistic cop-out.
- vkou 5y agoMy understanding is that an attestation that you have a billion dollars looks at your bank balance, and observes that you have a billion dollars in your accounts. An audit looks at the history of your overall financials, to ensure that you didn't just borrow that billion dollars two days ago for the sole purpose of passing the audit. Or that you didn't, like, cash a half-billion dollar check from yourself to yourself, and have the money immediately show up in the destination account, before it was debited from the source account.
- SilasX 5y agoI think that's confusing means and ends. The point of stablecoins is to have something that's the same value as a dollar, but which can interface with ("all the wonderful magic of") smartcontracts. One way to achieve that is to have a big trusted organization honor redemption on demand. (GUSD and, I think but don't quote me, USDC.) Another way is for an org to consistently honor enough redemptions (but not on an on-demand basis) that it trades at par (USDT, for now). Another (dubious, increasingly unreliable) way is for some cryptocurrency to automatically buy the stablecoin when it falls below par (TerraUSD/UST with LUNA, already failed).[1] Yet another is to issue the stablecoin only in return for a significant collateral buffer (with other cryptocurrencies) and force sellbacks when the collateral gets too close to critical (DAI and, I think, FEI, not to be confused with the DEI in this story). [1] TerraUSD's platform had the Ponzi-esque Anchor paying 20% returns, but is stabilizing mechanism did not (attempt to) depend on this in any direct sense.