3 ms·
On the other hand, NVIDIA does not have legal authority to control where its GPUs actually end up being used (nasty things like drivers shutting down when detec
by mschuster91 5y ago
On the other hand, NVIDIA does not have legal authority to control where its GPUs actually end up being used (nasty things like drivers shutting down when detecting virtualizations aside). How can anyone prove or disprove that a specific percentage of GPUs end up in a specific market, as long as NVIDIA can prove they have kept their usual delivery targets towards wholesale distributors?
- dematz 5y agoThis is a good question. I remember having to give my identity before walking out of a store with a computer with a GPU in it, and if someone really wanted to buy multiple GPUs for mining that wouldn't stop them. The SEC lists some facts suggesting nvidia thought they were ending up mining (https://www.sec.gov/litigation/admin/2022/33-11060.pdf https://www.sec.gov/litigation/admin/2022/33-11060.pdf): "NVIDIA launched a product line of cryptomining processors, known as “CMP,” which the company marketed to large cryptomining operations ... Based on known CMP sales, the company identified cryptomining as a significant element of the OEM GPU sales" "NVIDIA also received information indicating that cryptomining was a significant factor in year-over-year growth in NVIDIA’s Gaming GPUs revenue. Some of the company’s sales personnel, in particular in China, reported what they believed to be significant increases in demand for Gaming GPUs as a result of cryptomining" These were the 2 most concrete points to me - management was aware miners drove up GPU prices for gamers and saw it as another big market to capture, and sales attributed increased demand to miners. The rest of it basically says crypto grew, nvidia sales grew, and nvidia thought sales grwe because of crypto. Honestly, I'm not sure it's possible even knowing these factors to know who really bought the GPUs or where they really ended up, but idk all the SEC probably cares about is nvidia not disclosing material seeming information.
- simiones 5y agoThat is irrelevant. The SEC also didn't go and check what people were using their NVIDIA GPUs for. The problem is that NVIDIA leadership knew/believed that a proportion X of their GPUs were being bought for crypto mining (thus tying demand with crypto prices), while they reported to investors a different number, Y, with Y < X. This is material information that they simply lied about, which is illegal for a publicly traded company. In fact, the lawsuit could have happened even if Y > X. If NVIDIA had reported the same numbers they did, and people had been in fact using them at the same rate that they did, but NVIDIA hadn't known about it, then nothing illegal would have happened. If NVIDIA had later found out and disclosed this to investors, again no lawsuit (though perhaps share prices would have changed, one way or another).