3 ms·
> I've never understood car makers obsession with proximity unlock. The competition has it. Some people like it. And in Tesla's case, it saves money. There is
by dotancohen 5y ago
> I've never understood car makers obsession with proximity unlock.
The competition has it. Some people like it.
And in Tesla's case, it saves money. There is no cylinder on the steering column, no cylinder in the door, no steel key to manufacture, no rod going to a physical unlock switch, and no physical unlock switch. So we've saved 500 grams in the car and probably a good $20 too, no to mention the room in the door for the rod and the physical switch, which add engineering work.
There is a long tail of removing grams and dollars from the car manufacturing process, and 500 grams and $20 is significant. This long tail is why e.g. the Model 3 uses a touch screen for most controls, why the rear glass extends far into the roof, and many other seemingly-"premium" features of the Model 3. It's actually cheaper to manufacture them this way.
- riffraff 5y agobut why use _proximity_ ? You may just as well require a click on the key fob or phone, the cost savings would be exactly the same.
- brianwawok 5y agoIt’s great. Walk up to car get in and push gas. Stop it and walk away. No locks to fiddle with, it just works.
- bjt2n3904 5y ago> And in Tesla's case, it saves money. There is no cylinder on the steering column, no cylinder in the door... This is precisely what I mean by "brain dead". You'll forgive the hostility, but this is exactly what I'm talking about! Nothing about this list of things REQUIRES proximity unlock. You can still require the user to push a button on their key fob to explicitly unlock the door. I get the convenience factor, I do. If that's a feature you enjoy, then great! All the happiness for you. But give me the chance to opt out of something that is deeply broken from a security perspective. Let me press a fscking button to unlock my car, instead of my car deciding I probably want it to unlock.
- raverbashing 5y agoExactly. Customers "pushing for convenience" are unaware of the possible security implications of it (to put it in a polite way). And it is absolutely the duty of manufacturers to shut them away from stupid crap like that. Ask any consumer if they want a Pony and they will say yes.
- brianwawok 5y agoGlad you aren’t my car manufacturer.
- raverbashing 5y agoSure, you're free to pick the best solution for you. I'd opt for the most reliable one.
- einarfd 5y agoI believe I've seen a setting to setup a pin code to drive on my Model 3. You can also unlock the car with the cards that came with it instead of setting up the app on your phone and using Bluetooth. It would be a bit clunky, but it would work. There is also a keyfob you can buy (https://shop.tesla.com/product/model-3_y-key-fob https://shop.tesla.com/product/model-3_y-key-fob), not sure if that uses Bluetooth or not, and is vulnerable though.
- gjs278 5y ago
- bratwurst3000 5y agoYes opt out is completly missing with electronic cars. I hope some day it will be mandatory. All those „features“ are useless to me and only freaking me out.
- diblasio 5y agoSetting up the proximity unlock is a manual step and decision you make. You can just not do this and use the keycard + pin if you're wanting more security.