4 ms·
In addition to the rationale given by the other responders, the overturning of Roe v Wade means you have many states where abortion access is not just legal, bu
by hn_throwaway_99 5y ago
In addition to the rationale given by the other responders, the overturning of Roe v Wade means you have many states where abortion access is not just legal, but guaranteed and protected, and other states where not only is abortion illegal, but anyone who assists someone in getting an abortion is guilty of a crime. I've heard it said that this is the biggest incompatible coexistence of state laws since free states vs slave states.
So it's very likely you'll have law enforcement in forced-birth states try to subpoena data from tech companies where servers and workers are in abortion-legal states. The argument is that strong encryption will prevent these kinds of immoral (from the perspective of the author) data requests from being fulfilled.
- Buttons840 5y agoThe hotness of abortion (can you even conceive of a more controversial issue?) and the geographical nature of having people travel to other states to get abortions, while some states try to limit what you can and cannot do in other states, this does seem like the most likely to cause civil war (most likely of the many unlikely possibilities). The legal shenanigans we see happening could deepen this divide, as you say, and transform it into a economic divide as well. Will we one day seek companies that do not host their data in certain states? How will this effect those states where nobody wants to do business? Texas recently passed a law that Twitter cannot censor people based on political views, and that it is illegal for Twitter to simply leave the state. We may see this play out, where a state feels wronged by a "foreign" company in another state, yet may not have the power to enforce any punishment on the company in those other states, again, furthering the divide.
- robonerd 5y agoCivil war seems far-fetched; states have a lot less autonomy today than they did before the last civil war, specifically because of that civil war. The ability of a state to successfully wage war against others has been largely scrutinized and corrected. I think the most likely outcome is Congress passes a federal law (which inevitably pisses off one side, the other, or maybe even the extremes of both sides) and the losing side gets back to the status quo of seething mostly-peacefully about it.