5 ms·
It's such a pretty app, but I can't bring myself to drop $150 for it.
by kstrauser 5y ago
It's such a pretty app, but I can't bring myself to drop $150 for it.
- corn13read 5y ago
- msbarnett 5y agoEh, for how much use I get out of a merge tool, $150 is pretty meaningless for the right tool. We're talking fractions of fractions of fractions of a penny per use over many years. If it makes my life better those kinds of tooling costs aren't even worth thinking about. That said, I haven't used the new Kaleidoscope (although I was a fan of their last version and happily used it for 8 years or so), and currently use Sublime Merge. Edit: someone care to explain to me why this completely innocuous comment on my personal philosophy of tool value is worthy of downvoting to -2?
- 40four 5y agoI’m sure someone as experienced as you knows commenting about up/ down votes is explicitly against the guidelines. No worries though. No need to fret, just imagine those sad souls, and what most be going through their heads, as to find your comment offensive :) Maybe they were pushing back against the idea of paying money, for good quality software, that provides value to your life?!? Haha, joking of course. But seriously, I agree with you. If it is a tool that I use all the time, makes my life easier, and is of good quality… I’m happy to pay up for a license. I’ve spent way more than that on my favorite database GUI clients over the years. Money well spent, and the developers earned it. Happy to support them!
- WastingMyTime89 5y ago> Maybe they were pushing back against the idea of paying money, for good quality software, that provides value to your life?!? Or they realise the hubris you need to have to think 150$ to be a meaningless amount of money. It's already quite a sum at the median American salary and the USA is one of the most affluent countries from which HN readers hail.
- msbarnett 5y ago> Or they realise the hubris you need to have to think 150$ to be a meaningless amount of money. It's already quite a sum at the median American salary and the USA is one of the most affluent countries from which HN readers hail. Ok, but I’m a software developer and this is a professional tool with which I do a job that makes me several hundred thousand dollars a year. I don’t know that it’s “hubris” to recognize that relative to the income this helps me create, its costs are a rounding error. Obviously $150 is a lot of money for a lot of people making a much lower income!… but those people likely aren’t in the market for a 3-way diff & merge tool, so I can’t imagine why you’d expect a discussion of this tool to have to add a disclaimer accounting for them? This is a professional tool whose costs exist relative to the income they create for the professional who wields them. My plumber brother-in-law certainly doesn’t refuse to spend tens of thousands of dollars on the equipment he uses for his job on the basis that this would be too expensive for someone working the counter at a fast food store. Nor should he – the costs make him money, and that’s what’s important. (indeed, compared to almost any trade you can think of, we're lucky that our tools cost so little)
- stingraycharles 5y ago> Obviously $150 is a lot of money for a lot of people making a much lower income!… but those people likely aren’t in the market for a 3-way diff & merge tool You’re forgetting that even in e.g. European countries, the average salary is much, much lower than in the US, most software devs don’t get 6-figure salaries. They would definitely be in the market for such a tool, but the price is prohibitive.
- msbarnett 5y agoWell that's fine, really – they should make decisions about what tools to buy based on how much it makes them, not how much it makes me, just the same as I don't base my decisions on what tools I buy based on a hypothetical Estonian contractor's salary. I'm not really "forgetting" anything so much as I was making a statement about myself – you'll notice the prominent "I" and "me" in "Eh, for how much use I get out of a merge tool, $150 is pretty meaningless for the right tool" and "Ok, but I’m a software developer and this is a professional tool with which I do a job that makes me several hundred thousand dollars a year." – which for some reason has prompted a bunch of "well, whatabout median American income making non-developers" and "well, whatabout underpaid European developers". I am neither of these things. Wasn't talking about them. North American saws probably aren't priced affordably for Estonian carpenters either, when it comes down to it.
- smohare 5y agoMeh. People have issue with those proselytizing crappy software that is not deserving of even a download. The issue isn’t with people being derisive of bad alternatives, but folk who are so convinced of the utility of garbage that they keep promoting it. Database / warehouse IDEs are also such an extreme edge case that I’ll leave to reader as an exercise to reason about. Why even bring that up?
- kstrauser 5y agoI get that. I'm sure I've paid for tools over the years that would make someone else shake their head. Good on the Kaleidoscope gang for making a tool that people are willing to shell out for. It still gives me sticker shock, though.
- jw1224 5y agoI just realised I’ve been using Kaleidoscope for maybe 10 (?) years now. I certainly didn’t pay $150 for it at the time, but if I had done, it would’ve been worth every penny. — I seem to recall the app was acquired by a new development team a couple of years ago. It seems to have been one of those rare acquisitions where it’s consistently gotten better afterwards (and it was great to begin with).
- Nextgrid 5y ago150 would be peanuts if there weren't any other tools out there, but there are plenty of alternatives, both free and paid, and some of which people might already be paying for (IntelliJ/PyCharm has a very good built-in diff tool).
- simondotau 5y agoEspecially since you can’t even edit text directly in it. WinMerge is pretty much the only Windows app I miss now that I’m using MacOS full time.
- aaronblohowiak 5y agoKdiff3
- shadowfiend 5y agoThat is false. You can edit directly in it, at minimum in 3 column view. I know because I do it regularly and have done for years.
- simondotau 5y agoIt is not false. You can't just drop two text files onto Kaleidoscope and perform a diff with manual edits. I do know that Kaleidoscope can support editing under certain specific conditions, but those aren't relevant for me. WinMerge supports editing under any conditions. https://twitter.com/kaleidoscopeapp/status/341930870900416512 https://twitter.com/kaleidoscopeapp/status/34193087090041651... That tweet is from 2013 and nothing has changed in the intervening nine years.
- denkmoon 5y agoCan't get work to drop $150 on it :(
- PokestarFan 5y agoPersonally I prefer the IntelliJ merge tool since I don't have to pay extra for a 3rd program.
- kstrauser 5y agoAs a side note, sorry I even brought this up. While I still think it's expensive for what it is, darned if I'm going to chastise anyone for buying a tool they like. I certainly didn't expect the conversation to go off the rails like that.