2 ms·
You have the look at the system as whole, not just the UST side of it. The system as a whole was not doing anything that generated value, and could only pay yie
by vkou 5y ago
You have the look at the system as whole, not just the UST side of it. The system as a whole was not doing anything that generated value, and could only pay yield as long as people were paying money into it.
This was the major innovation of UST. A ponzi that's sufficiently obfuscated that if you look at any part of the system in isolation, it seems fine.
You can have an uncollateralized currency - like baseball cards, but that's not what UST was. It made additional promices (like being a stablecoin, and offering yield).
You maybe even theoretically can create an uncollateralized stablecoin (that remains stable) but you're not going to attract $XY billion into your stablecoin without dangling a carrot to convince the greedy to invest. Investing into a stablecoin is stupid[1], because its price can't go up - so in this case, the carrot was fraudulent yield.
UST only had value because it was backed by Luna, and it only had demand for it because of the promises of yield. Luna was backed by nothing but speculation, driven by demand for UST. Once net money stopped flowing into the Luna ecosystem, the whole thing collapsed.
Any system that only works as long as net value flows into it, but produces no value of its own, but promises yields is a ponzi.
[1] Yes, there are use cases for it that don't involve speculation, but those use cases aren't going to see the market cap explode at the rate Tera/Luna did.