3 ms·
You thow up a bunch of targets, I'll limit myself to one: What was he trying to convey with this paragraph that closes the article? My read is that Smil is ad
by dredmorbius 5y ago
You thow up a bunch of targets, I'll limit myself to one:
What was he trying to convey with this paragraph that closes the article?
My read is that Smil is addressing a lot of hand-wavy assertions, again from across the BAU to halt-fossil-fuels-now spectrum, that there are easy ways out. A hard analysis based on quantities, properties, and available viable options says that no, there aren't easy ways out. AI alone won't save us, aps won't save us, unsubstantiated claims of dematerialisation won't save us. You could look to sources such as David MacKay, Sustainable Energy --- Without the Hot Air, who made a similarly hardboiled analysis for the UK. Given rates of energy consumption, touted measures like "unplug your electronics" are not enough. This isn't a problem that's solved by a bunch of small measures, but by a bunch of big measures.
And the specific big measure here is get fossil fuels out of materials production. Most espeically of ammonia, plastics, steel, and concrete, though that itself is still just a start.
You've expressed yourself largely, if not entirely coherently, in what you're against.
What do you happen to be for? What goals and methods are you advocating, addressing what problems, specifically?
You admitted above to not even reading the article. If you're going to discuss it at length, I'd hope you might fix that. And read closely, because his arguments really are nuanced.
https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31396935 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31396935