3 ms·
This seems confusing to me (although I am just an engineer so it isn't surprising if I've missed something). The photon is basically a packet energy. It bounces
by bee_rider 5y ago
This seems confusing to me (although I am just an engineer so it isn't surprising if I've missed something). The photon is basically a packet energy. It bounces out of the box, I guess reducing the energy in the box (right?), which is just normal photons-bouncing-out-of-box behavior.
In this case, they've managed to come up with a configuration, via superoscillation, that results in an unusually large packet of energy. But is this a conservation of energy issue? I don't see how this is any "worse" for conservation of energy than bouncing out multiple red photons.
Is the inability of a red box to release higher energy photons actually a deep physical principle, or just a general trend because configurations that can generate superocillations are rare? I guess I don't see the link between "photon is too big" and "conservation of energy" -- probably it is an obvious link for the physicists here, though.
- zmgsabst 5y agoMy experience of this is generally: “Physicists discover limits of simplifying assumptions, pretend to be surprised ignoring things leads to inaccurate results in extreme circumstances.”
- ziddoap 5y agoThey have a photon with energy=x, and are detecting a photon with energy=x+y. The question is where the y comes from. Since they've ruled out the usual suspects, it seems to be a violation of conservation of energy.
- QuadmasterXLII 5y agoMy understanding is that at the beginning of the experiment there is only one red photon in the box.
- bee_rider 5y agoOh wow, that is a crucial aspect that I totally missed, which makes the result much more surprising!