4 ms·
I’ve stopped using FSD except on the highway when it uses the old model. Every single time I used FSD I experienced at least one moment of mortal terror as the
by fnordpiglet 5y ago
I’ve stopped using FSD except on the highway when it uses the old model. Every single time I used FSD I experienced at least one moment of mortal terror as the car made an obviously wrong decision like lurching into oncoming traffic or off the road. I’m shocked frankly there aren’t more stories. The only thing I can imagine is people did like me and stopped using it.
- jread 5y ago+1 Bought a used X with FSD and learned the hard way to only use on freeways and highways in simple driving conditions or traffic. Even then I’m on constant alert for phantom braking. I can’t understand the $12,000 price justification.
- darknavi 5y agoFSD understands roads _so much better_ than the old stack. I like using without any "navigate" features, aka "drive in a straight line" mode when on surface streets.
- ink 5y agoThis has been my experience as well.
- chronofar 5y agoSame. I've also stopped letting it make decisions about lane changes on highways, so it's basically just an advanced cruise control for me. Once the novelty wears off (both in the case of highway and more recently surface street beta), I ultimately want to use self-driving to remove cognitive load and provide a safer experience. The vehicle does a good job at keeping lanes at a relatively steady speed (note not great, phantom breaking is still a thing and it brakes/accelerates too fast still), but too often makes poor decisions which ends up increasing the amount of attention I have to pay, thus defeating the purpose. On some highways I frequent I can't even turn on auto-navigate at all, even w/ auto-lane change turned off, b/c for some bizarre reason it thinks it needs to get to the far left of a 16 lane highway to follow the route so it keeps bugging me even after I reject it (so again, just more of an annoyance). I pretty much only turn it on on surface streets when showing someone new in the car w/ me or driving on a long straight 2 lane backroad (which it does probably best of all). Personally I'm not as up in arms about Tesla being reckless as everyone else, I think they make it pretty clear you need to supervise the car thoroughly. But for me it's just not really even close to the level it would need to be to provide the convenience L4/L5 would.
- dawnerd 5y agoI really don't understand how anyone is out there saying FSD is doing amazing like all those youtubers and Elon fanboys keep saying. It does horribly. Sometimes it does well enough to fool you into thinking its better... but then it just goes and takes the wrong turn or gets into the wrong lane. I've requested twice to be removed from the FSD now and so far no one has removed me.
- throwaway0a5e 5y agoThe greater your ability to be like "that was a crap move, why did it make that move?" the less likely you are to be using FSD in a situation preceding one of those crap moves to begin with.
- brokenmachine 5y agoIt scares me so much that there are people out there trusting this garbage in a vehicle on public roads.
- kaba0 5y agoIt should be made illegal ASAP and those who bought it be refunded
- hatware 5y agoBut you paid $10K for it, right?
- misiti3780 5y agoit's 199/month
- hatware 5y agoEither way, you don't own it.
- misiti3780 5y agothat has nothing to with the OP
- hatware 5y agoIt absolutely does! Tesla's practices are incredibly anti-consumer, and FSD is vapor-ware. $10K plus $200 monthly? Talk about getting taken for a ride.
- misiti3780 5y agoit's 10K or 200/month, not both. who are you kidding - you pay 10 a month for spotify and dont own the songs, you rent movies on amazon and probably storage on dropbox and s3, computing power on google or ec2. it's no different, except for you hate tesla and think it's different.
- brokenmachine 5y agoSpotify actually plays music as it claims. Amazon, etc that you listed actually provide services. FSD is a feature that doesn't exist.
- 5y ago
- drewg123 5y agoWhat made me mostly stop using it is that on a winding country road with no shoulder that I drive daily, it often STOPS for oncoming traffic in the opposite lane. These are standard width lanes, with plenty of room for 2-way traffic. It also (on the same sort of road) applies the brakes gently very often, making me a bit sea-sick from the constant brake tapping.
- popularonion 5y agoI paid $8K for FSD two years ago and still not in the beta, but I stopped caring a while back. I still use Autosteer all the time. LIDAR FUD is what everyone talks about the most by far, but I think these are the real, actual issues: - Side pillar cameras simply do not give enough sight coverage of intersections, no matter what computer models say. - Camera resolution needs to be a lot higher than everyone thinks. Think of how much harder it feels for a human to drive with even just a little bit of fog or rain. - Project assumptions based on circa 2015 peak ML/AI hype. Classic development hell where rewrites/improvements are put off far too long.