3 ms·

Good luck, spectrum is highly regulated in every country I can think of. If national governments don’t want you networking across borders, you’re definitely not

Good luck, spectrum is highly regulated in every country I can think of. If national governments don’t want you networking across borders, you’re definitely not going to be broadcasting long range radio transmissions that way. In fact, it’s currently illegal to transmit encrypted data or to relay packets via ham radio in the US.

matheusmoreira 4y ago
Who knows? The whole point of decentralization is for there to be so many nodes in the network they can't possibly take them all down so that it's pointless to even try. What if all smartphones formed a mesh network? There aren't enough prisons in my country for all those criminals.
- eloisius 4y ago
  I agree with your ethos, but I don't share your optimism. If the state wants to enforce networking firewalls along national boundaries, no technological solution will save us in general. As a resourceful techie with the right know-how you may be able to sneak your packets through, just like people in Cuba receive a literal packet of data via sneakernet, but if the state doesn't want widespread meshnets circumventing their firewall, they will imprison you for emitting pirate radio signals, they will penalize any electronics manufacturer that makes non-compliant hardware, and rest assured that companies will go right along. Liberty requires more than technical solutions. I'm saying this as someone who once wrote a decentralized P2P mesh for instant messaging[1]. I was inspired by the HK protests going on ~2014 after hearing that they were using Bluetooth chat apps. Luckily Matrix, Telegram, Signal, etc. mostly solved the problem. Still, I don't think any amount of mesh networking would turn back the tide of Hong Kong now. [1]: https://github.com/zacstewart/comm/ https://github.com/zacstewart/comm/
- groby_b 4y ago
  >What if all smartphones formed a mesh network? There aren't enough prisons in my country for all those criminals. There don't need to be. You publicly gruesomely execute the first 100 or so you catch, and the practice of running a mesh node on your cell phone will fall so far out of fashion that the network breaks. Societal shortcomings cannot be fixed via tech alone. If you can't build a society resilient to authoritarianism in the first place, tech will not help you. It can be used to increase resilience, but that's far from fixing the problem by itself.

matheusmoreira 4y ago

Who knows? The whole point of decentralization is for there to be so many nodes in the network they can't possibly take them all down so that it's pointless to even try. What if all smartphones formed a mesh network? There aren't enough prisons in my country for all those criminals.

eloisius 4y ago
I agree with your ethos, but I don't share your optimism. If the state wants to enforce networking firewalls along national boundaries, no technological solution will save us in general. As a resourceful techie with the right know-how you may be able to sneak your packets through, just like people in Cuba receive a literal packet of data via sneakernet, but if the state doesn't want widespread meshnets circumventing their firewall, they will imprison you for emitting pirate radio signals, they will penalize any electronics manufacturer that makes non-compliant hardware, and rest assured that companies will go right along. Liberty requires more than technical solutions. I'm saying this as someone who once wrote a decentralized P2P mesh for instant messaging[1]. I was inspired by the HK protests going on ~2014 after hearing that they were using Bluetooth chat apps. Luckily Matrix, Telegram, Signal, etc. mostly solved the problem. Still, I don't think any amount of mesh networking would turn back the tide of Hong Kong now. [1]: https://github.com/zacstewart/comm/ https://github.com/zacstewart/comm/
groby_b 4y ago
>What if all smartphones formed a mesh network? There aren't enough prisons in my country for all those criminals. There don't need to be. You publicly gruesomely execute the first 100 or so you catch, and the practice of running a mesh node on your cell phone will fall so far out of fashion that the network breaks. Societal shortcomings cannot be fixed via tech alone. If you can't build a society resilient to authoritarianism in the first place, tech will not help you. It can be used to increase resilience, but that's far from fixing the problem by itself.