2 ms·
Headlines are almost never written by article authors. The corresponding chapter title from Smil's book is "Understanding Our Material World: The Four Pillars
by dredmorbius 5y ago
Headlines are almost never written by article authors.
The corresponding chapter title from Smil's book is "Understanding Our Material World: The Four Pillars of Modern Civilization".
Smil highlights their significance, irreplaceability, and that "the mass-scale production of all of them depends heavily on the combustion of fossil fuels, and that some of these fuels also supply feedstocks..."
The title as submitted seems to me to be fair: "The modern world can't exist without fossil fuels". Not that civilisation cannot, or that there isn't a possibility for replacing either the materials to a substantial degree, or the role of fossil fuels in their production, but that the result of doing so would leave us with something much at odds with the present parameters of the indistrialised, technological, high-energy, fossil-fuel dependent world we take as a given.
And to that extent, Smil's argument seems quite sound. You'll find similar viewpoints expressed both by strong critics of the fossil-fuel world, say, Richard Heinberg, or by apologists for the fossil fuel industry, such as Daniel Yergin. To the extent that they all agree that where we are now is a direct consequence of human utilisation of fossil fuels, I find no basis for disagreement.
The question is what the future implications and prospects are. Fossil-fuel defenders see an unlimited future for that resource. Critics think we need to eliminate all possible use immediately. Smil, as he himself notes, tends to cut a middle path in his arguments, though that's really not the most valuable aspect he brings to the discussion. It's an absolutely unsparing assessment and quantification of fossil fuels' role and where that leaves us in considering future options.
It's a philosophy which earns him strange bedfellows and frequent criticism from across the growth-sustainability spectrum.
And I think you'll find that the more you rely on Smil's actual text, rather than third-party headline summaries, the more his argument and facts cohere.
- ZeroGravitas 5y agoYou're just making it worse. Using mass produced PV power, which is the cheapest energy ever produced in history, and uses Quantum Physics effects to turn sunlight into electricity is in your opinion not 'industrialised, technological, high-energy'? How can you type that with a straight face in 2022? Oh, what's this one you slipped in at the end as if it belonged amongst those other words, "fossil-fuel dependant". Yeah, it's not that, because, it turns out, CO2 pollution is bad, even worse than all the other pollution they've caused. > And until all energies used to extract and process these materials come from renewable conversions, modern civilization will remain fundamentally dependent on the fossil fuels used in the production of these indispensable materials. No artificial intelligence designs, no apps, no claims of coming “dematerialization” will change that. What was he trying to convey with this paragraph that closes the article? I mean he's literally saying that until we get to net zero, then we will still be burning fossils fuels. Okay that's true I guess. But he sounds weirdly happy about it, like he's proved someone wrong about something. Maybe some person he's argued with that held the incredibly esoteric opinion that not renewable power, efficiency, insulation, and pricing in externalites was going to replace fossil fuels but 'artificial intelligence and apps'??? I mean that's an absurdly strawman position to attack, and I'm still not sure that Smil is even right about that. Technology is kind of a big deal in a lot of fields. AI gets used to enhance oil recovery for example. Is his closing argument literally "Old man yells at the cloud."?
- dredmorbius 5y agoYou thow up a bunch of targets, I'll limit myself to one: What was he trying to convey with this paragraph that closes the article? My read is that Smil is addressing a lot of hand-wavy assertions, again from across the BAU to halt-fossil-fuels-now spectrum, that there are easy ways out. A hard analysis based on quantities, properties, and available viable options says that no, there aren't easy ways out. AI alone won't save us, aps won't save us, unsubstantiated claims of dematerialisation won't save us. You could look to sources such as David MacKay, Sustainable Energy --- Without the Hot Air, who made a similarly hardboiled analysis for the UK. Given rates of energy consumption, touted measures like "unplug your electronics" are not enough. This isn't a problem that's solved by a bunch of small measures, but by a bunch of big measures. And the specific big measure here is get fossil fuels out of materials production. Most espeically of ammonia, plastics, steel, and concrete, though that itself is still just a start. You've expressed yourself largely, if not entirely coherently, in what you're against. What do you happen to be for? What goals and methods are you advocating, addressing what problems, specifically? You admitted above to not even reading the article. If you're going to discuss it at length, I'd hope you might fix that. And read closely, because his arguments really are nuanced. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31396935 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31396935