3 ms·
Personally, it's going to take a lot more failure for me to be convinced that averting ~4 million deaths was somehow misguided in the long-term. It's interestin
by whimsicalism 5y ago
Personally, it's going to take a lot more failure for me to be convinced that averting ~4 million deaths was somehow misguided in the long-term. It's interesting how much American media is trying to convince me otherwise as of the past few months.
- xyzzy123 5y agoAbout 10 million people die per year in China. At some point when thinking about the value of preventing death you need to introduce QALYs and then you need to think about the the duration, impact and breadth of lockdowns.
- whimsicalism 5y agoBut most of China has not been on lockdown for most of the pandemic. Most people have experienced less lockdown than in the US, albeit more intense when it is locked down. 4 million excess deaths is a ton no matter which way you look at it.
- xyzzy123 5y agoI agree and the strategy makes sense for China. Since it is now more or less endemic in the rest of the world it will be interesting to see how long they will maintain it. Ultimately zero covid is a thing you do to buy time for your healthcare system or for better vaccination coverage (or just to kick the can, maybe you get better tech). The 4 million deaths are inevitable unless you can maintain zero COVID forever or fundamentally change the situation for people who are very vulnerable to COVID-19. Preventing healthcare systems from being overwhelmed is a big factor. Otherwise you are just doing "accounting" to choose what year your excess deaths happen in, for political purposes. All that said, I'd always take an extra year over dying right now.
- whimsicalism 5y ago> fundamentally change the situation for people who are very vulnerable to COVID-19 the situation is already fundamentally changed in terms of treatment efficacy than what it was in 2020.
- xyzzy123 5y agoSo what's China waiting for (have 4 million deaths been averted by zero covid, or have they been delayed?). Is it still 4 million or not anymore? I guess they are delayed and will be averted in future? Maybe there will be further tech shift, or a healthcare surge? I suppose what I am trying to express is that zero covid is not a viable long-term strategy, it's a thing you do to buy time for your actual strategy, whatever that is.
- whimsicalism 5y agoChina has done an awful job vaccinating their population - this is the real story that is being undercovered by the media, rather than trying to convince me that somehow their massive lockdown success is somehow actually a failure.
- xyzzy123 5y agoFair call.
- spookthesunset 5y agoI suppose if you consider robbing people of their supposedly inalienable human rights is a “success”, then sure it’s a “success”. But believe it or not there are vastly more problems in the world than an extremely myopic focus on exactly one single respiratory virus to the literal exclusion of everything else including human rights. Serious I cannot get over how many people think this kind of response is ever justified. It is incredibly myopic thinking.
- pengaru 5y ago> China has done an awful job vaccinating their population - this is the real story that is being undercovered by the media According to [0] they've got 1,287,195,000 fully vaccinated, how is that an awful job? AIUI their failing is more along the lines of not using the mrna vaccines, but despite having a huge population they seem to have put jabs in most arms. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/COVID-19_vaccination_in_mainland_China https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/COVID-19_vaccination_in_mainla...
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- _fat_santa 5y ago> 4 million excess deaths is a ton no matter which way you look at it. You have to take the size of China into account, with 1.5B people, 4M is 2% of their population, it would be similar to 700k deaths in the US. While yes it is a ton, think about what effect the lockdowns will have. Some have speculated that more people have died thus far in Shanghai from the lockdowns than from Covid itself.
- whimsicalism 5y ago> Some have speculated that more people have died thus far in Shanghai from the lockdowns than from Covid itself. Which only shows how few covid deaths China has had.
- slaw 5y agoWhich shows how benign covid is.
- floxy 5y ago>with 1.5B people, 4M is 2% of their population Missed a decimal point: 0.267%
- greenglass 5y ago
- starky 5y agoThe reality at the moment is that practically everyone is going to get Covid at some point, Delta and now Omicron are just too transmissible. The only practical way for their zero Covid policy to work was to shut down all people coming into the country before Omicron arrived. Eventually they are going to have to move to a strategy of managing the virus to minimize the load on their medical system and prevent as many deaths as possible.
- whimsicalism 5y agoReality aside, there are millions of people in China who are alive today who would not be if they had followed the US' policy. It is far too early to be calling that a failure.
- spookthesunset 5y agoIt is a failure no matter what the outcome is. The end doesn't justify the means. You don’t get to rob people of their basic human rights. Ever. That is why they are called “human rights”. It means you don’t get to take them away.
- whimsicalism 5y agoDo we not routinely rob people of human rights when we go to war over things far smaller than 4 million lives?
- spookthesunset 5y agoIt doesn’t matter if it is for one person or 4 million. Human rights are human rights. Not just “sometimes” but always.
- swores 5y ago> You don’t get to rob people of their basic human rights. Ever. Pretty much every country on earth disagrees with such a binary statement, unless you can point me to one that doesn't have prisons. (I'm not saying prisons are wonderful or arguing for/against them here, nor saying that everyone in each country agrees with the current policies, just pointing out that all of our countries have laws that say you DO get to rob people of their basic human rights in certain situations.)
- spookthesunset 5y agoSo this response is okay? How can you say for sure this response even works? How sustainable is it? How is it not an absolute violation of inalienable human rights? How can you even call human rights “inalienable” when your government is willing to toss them out the window for some respiratory virus? Do people still think Covid is some kind of airborne Ebola or something? People have lost their minds over this. It is scary how willing humans are to commit an atrocity like what is happening in Shanghai when they are pumped full of nonstop over the top fear. Covid myopia is worse than Covid.
- chasd00 5y agoseverity of COVID or the proper response to it makes no difference. Zero Covid Policy is a _policy_ from the authorities. Changing it would mean admitting the authorities were wrong. That's not going to happen. human rights, health, spread of covid, none make any difference. The only thing that will make a difference is when political circumstances arise allowing the Zero Covid Policy to be modified without appearing as weakness.
- shadowpho 5y agoNone of our rights are absolute. The government can and does take them away. The question becomes more of what's a good reason to take them away, and saying no good reason is misguided.
- spookthesunset 5y agoI am hard pressed to think of any scenario where it is okay to strip people of inalienable human rights.