3 ms·
I have one of the other top comments where I argue that PoW is fundamentally unsustainable, and I assure you I did read the article. What the article is saying
by hn_throwaway_99 5y ago
I have one of the other top comments where I argue that PoW is fundamentally unsustainable, and I assure you I did read the article.
What the article is saying is that standard accounting practices might obfuscate miners true profitability over the lifetime of depreciable hardware. My argument is basically that, as I believe PoW is guaranteed to be unsustainable in the long run, all of the miners who are eventually left "holding the bag" when the music stops (and by holding the bag I mean have invested millions in mining equipment that is suddenly worthless) will be unprofitable at that point.
To argue it somewhat differently: systems like Ethereum have essentially come to the same conclusion I have, and will be phasing mining out altogether for PoS. The reason Bitcoin isn't doing that is because miners have considerable more power over the direction of the protocol. Which might be fine if PoW we're long-term sustainable, but it's not.
- SilasX 5y agoFair enough, but I think the parent was right to object that the comments were not talking about mining in the context of the depreciation accounting issue that the article focuses on, but just giving their hot take on mining in general, and doing the latter (when the article's focus is something else) makes the forum worse.