3 ms·
How does this square up with owners of private property having the ability to determine what they do with that private property? I mean, do these plaintiffs hav
by bediger4000 5y ago
How does this square up with owners of private property having the ability to determine what they do with that private property? I mean, do these plaintiffs have ownership in whatever social network?
Can spammers sue for being censored? What about bot herders?
I acknowledge that there's some tension in the various rights here, but the USA has rarely mandated that non-common-carriers and non-broadcast media carry particular speech. The old "fairness doctrine" is a notable exception, but we all cheered and waved the flag when that got disposed of.
This looks like a particular political faction having a tantrum about some media not going 100% their way. Back in the Reagan Years, when we all agreed to get rid of things like the fairness doctrine, restrictions on cross-ownership of forms of media and number of markets, one political faction cheered this and everyone else was told cry more, that market forces would take care of things.
Now that markets have shifted, we're seeing the faction that cheered removing barriers crying. I'm having a hard time mustering sympathy, but maybe that's because I'm old.
- krsrhe 5y agoYou’ve already thought about this more than the legislators who voted for this inane and unconstitutional law, who are just trying to “own the libs” for their voter base.
- rektide 5y agoIt doesnt. These people want everyone hosting things online to have to meet some ill defined mystical special status as "publishers" to be able to decide anything for themselves (with ill-defined requirements/consequences for declaring so) or be forced to host whatever trashy hoi-poi shows up & starts screaming hell. They want to insist platforms have no right to taste or discernment. Everyone who doesnt qualify for this weird made up non-legal term "publisher" is a "platform", which clearly to these folk (and no one else) implies a public utility subject to complete government regulation that far outstrips any rights of either the company, or the public, either of which maybe perhaps just would never vote with their feat/want to use a so called "platform" which insisted upon letting the shouting braying class into their feeds in the first place. It's bitter, it's shallow, it's insanely hyper-regulatory to tell people & companies they have to accept private intrusion to support some loudmouth shouting class's "right" to yell at all of us. This right to yell, this particular deranged psycho-world rendition of free speech, trumps all other rights anyone might have .
- bediger4000 5y agoI think that's why the Trump administration tried to distinguish between some "God Given" rights, and rights established some other way. Tensions between, say gun ownership, and private property (No Guns in the bar & grille rules) can be resolved their way.
- bediger4000 5y agoFor the olds among us, this Texas law strikes me as Stephen Boursy on a national scale. I also note that if this law has any effect at all, we'll get to see Elon Musk's Twitter experience the Heat Death of The Intolerance Paradox (https://rationalwiki.org/wiki/Paradox_of_tolerance https://rationalwiki.org/wiki/Paradox_of_tolerance)
- olliej 5y agoIt doesn't. Conservatives argue that all people should be required to publish anything produced by a conservative, as anything else is censorship. Conservatives, and this conservative law, are unequivocally opposed to free speech. This has been their position for decades, this law is just a new variation: forcing people to host speech against their will, rather than the traditional conservative censorship. Trump and similar "conservatives" got "censored" after repeatedly breaking the same rules against misinformation, false claims, etc. He could have avoided "censorship" by simply stopping those false and fraudulent claims, but he didn't and was subsequently dropped from multiple platforms - for the same reason anyone else would have been banned from those platforms. The problem is that conservative politicians have aggressively pushed for suppressing content that they don't like, and now they're seeing people suppress content that they actually like, and they want that to be people suppressing that to be illegal as well. I want to be very clear - to me there is a large difference between an actual conservative viewpoint and the "conservative" viewpoints that are getting legal protection. "conservative" seems to be false/misinformation rather than any position on social spending, taxes, etc