4 ms·
> I get that we can't open the flood gates. Actually: why not? This is how the US has operated for centuries after all, not to mention that treating immigrants
by mschuster91 5y ago
> I get that we can't open the flood gates.
Actually: why not? This is how the US has operated for centuries after all, not to mention that treating immigrants as a natural disaster ("flood") is a talking point established by the anti-immigrant far-right.
It's disturbing to see how the far right has managed to pervert the core of the identity of the US and the core values on which the EU was founded. Both the US and the EU are now, first and foremost, militarized borders to ward off the poor (that are mostly migrating due to the consequences of decades of our very own politics).
- grapeskin 5y agoSaying being against completely free and open immigration is a far right talking point just normalizes the far right. Most people are against completely open immigration. I’d rather people not think that it’s okay to be far right because anything else is pro-unlimited immigration. I don’t think imposing strict per-country quotas is really the solution, but I do think per-case scrutiny is a good idea. People bring their own culture and even their country’s problems with them when moving to another country. In modest numbers, people adapt to the home country and become indistinguishable from the locals after a few years. If it’s not limited to some extent, you end up with some unwilling to adapt in any way because they have a social bubble. With that, the problems many people sought to escape start becoming endemic in their new country. Before there’s some tirade about me being racist or “far right”, I’m neither. I’m an immigrant myself. I often avoid people from my home country because of the reasons described above.
- bradlys 5y ago> In modest numbers, people adapt to the home country and become indistinguishable from the locals after a few years. We must be in huge numbers territory then because definitely not the case in Bay Area or quite a few places I’ve been in the US. You can tell a local from non-local easily here… There’s almost no interest in assimilation - this cascades down even into the children who identify more with their parent’s home country and less with the country they were raised in. I’ve seen this attitude transcend multiple continents and generations - ones born in Africa from Asian parents migrate to Europe and then raise their own children in the USA but those kids still identify more heavily with their grandparents asian home country.
- mschuster91 5y ago> I’ve seen this attitude transcend multiple continents and generations - ones born in Africa from Asian parents migrate to Europe and then raise their own children in the USA but those kids still identify more heavily with their grandparents asian home country. Immigration is not one-sided (=the immigrants have to assimilate and that's it) like the far-right wants - the majority society also has to do their part in integrating immigrants. At least here in Europe, wherever you look immigrants face massive discrimination: they have it vastly harder, even after multiple generations, to find jobs [1] and housing [2] simply due to their migrant-heritage last name, they have a harder time in schools [3], in social life... it's no surprise that immigrants prefer to turn to their ethnic community as a result, furthering segregation. [1] https://www.zeit.de/politik/deutschland/2017-09/diskriminierungsbericht-jobcenter-auslaender-namen-studie https://www.zeit.de/politik/deutschland/2017-09/diskriminier... [2] https://www.sueddeutsche.de/leben/gesellschaft-auslaendischer-name-ist-bei-der-wohnungssuche-eine-huerde-dpa.urn-newsml-dpa-com-20090101-170622-99-952689 https://www.sueddeutsche.de/leben/gesellschaft-auslaendische... [3] https://www.zeit.de/gesellschaft/2018-08/rassismus-schule-metwo-diskriminierung-migrationshintergrund-namen https://www.zeit.de/gesellschaft/2018-08/rassismus-schule-me...
- grapeskin 5y agoIf a society is unable to accept and help assimilate immigrants, it seems it’s probably for the best that that society maintains a policy of strictly limited immigration. It’s very apparent neither the host country nor the immigrant benefits from moving there. It’d be ridiculous to say Bhutan needs to make efforts to help people assimilate, wouldn’t it? Most people have zero desire to adopt their culture (and thus don’t move there) and Bhutanese have zero desire to invite people into their country to reside if they’re not ready to adapt quickly (and thus don’t invite them). And I think that’s perfectly okay.
- bradlys 5y agoI agree it’s definitely not one sided but I’ve seen many people where I’m at very happy to accept people with a different background and culture but… the other side just has absolutely no interest. It’s very much stay within the family/community mentality. Which definitely goes against how Americans in general work (individualistic).
- opportune 5y agoI fully support immigration but it is possible for there to be too much, especially if other policies (like building housing) are not in sync. Look at Canada: they have proportionately more immigration per-year than the US and it's likely a large contributing factor to their housing crisis. Another thing to address is immigration being heavily concentrated in certain cities. I don't think people should be punished based on where they want to move to, or limited from immigrating to certain places instead of others, but the government should probably try to incentivize immigration to be more dispersed. That said, I think the US could definitely take in more skilled immigrants than we do now. Actually the majority of immigration to the US is not through skilled-labor programs but instead things like family unification. That's kind of silly.
- 3qz 5y agoFar right? Even Bernie Sanders thinks open borders is a Koch brothers proposal.
- johndfsgdgdfg 5y agoI find it interesting that how giving visa to foreign skilled workers issue somehow gets turned into open border discussion. That's quite a leap. We all know when people say "open border", it's not open border for a specific group of people. If you are not in that group, then it's too bad that no one cares about you. [1] [1] https://www.hindustantimes.com/world-news/us-senator-richard-j-durbin-under-attack-for-mocking-indians/story-nhsMgq3gDAHI3V7YpKuLPK.html https://www.hindustantimes.com/world-news/us-senator-richard...
- anamax 5y ago> This is how the US has operated for centuries after all Actually, the US was extremely restrictive on immigration from the late 20s until 1965. For most of the "centuries", the US wasn't an attractive destination, so legal restrictions were irrelevant. As the US became attractive, it went through waves of immigration- peaks and valleys.