3 ms·
This is a really excellent summary of just one among many sufficient reasons why bitcoin’s economics are fundamentally untethered from reality. Just the last po
by woodruffw 5y ago
This is a really excellent summary of just one among many sufficient reasons why bitcoin’s economics are fundamentally untethered from reality. Just the last points alone are condemning: no legitimate scheme in history has seen its executives cash out real money against such a small proportion of expected future earnings (in scrip).
- paulgb 5y agoThanks! FWIW, this is a follow up to an older article that covered a number of other issues with bitcoin's economics: https://paulbutler.org/2021/betting-against-bitcoin/ https://paulbutler.org/2021/betting-against-bitcoin/
- repomies69 5y agoThis article has really nothing to do with Bitcoin itself. It is just a story how stupid investors are pouring money to companies that have the Bitcoin in its name, without really going through the business at all. These companies have been ridiculously lousy investments. Borderline scams, when you look at executive compensation.
- catlifeonmars 5y ago> This article has really nothing to do with Bitcoin itself. It is just a story how stupid investors are pouring money to companies that have the Bitcoin in its name, without really going through the business at all. How do you figure? Much of the (featured) article is centered around hashrate to bitcoin production ratios over time. Literally one the central features of bitcoin.
- woodruffw 5y agoIt has "nothing to do with Bitcoin itself" in the sense that it's about the economics of mining, which has everything to do with bitcoin and its valuation.
- wallacoloo 5y agoit's about the economics of mining _using an external source of capital_. the more significant interaction is not between the ASICs and the bitcoin rewards, but the companies and their investors. in that sense, it's more accurate to say it has "everything to do with public stock markets". the author gives the oil analogy. the oil wells themselves have very similar economics to mining. it's the relationship between these similar operations and the investors which sets them apart more than the activity they're involved in.
- MuffinFlavored 5y agoGiven all of the "problems" surrounding BTC/crypto, when will they actually matter enough to make BTC/USD stop being $30k and go to $10k or $0? It dropped to $25k for like... what feels like a split second and people are still FOMOing into it, running it up to $30k (unless it's some kind of manipulation by whales to trap people's money... who really knows?)
- woodruffw 5y agoThis is the eternal problem with all scams: the music doesn't stop until it stops, and anybody with accurate information about when is unlikely to be on "your" side.
- mirceal 5y ago> bitcoin’s economics are fundamentally untethered from reality are they thought? What's untethered from reality is the understanding of how bitcoin work. Everyone wants to throw in 100$ and wake up to millions in 5 years. That just does not work anymore. One can model all costs involved when it comes to mining and can make a decision based on cost vs expected profit. Bitcoin (and cryptocurrencies) are not vending machines. The math to model this is harder and there is a lot more uncertainty. Can it be done? Probably. Will we have winners and losers in the mining game? of course.
- woodruffw 5y ago> are they thought? What's untethered from reality is the understanding of how bitcoin work. Everyone wants to throw in 100$ and wake up to millions in 5 years. That just does not work anymore. Economics is a social activity, not an abstract property of an asset or instrument. If the body of people using or interacting with bitcoin are fundamentally misguided about its economic properties, then the economics of bitcoin itself are fundamentally misguided ("unreal"). As I read it, the article's point was this: the economics behind large mining initiatives are bunk (it would be more profitable to simply buy bitcoin at current prices using the same capital). Simultaneously, it is true that bitcoin's mining activity is a supporting factor in its valuation. In other words, bitcoin is doing the economic equivalent of the toothpick trick: two supposedly supporting factors are actually mutually vulnerable to the same outside pressure (the availability of gullible investors, or lack thereof).