3 ms·
I'm not a huge Apple fan, but I totally agree. Private Relay has its faults, but it seems poised to push back against commercial mass surveillance, in a way tha
by mindslight 5y ago
I'm not a huge Apple fan, but I totally agree. Private Relay has its faults, but it seems poised to push back against commercial mass surveillance, in a way that niche usage of VPNs simply cannot dent. Now website operators have to ask themselves "Do I really want to hassle normies using iPhones with CAPTCHAs?". Traditionally, VPN/TOR users just bear that bullshit and pray websites do not alter the deal any further. But the mass market won't stand for that.
Long term we've yet to see what the evolution will end up being (Apple could publish a list of their exit nodes for websites to whitelist, causing Mullvad et al to be left out in the cold), but for now I'm cautiously optimistic.
- donmcronald 5y agoIt really sucks when someone thinks they may have been phished an you need to review login logs to assess things. VPNs suck too, but it’s easy to tell people not to use them for business connections. Something from Apple will be marketed as being amazing even if it’s a net negative for some users.
- dwaite 5y agoThe exit nodes are published, mostly to get incorporated into geo-ip tables.
- dixie_land 5y ago> poised to push back against commercial mass surveillance By consolidating all surveillance to Apple?
- mindslight 5y agoFor one, consolidation into just Apple is better than both websites and ISPs getting the surveillance data. People can also voluntarily choose to use Private Relay, whereas they can't generally make that choice for their last mile ISP (oligopoly) nor for the common surveillance systems that are used across websites (eg CAPTCHAs). For two, by hopefully making usage of VPNs more palatable to sites that are currently harassing what they perceive as the small segment of VPN users with blocks and CAPTCHAs. I admit that #2 is hopeful, and that we might just end up with those sites whitelisting Apple while continuing to hassle everyone else that wants to hide their IP. But I'd prefer to hope for now. Obviously the real long term answer is the development and adoption of secure protocols instead of centrally-named and centrally-served HTTPS/DNS, but that's orthogonal.