4 ms·
I should have quit when I saw they thought two examples of fistfights years apart were any evidence for their case, but I persisted. Science around rational ch
by pessimizer 5y ago
I should have quit when I saw they thought two examples of fistfights years apart were any evidence for their case, but I persisted.
Science around rational choices often tends to be premised by bizarre theories about what is obviously rational. People take free stuff because it often costs them nothing if it turns out to be a mistake. I can throw a free piece of chocolate in the trash if I don't like it. Throwing a 13¢ piece of chocolate away is like throwing away 13¢. This fake effect would disappear if you were given the choice between a free thing with no resale value and a cheap thing with high resale value, because the cheap thing now becomes profitable to throw away (or in this case sell.)
Also, the specifics about chocolate: I've never had a Lindt chocolate, I've had a Hershey's Kiss (they outsell Lindt in the US by multiple orders of magnitude.) I have no idea whether they're more expensive because they're better, or even because they're more expensive to manufacture or the chocolate is of higher quality grade - they could be more expensive because of the packaging. The fancy thing is often worse ("for a more refined palate") than the cheap thing. The Lindt is a risk that the Hershey's is not.
I'm going to skip free shipping, because, again, out of context it's difficult to evaluate the current value of products one hasn't bought recently. It's far easier to evaluate shipping costs. Also, shipping costs swamp other considerations when buying small, inexpensive things, which are most people's purchases. Also, this is a dumb survey ranking public concerns, and as always being used as a proxy for importance. [edit: just looked closer at the list of concerns they ranked free shipping above. They're all objectively worth less than free shipping to someone not in a hurry.]
The last (and the goal of the article) is the goofy attempt to transfer this badly argued effect to the consumption of online news. I read tons of online news that is awful, and is written by people who are bad, financed by other people who are bad. I wish I could take money away from them. I might be reading it to see what bad people are thinking, or I might even be reading it because I was suckered in by a deceptive or vague headline. While I want to know what bad people are thinking, I don't want to pay them for the privilege. Linkbait headlines steal my time and energy, and I not only don't want to pay them, I wish I could fine them.
- bowsamic 5y agoOff topic but here in Europe your chocolate example would be reversed: Lindt is the most pleasing and neutral milk chocolate, while Hersheys is considered an acquired taste
- henvic 5y agoWhat??? I don't think so.
- bowsamic 5y agoLindt is cheaper and more commonly eaten than Hersheys in Europe.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- henvic 5y agoWow. Is it really cheaper? I've been living in the Netherlands for two years, and never noticed it. Granted, I don't see Hershey's as much... and I've seen some times Lindt for way cheaper than I expected in the street market, but even so I had no idea...
- pessimizer 5y agoI'm sure Hershey's is worse. I don't buy it. But I wouldn't choose mystery chocolate over it, and by numbers in the US Lindt would be mystery chocolate to tens if not hundreds of millions, while everyone has had a Hershey's kiss. Imagine if in Europe Hershey's was marked as a fancy import. You would try it and distinctly taste vomit (butyric acid.) The proprietor at the chocolate store then tells you that's what's good about it.
- bowsamic 5y agoHersheys is indeed marked as a fancy import in Europe (as are most American snacks). They are sold at a premium EDIT How many more times are you going to edit your post?
- pessimizer 5y agoI just posted it. Probably half a dozen if it's anything like any of my others. > Hersheys is indeed marked as a fancy import in Europe (as are most American snacks). Then you don't have to imagine?
- hnbad 5y ago> I can throw a free piece of chocolate in the trash if I don't like it. Throwing a 13¢ piece of chocolate away is like throwing away 13¢. This is literally the sunk cost fallacy. There's nothing rational about sticking to an awful candy bar because you paid money for it vs throwing away the free one because you didn't. Lastly, online news consumption is very much suffering from this problem. Not just at the consumer level: think tanks funded by billionaires trying to affect political policy often provide ready-made "press info" and 24/7 contact details for arranging interviews or video calls whereas citing actual research means having to wade through research papers and trying to get a hold of busy scientists with little media training. In consequence you'll see a lot more media appearances of so-called "experts" doing PR for opaque think tanks than actual researchers qualified to give an "objective" view on an issue. It's not just that "free" media is bad, it's that it can often afford spending tons of money on refining its content in such a way to further its sponsors' political goals. And it's not an accident that most of these outlets espouse right-wing views rather than left-wing -- as progressive as some billionaires may allegedly be, consumer protection, workers' rights, wealth redistribution and democratizing political power are antithetical to the interests of all billionaires, so aside from some pet issues any actual left-wing politics that go beyond ineffective posturing are off the table if they want to maintain their positions of power and wealth. I'm not saying this means you should pay for news (or that paid news sources are always more neutral and factual -- arguably neutrality is an impossibility and not even necessarily desirable). I'm saying that asking people to pay for news means only those able and willing to pay for news will get access to them and everybody else will be preyed upon anyone who can afford to provide "news" for free.
- lupire 5y agoIt's not sunk cost if you refuse to buy the 13c chocolate as PP said.
- TheOtherHobbes 5y agoThe economic frame is entirely the wrong one for this. Economics is primarily about behaviour modification and "free" is one popular strategy for changing beliefs and behaviours. There are truly altruistic examples of "free", but they're much rarer than people think. With "free" news the cost is attention and a risk of having beliefs and behaviours influenced. Some people think that's a price worth paying. But this influence is covert, uncosted, and may even be presented in deliberately deceptive ways. So it's not seen for what it is. If the exchange value was spelled out there would be far fewer takers.