3 ms·
The brain has been optimized by nature to do it's job on as little energy as possible. Considering human brains use 20% of all the calories eaten, the most of
by londons_explore 5y ago
The brain has been optimized by nature to do it's job on as little energy as possible. Considering human brains use 20% of all the calories eaten, the most of any organ, there is likely substantial evolutionary pressure to make any changes which reduce energy use, all other things being equal.
For the sake of this argument, assume information is transmitted and processed in the brain with a binary signal from each neuron, ie. firing or not firing.
From that perspective, it's likely that firing a neuron (which uses a lot more energy than not firing a neuron) is a relatively unlikely event. Ie. if you made a version of the brain which worked in discrete timesteps, the vast vast vast majority of timesteps would not have a given neuron firing.
GPU's don't have such a limitation.
- ben_w 5y agoGPUs have their own limitations though, the 3090 given as an example needs active cooling.
- inkblotuniverse 5y agoDoesn't the brain, too? It's blood-cooled. Being too hot makes it hard to think.
- sseagull 5y agoOne of the theories of brain evolution is that it increased in size after bipedalism due to the need for better cooling when standing up (the so-called Radiator Theory)
- ben_w 5y agoI think so? The point I was trying to make is they’re both under pressure to reduce wasted energy use.
- SemanticStrengh 5y agoThe brain doesn't consume enough energy to cause relevant heating. And it's more CBF cooled than blood cooled IMO
- londons_explore 5y agoThe brain generates 20 watts of heat. I assume that to work well it needs to stay within about 1 degree of 37C, like most other organs. Even the best manmade heatsinks can't dissipate 20 watts and have less than one degree of heating. So I hypothesize that heating is relevant.