3 ms·
Eh, this is not great. It's funny that it links to Last Psychiatrist, an early version of modern bro Substacks whose main thing was calling you a narcissist and
by astrange 5y ago
Eh, this is not great. It's funny that it links to Last Psychiatrist, an early version of modern bro Substacks whose main thing was calling you a narcissist and constantly using rhetorical techniques like "I can tell you believe X, don't you? Huh? Huh? Well too bad it's actually Y!" and I'm like "but I don't believe X".
> The World Only Cares About What It Can Get from You
> What You Produce Does Not Have to Make Money, But It Does Have to Benefit People
I think these are conflicting…
> What You Are Inside Only Matters Because of What It Makes You Do
This one's true though.
- em-bee 5y agothere is no conflict. money is not the only benefit others can get from your work. if you run a soup kitchen it will certainly benefit people even if it doesn't make money. for me the whole purpose of life is to make a positive contribution to society. that can take many forms
- astrange 5y agoThe conflict is between “the world is just trying to rip you off” and “you should work to benefit society”.
- em-bee 5y agoThe World Only Cares About What It Can Get from You is not the same thing as the world is just trying to rip you off
- __B_B__ 5y agoYou're assuming "the world" and "society" to be harmonious concepts but in the worldview of the author they're not, and therefore, for him, there is no contradiction. You will see it in the way he describes working together to meet basic needs at the end of point 6. He says society is a system for meeting needs. The world presents a set of problems and society presents a set of solutions through it's behavioral demands. The rest of the article is just him rationalizing the demands and the repercussions of not meeting them but the underlying assertions he is making are these: That humans are not a part of the world. They are just in it and afflicted by the requirements of being there. That society is a social technology which partitions us off and functions to preserve us therein. Therefore any demands it makes or repercussions it inflicts are legitimate and bound up with your survival and that the sooner you get on board, the sooner you will be "a better person". Another dead give away is the fact that "better" is a completely subjective evaluation, but he kind of buries the lede on that one and goes on to talk about "society" in the singular, probably knowing full well that the reader will just project their own subjective definition.
- guerrilla 5y ago>> What You Are Inside Only Matters Because of What It Makes You Do > This one's true though No, it's also false. The only reason you do anything is to feel a certain way. If being or believing you are X makes you feel what you want, then mission accompolished. What you are on the inside is the only thing that can matter to you, whether it requires action to accomplish or not.
- astrange 5y agoImposing your own meanings on everything without letting the outside world participate can work for a while. But if there was a boulder falling on you then I don't think it'd really help; it's going to win and you're going to end up unhappy about it. (That's why if you're going to read some online guy's made up philosophy blog, it should be meaningness.com.)
- guerrilla 5y agoYou misunderstood what I wrote. I said nothing about meaning. What I said is that the only thing that can possibly matter to you is how you feel. Talk of anything else is bullshit bordering on religion.