3 ms·
This play of locking all Russia's valuable commodities in, with the only out being in the direction of China, seems risky. It relies on Russia making a series o
by roenxi 5y ago
This play of locking all Russia's valuable commodities in, with the only out being in the direction of China, seems risky. It relies on Russia making a series of catastrophic economic mistakes (although, parenthetically, that is an outcome backed by history). The obvious way this plays out is that Russia's economy snaps back really quickly and a Russia-China trade corridor starts firming up because there are no other options. Then they both benefit from it.
It isn't yet so clear that the weak links in finance can be so easily weaponised against a state by foreign powers. Economic warfare always seems to me to be a series of self inflicted wounds. It would be interesting (and terrifying) to see whether these attacks would work against a liberal economy.
- usernomdeguerre 5y agoPart of the weakness is that 'warfare' is probably not the best way to conceptualize it. In actual warfare I end someone's life and they do not wake up the next day to fight me, or I wound them to a similar outcome. In 'economic' warfare I still wake up the next day when you freeze all my assets, or stop sending me my goods, or stop servicing my departments. It's just a fundamentally different dynamic. And I agree, it's not clear. That said, I do think these actions were necessary, geopolitically. My tangential opinion is that there have been two implementations of Capitalism in conflict the past decades, Western and Chinese. It's what I think has spurned the capital booms in each and acted as the foundational fabric for lots of cultural and political skirmishes. But in this environment China could not necessarily be seen in direct competition and vice versa. Here, Russia acted as a sort of European conduit for China's geopolitical aims and cultural propaganda. These western economic actions now help to more clearly split the two implementations in order to, I speculate, give the Western system time to breathe and consolidate. Lick its wounds. Whether it meets its goals, i'm skeptical, but I do believe it's rational even if it causes Russia to re-orient rather than collapse. It may also be beneficial as a warning to smaller nations looking to try and keep a foot in both, if Russia can't do it...
- zmgsabst 5y agoTwo thoughts: 1. I believe Russia also has India as a trading partner, so a resource rich country has access to over half the world’s population — they’ll figure it out. 2. I believe that China has already weaponized finance against the US, from funding organizations at universities to coercing policies at major companies, eg Disney and WarnerMedia, to demanding IP transfers from anyone who wants to do business there. My understanding is that the US was woefully unprepared for a one-way open market and the disruptions that would bring to their economy.
- sircastor 5y ago> My understanding is that the US was woefully unprepared for a one-way open market and the disruptions that would bring to their economy. Sure - we're attached to the idea that the market will self-manage all this stuff, and it's antithetical to the US' culture that a government would directly interfere with it.
- blihp 5y agoDon't blame China for our broken systems of corporate governance.[1] It was people on our end, who actually had the leverage in these transactions, who decided it was a good idea to exchange long term competitive advantage for a few years of record profits followed by bankruptcy. (for many of them) All China did was weaponize our greed against us. [1] It's also worth noting that government(s) played their part in facilitating much of this by not saying 'no' to some of these deals.
- formerkrogemp 5y agoIf a man gives another a knife, asks to be stabbed, and is stabbed. Do we blame the knife, the asking man, or the opportunist?
- paulryanrogers 5y agoNot sure this analogy accomplishes what you intend. In such a case the opportunist (China?) is still committing assault and possibly murder. The victim (USA?) is likely joking, trying to show off, mentally unwell, or already suffering so much it would be mercy. Anyway, it appears you're trying to say the USA should realize it was asking to be exploited because they were too short-sighted or naive.
- blihp 5y agoIt might be more apropos to look at it as a con man thinks he spots a mark, runs his con but gets conned himself. At every step he can see the tables are being turned and there are multiple opportunities to walk away, as it's a long con. However, the instigating con man's greed won't allow for it. He then cries out 'that's not fair... he conned me!' There are no innocent victims in this story.
- Etheryte 5y agoThis might make sense if we were talking about the same resources being distributed in different ways, however this is not the case in many fields. Gas is a good example, Russia sells to Europe and China from completely different wells. It is not the case that when Europe stops buying, they can just sell the same gas to China. It's not economically feasible to transfer all the way across Siberia, they simply end up selling less.
- roenxi 5y agoThe Chinese are known for executing crazy big infrastructure projects quickly and well. That energy is valuable. Now maybe shipping gas across Siberia is impossible. But if it isn't and 1 unusually clever Asian out of a population of ~2 billion figures out how to do it economically then this series of forcing moves might look really silly in hindsight.
- Atatator 5y agoWhere this myth about "shipping gas across Siberia is impossible" comes from? Projects like Yamal LNG https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yamal_LNG https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Yamal_LNG are already operational. On top of that Chinese gas consumers are not dramatically further away than consumers in western Europe - it's only matter of 2-3 years to build a pipeline to connect them.