5 ms·
"Is that really what's holding manufacturing back here?" While I also have various ideological preconceptions about the source of the economic problems in the
by jerf 15y ago
"Is that really what's holding manufacturing back here?"
While I also have various ideological preconceptions about the source of the economic problems in the US and elsewhere, I would observe that when someone like the CEO of Apple is expressing an opinion about what makes a factory easier to open in China than in the US, someone who has actually been the guy-who-can-say-yes to actual factories for which that decision was actually made, it's probably worth listening to that opinion. Even if you can somehow prove he's objectively wrong on the merits, his perception would still be a useful data point.
On the other hand I wouldn't expect any particular insight into our school problems from him, beyond what any reasonably skilled businessman could present.
- rayiner 15y agoJobs was a businessman, not an economist. There is a good reason regulation makes it more expensive to open factories in the US: our regulations force companies to internalize the negative externalities their businesses create. China effectively subsidizes industry by forcing its citizens to bear the costs of pollution, injuries, etc, inherent in such activities. US regulation forces companies to bear some of these costs (hardly all of them). In its retrospective study on the 1970 Clean Air Act, the EPA estimated that the benefit of pollution control over the 20 year period was on the order of $22 trillion. Relative to the "so-called 'no-control' case, an additional 205,000 Americans would have died prematurely and millions more would have suffered illnesses ranging from mild respiratory symptoms to heart disease, chronic bronchitis, asthma attacks, and other severe respiratory problems... the lack of Clean Air Act controls on the use of leaded gasoline would have resulted in major increases in child IQ loss and adult hypertension, heart disease, and stroke." Meanwhile, "the actual costs of achieving the pollution reductions observed over the 20 year period were $523 billion, a small fraction of the estimated monetary benefits." What's good for business isn't necessarily good for the economy. The things that businessmen push for: deregulation, limitations on tort liability, etc, create more in costs to society then they create in benefits to businesses. Indeed, our measurements of things like GDP are so fundamentally flawed that they encourage politicians to adopt such measures. If a factory's poisonous emissions causes you to have lung problems, that doesn't count against GDP, but when you seek medical attention for those problems GDP goes up!
- anamax 15y ago> In its retrospective study on the 1970 Clean Air Act, the EPA estimated that the benefit of pollution control over the 20 year period was on the order of $22 trillion. $22T/20 years is over $1T/year. US GDP in 1990 was under $6T. US GDP in 1970 was just over $1T. > the lack of Clean Air Act controls on the use of leaded gasoline would have resulted in major increases in child IQ loss Oh really? Why would leaded gas in 1980 cause more problems than leaded gas in 1950? > Meanwhile, "the actual costs of achieving the pollution reductions observed over the 20 year period were $523 billion, a small fraction of the estimated monetary benefits." Just as the benefits are not limited to the money not spent on medical care, the money spent on pollution controls are not the only costs.
- redcap 15y ago> Why would leaded gas in 1980 cause more problems than leaded gas in 1950? Larger population and rising wages lead to more cars on the roads and hence more pollution?
- smithian 15y agoGDP does not account for the externalities that the study took into account.
- anamax 15y ago> GDP does not account for the externalities that the study took into account. Externality estimates and valuations are notorious for reflecting the biases of the estimators. Estimates that are a large fraction of GDP are very suspicious. Do you seriously believe that the clean air act "saved" 1/6th of the US economy?
- smithian 15y agoI hear what you are saying, but I think you're mixing units. Since the study is accounting for things that are not accounted for in GDP, It doesn't seem to make much sense to compare the dollar figure reached in terms of GDP. If GDP devalues human health as part of its basic assumptions, an analysis that does not devalue human health will come to different numbers. It's almost a tautology.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- jduran 15y agois that an appeal to authority
- philwelch 15y agoIt's worth noting that during the Macintosh and NeXT days, Steve was fanatical about building computer factories in California. It was probably a lot of very hard-learned lessons that got him to accept Apple's arrangement with Foxconn.