7 ms·
This, and the app-store debacle, is the kind of stuff that makes me think that Apple isn't in it for the long haul. Why doesn't MacOSX ship with native GTK? An
by mseebach 18y ago
This, and the app-store debacle, is the kind of stuff that makes me think that Apple isn't in it for the long haul.
Why doesn't MacOSX ship with native GTK? And Qt? Why hasn't OpenOffice worked seamlessly from day 1? Or at least day 5? Why don't Apple embrace the huge community that worships their products, instead of becoming the next Microsoft? What have they got to loose?
If getting my favourite Linux apps to run on my MacBook had bees as easy as apt-get, heck, even as easy as under Windows, I'd still use Mac OS X.. now it's running Kubuntu, and I'm regretting not getting a ThinkPad.
I'm disappointed, I REALLY wanted to like MacOSX.
- zain 18y agoSounds like you REALLY wanted MacOSX to be Linux.
- j2d2 18y agoIt also sounds like he REALLY isn't apple's market anyway.
- nailer 18y agoMost software developers want that - or, more specifically, all the benefits of Linux with mainstream hardware and application support. What's wrong with that?
- wmf 18y agoIs GTK really a benefit compared to Cocoa?
- Niten 18y agoYeah, Cocoa is hot and all, but just try getting that nice shiny Cocoa app of yours running on all three of OS X, Linux, and Windows...
- wmf 18y agoIf you want to write a cross-platform app, I argue that GTK is still not a very good solution. I wonder how Adobe is progressing with their cross-platform Cocoa-based CS5.
- stcredzero 18y agoYou'd probably be better off with wxWidgets or Qt than GTK.
- orib 18y agoUh, What? Mainstream hardware support from OSX? Not only does it have poor support for common hardware, it has artificially restricted support. What it does support, it supports reasonably well, but that hardly qualifies OSX as a system that supports mainstream hardware.
- tlrobinson 18y agoOS X does provide most of the benefits of Linux, except for large portions of the OS being closed source. You get a terminal with bash or whatever shell you wish, which works great (none of the Cygwin crap). You can compile most non-GUI Linux apps for OS X (and many GUI ones). Etc. I rarely run into things that I can do on Linux that I can't do on OS X.
- mseebach 18y agoNo. But the other threads in this discussion are about Gaim/Pidgin and Gimp. Why has it been a dead-simple 5-minute thing to install those apps on Windows for years, but still tricky on MacOSX? Why did it take, what 7 years, from the launch and immediate celebration of OSX, to get native GTK? So, without knowing the answer to the above, I guess you could say I'd like it to be more like Windows (ducks).
- ii 18y agoNative GTK is not the Apple problem. GTK developers could use Mac application paradigms instead of Windows's and embrace GNUStep/Objective C for GIMP and GNOME instead of implementing their own toolkit. They made the choice of going Windows-like way, not Apple. That's the reason of why "on Windows for years, but still tricky on MacOSX".
- andrewf 18y agoVolunteer time/interest.. not enough people want to scratch the itch. The need for multiple binaries - (OS X 10.4/10.5) x (PowerPC/Intel) x (32/64 bit, maybe) - is also a pain. You can cross build, and you can munge multiple builds into a "universal binary", but it's not obvious enough to avoid the same discussions happening on every open source project's mailing list.
- Zev 18y agoBecause Mac OS X has Cocoa/Aqua for its UI instead of GTK/Gnome or QT/KDE. If you want GTK/Gnome or QT/KDE, use Linux. If you want Cocoa/Aqua, use Mac OS X. If you looked at something like MacPorts or Fink, you would see that installing $randomPackage is as simple as "sudo (fink/port) install packagename" Oh, and last i checked, NeoOffice worked fine (And OpenOffice is finally getting around to finishing a native Mac port). So, um, it has been supported since day one. If you bothered searching and finding it. But it's not Apple's fault OO.o doesn't advertise their product in a way to get on your radar.
- nailer 18y ago> If you looked at something like MacPorts or Fink, you would see that installing $randomPackage is as simple as "sudo (fink/port) install packagename" We both know the amount of packages available in Fink pales in comparison to the average Linux distribution. To state otherwise is disingenuous.
- dzorz 18y agoI wouldn't say it pales. OK, this is kind of like comparing apples and oranges, but still: Leopard: port list | wc -l 5038 Tiger: fink list | wc -l 8111 Ubuntu 8.04: apt-cache pkgnames | wc -l 33720 So the number of packages is 5-6x smaller, but most common/useful packages are present. Also you should take into account that many packages present in ubuntu don't mean anything in OS X. And for example there are for example tons of python packages in Ubuntu, all/most of which can be easily installed through easy_install :-) Let's compare how up to date the packages are: port info cmake cmake 2.6.1, devel/cmake (Variants: universal) ... apt-cache show cmake ... Version: 2.4.7-1build1 ... So based on sample of 1 package we can see that MacPorts is more up to date than Ubuntu. Joking aside, cmake really matters to me...
- Niten 18y agoNot to mention that both Fink and (to a lesser extent, lately) MacPorts tend to crap out on every fourth or fifth package you ask them to install...
- 18y ago
- trezor 18y agoUhm... So why did you get a Mac again? I don't even have a Mac, but if all I wanted to do was run Linux shit (and you clearly did), I'd pick up a cheap Dell laptop instead of overpriced Mac hardware.
- tsuraan 18y agomacports gives OSX a decent enough package management system; port install ocaml, port install erlang, what more could you ask for? I guess using system libraries would be a bonus, but it's really quite usable as-is.
- lg 18y agothe erlang port was broken for a while, actually...don't know if that's still the case, but anyway it's not hard to build from source.
- michaelneale 18y ago>Why don't Apple embrace the huge community that worships their products, instead of becoming the next Microsoft? What have they got to loose? I think for Shareholder Value, they DO want to be the next Microsoft. Technically uninteresting but raking it in for generations.
- krschultz 18y agoThe reason Apple is very successful is because there are few choices. A lot of hardcore hackers don't get this, but people don't like a lot of choices, and they especially like uniformity and consistency. I like that for my Ubuntu setup, all the apps have the same look and feel whether it be GTK or KDE, I keep them separate. I like that for Mac OS X they all have a common look and feel. I don't like that on Windows everything looks different. So by bringing in all this extra crap, they loose that consistent look and feel, and that is basically what separates their platform to most people. They have a lot to loose.