4 ms·
I have a hard time believing that while the current status quo is suboptimal, there's some little known compounds that are, as you say, revolutionary and with l
by sph 5y ago
I have a hard time believing that while the current status quo is suboptimal, there's some little known compounds that are, as you say, revolutionary and with little side effects. Pharmacological research is a constantly moving target, there is no scientific nor economic reason that a supposedly "perfect" remedy remains unknown. Sounds too much like thinly veiled conspiracy, or perhaps they're not as perfect as you're suggesting.
That said, it's not my area of competence, so if you know _why_ opipramol and guanfacine are ignored compared to benzos and other anxiolytic, you should probably explain that.
EDIT: re: guanfacine, I know it's a second-line treatment for ADHD, it was previously used to treat hypertension, but this is the first time I hear it might be applicable as an anxiolytic. It does certainly have side effects, though not as bad as being neurodegenerative like benzodiazepines.
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Guanfacine https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Guanfacine
- gavinray 5y agoI have personal experience with Guanfacine (and Clonidine), beta blockers (Propanolol/Labetalol), Etifoxine, Phenibut, and a myriad of benzos. Long history of RX for anxiety disorders, which I eventually tapered off of and quit due to dependence. Can attest to Etifoxine being effective without side effects, guanfacine and clonidine being mildly effective. Beta blockers never did much for me but YMMV.
- ineedasername 5y agoAfter all of those, what did you settle on for managing anxiety long term? Was it the Etifoxine?
- gavinray 5y agoI keep Etifoxine on hand for acute panic attacks and take l-Theanine + Ashwagandha daily for general anxiety. The over-the-counter supplements don't do much but it's better than nothing.
- SemanticStrengh 5y agodo you think it is sustainable to take etifoxine daily or does it leads to addiction/tolerance?
- gavinray 5y agoI can't give anecdotal evidence on daily use because I've not used it in that way, but between medical literature and my own experiences my guess would be that you could take it daily. Dependence-causing anxiety medication generally had noticeable psychoactive effects. EG, Phenibut, benzos, etc. I wasn't sure if it did anything at first because I can't notice any kind of headspace change. But sure enough, if I have anxiety and feel like I might get a panic attack, taking ~100mg makes the anxiety subside. I've also had really good experiences with Buspirone, 10mg twice daily.
- makeitdouble 5y agoOn the inertia and the gap between what the research/newest drugs and what is prescribed day to day: it is very real. And there’s tons of reasons for that, ranging from: - doctors that cling to the treatment they know to work (“the devil you know”) - sheer lack of knowledge (not their speciality so they’re not up to date by a long shot) - waiting for a few more years to have long term real world data - pharma companies effectively bribing them by any means so they don’t look elsewhere
- loceng 5y ago- propaganda put out by competing pharma companies to smear newer medications or create distrust of them - pharma companies who spend more to get the lion's share of ad time keep their brand at the forefront of consumers, consumers then ask for those medications and then don't know about alternatives because they've been drowned out - arguably some of most effective drugs have been illegal the past 40+ years as part of the "war on drugs" (did pharma industry help make those illegal?): marijuana, psilocybin/DMT, MDMA, and even cocaine will knock people out of a depression - where it could be taken weekly or less (arguably potentially more addictive than other medications, but SSRIs with severe withdrawal symptom is arguably equivalent to addiction, the aversion to the withdrawal symptoms) - but pharma can't patent any of those, so they can't gain exclusive rights to a brand they advertise to manipulate people to buy or trust their brand over something else (so patented drugs can captured more revenue and have more profit to pay more for ad time to drown out cheaper, more effective competitors). - etc.
- PragmaticPulp 5y ago> I have a hard time believing that while the current status quo is suboptimal, there's some little known compounds that are, as you say, revolutionary and with little side effects. Your suspicions are correct. The parent comment is an example of a trend among people who know just enough about pharmacology to be dangerous: Exaggerating the benefits of less popular medications while demonizing mainstream medications. Add a dose of conspiracy theory ("pharmaceutical industrial complex") and it's a recipe for contrarian exaggeration. The parent comment strangely missed the actual mainstream, effective treatments for anxiety: SSRIs and Buspirone are widely used for long-term anxiety treatment with significant success. They’re not perfect and you can find horror stories if you search the Internet long enough, but people tend to get fooled into thinking mainstream medications are worse than obscure ones because mainstream medications will naturally have a higher absolute number of negative reviews online than rarely-prescribed medications. In practice, it would be rare for a doctor in the United States to prescribes benzos as a first-line and long-term treatment for chronic anxiety. They are prescribed for panic attacks and short-term anxiety (e.g. a difficult court case with an end date) but SSRIs are the mainstream treatment.
- loceng 5y agoYou should probably read about the pharmaceutical industrial complex to balance out your wildly biased and one-sided, unbalanced perspective. Are you honestly going to claim that the many multi-billion dollar pharmaceutical industry doesn't have a financial incentive to lead people toward 1) daily use medications that gives the industry a monthly recurring revenue stream, 2) where many people on them long-term because many of them have severe withdrawal symptoms so they are very hard to get off of? And then something like 80% of ad revenue of mainstream media in the US comes from the pharma industry - so how do you suppose that influences what news and narratives are shared or allowed to be shared to the majority of a population on the mainstream-mass media channels? You conveniently also forgot to mention that SSRIs, for example, actually increase the rate of suicide (along with suicidal ideation) - so you're more likely to kill yourself if you take them then if you didn't take them; that is from their clinical trials. It's the elephant in the room that's been mostly suppressed from conversation for some reason, somehow - probably in large part look at my previous paragraph for one mechanism used. Are you also claiming then you know "more than just enough about pharmacology" in order to give a more credible response? Or are you perhaps arrogant thinking you're more competent to respond - but perhaps instead you're just indoctrinated into a biased perspective? Do you work in the medical profession, perhaps even one that prescribe medications? Consumers are bombarded by propaganda, and professionals even more so. In reality you probably don't actually have any idea what level of knowledge nor experience the person you're responding to, saying that their response is dangerous. Reality is more complex than you're currently aware of.