4 ms·
There are lots of crucial goods, right? I don't see how the government could stockpile all of them. And infant formula is only good for a couple years, right?
by bee_rider 5y ago
There are lots of crucial goods, right? I don't see how the government could stockpile all of them. And infant formula is only good for a couple years, right? So it would have to be an ongoing project to keep it good. n95s eventually degrade, but I believe they've got a much longer shelf-life.
Also, masks become unusually important when there's an epidemic, so we wouldn't expect the economy to have capacity to deal with that. We should expect that in a well balanced economy, the supply of baby formula should basically match the demand. It seems to me that instead of government stockpiles (since they can't stockpile everything and don't know what will be needed) it would make more sense to monitor the market more closely and keep tabs on inventory... and, actually, it is pretty surprising that they didn't catch this before it became an issue.
- alasdair_ 5y agoStockpile to a point and then regularly auction off things that are nearing end of life (or, in the case of baby formula that is heavily provided by state programs, just give it to the states to distribute). We have national oil reserves. Having reserves of other essential assets seems fine to me, especially in the case where there are few substitute goods.
- kareemsabri 5y agoWhy is that necessary when it appears there is sufficient global supply and regulations are causing it to be unavailable to the US market? The issue isn't a shortage of production, as far as I can tell. And even if there were, a stockpile only absorbs a temporary shortage. A strong industry with many producers is what the government should desire, I imagine.
- alasdair_ 5y agoIt makes sense from a national defense perspective to have reasonable stockpiles of essential goods.
- kareemsabri 5y agoI'm not a national defense expert, but it seems to make sense to ensure your country can get access to essential goods. One possible solution would be stockpiling them. Another would be maintaining the capacity either in the state or the private sector to acquire or manufacture them rapidly. It feels like hindsight 20/20 to say "why didn't the government have a stockpile of [thing we had a shortage of]". It appears to me the policy here led to essentially a single point of failure or low optionality for the market to get the product. Not clear stockpiling is the answer to that problem.
- azemetre 5y agoIn our current political climate, people would attack this during the good times as wasteful and not a good use of money. I agree with you, but we have a party in this country that doesn't think good governance is a virtue.
- Consultant32452 5y agoIt's literally impossible to stockpile all essential goods.
- bee_rider 5y agoI was actually thinking of something like that as well. If nothing else, the cast-offs from a stockpiling program could be a nice social welfare program.
- kevin_thibedeau 5y ago> n95s eventually degrade Only the ones that depend on an electrostatic spray to assist filtration.