6 ms·
Reason missed the key point. Well over half of US infant formula is paid for by welfare programs. Those have per-state monopolies awarded by competitive bidding
by Animats 5y ago
Reason missed the key point. Well over half of US infant formula is paid for by welfare programs. Those have per-state monopolies awarded by competitive bidding. So it's not an ordinary consumer product.[1]
[1] https://naldc.nal.usda.gov/download/39616/PDF https://naldc.nal.usda.gov/download/39616/PDF
- ConceptJunkie 5y agoSeems to me that still falls under the umbrella of "bad government policy". So, you could say bad government policy doesn't explain the whole problem. There's also bad government policy.
- lupire 5y agoThis is Reason. Ther good government policy would be doing nothing, which wouldn't help poor families get formula either. There's a case to be made about fine-tuning things in some ways as the article suggests, but it's still gross to frame this under the "government is bad" banner as Reason does. This concern is especially relevant in the baby formula space, where Nestle killed thousands of babies by pushing their mothers off breast milk onto unreliably supplied formula.
- barry-cotter 5y ago> This is Reason. Ther good government policy would be doing nothing, which wouldn't help poor families get formula either. Their good government policy would be to give the poor families money. This would have the great side effect of getting rid of the idiotic state by state monopolies but the justification is the same as every other tied benefit. This is stupid. Give people the money and let them decide what to spend it on. They have the information and motivation.
- doyouevensunbro 5y agoI have zero faith that once the government programs are stopped the second step of giving money to the poor would actually happen.
- russellendicott 5y agoAs a parent of a newborn, none of the mothers we talk to actually want to breastfeed. Breastfeeding is a huge PITA for women, especially if they work. Despite the advice to breastfeed for 2 years it's rare if a mother lasts 6 months. I guess you could argue that if formula wasn't an option then mothers would _have_ to breastfeed but then they couldn't work. My point is that formula is a very attractive option for women so it's not like Nestle is holding a gun to their head. It's just a product they know people will buy.
- giraffe_lady 5y agoThe nestle thing is referring to a specific set of events it sounds like you might not be aware fully of. "Thousands" is a dramatically conservative understatement and while they didn't literally hold a gun to anyone's head (that I'm aware of, in this case,,,) they did do things like have reps dress as nurses and advise impoverished illiterate mothers that they needed to use formula knowing it would be received as trustworthy medical advice. I may not be representing it that well but if anything because I'm trying to carefully control my tone and am downplaying the harm knowingly caused. There are lot of different pressures on people and a lot of reasons why they might choose not to breastfeed but the nestle thing is not really that and is as clear cut evil as it gets really go check it out.
- watwut 5y agoIt is more that you live in an anti brestfeed bubble then anything else. 57.6 percent of mothers breastfeed after 6 months. That is not rare, that is majority. Also, women who stay with baby for few months or weeks arw no rarity - and breastfeeding is significantly easier in that setup. Not everyone can or find it comfortable, but it is not that much PITA in median.
- MandieD 5y agoThat’s one of the many reasons I’m glad that I live in, and had my kid in, Germany. The year I was off work wasn’t paid anywhere near my pre-baby post-tax salary (those payments are capped at 1800 EUR/mo), but because they cover up to 65% of previous net, and there are very strong legal protections for your job, taking that year is pretty much expected, followed on by a further two years part-time. That said, I was also amazed at how reasonably-priced formula is here. I had other issues and ended up supplementing for awhile, and it really wouldn’t have been that big a deal - about 2-3 EUR/day using Hipp (midrange) powder if we’d had to feed it exclusively.
- bradleybuda 5y ago> Their good government policy would be doing nothing, which wouldn't help poor families get formula either. Sure it would. If baby formula were unregulated the price would be lower - this is obvious on its face. It would also (probably) be riskier, and the trade-off might not be worth it, but it would be cheaper. We systematically underestimate how much poverty is worsened by regulation that increase the prices and/or reduces the availability of goods. The left has finally gotten religion here on housing ("YIMBY" just means "deregulate construction in order to drive down prices") so maybe there's hope.
- fragmede 5y agoWe are all worsened if the cheap baby formula has a 20% chance of killing your baby.
- sorethescore 5y agoCheaper but deadlier doesn't sound like a very good tradeoff when talking about infants.
- CPLX 5y ago> If baby formula were unregulated the price would be lower - this is obvious on its face This isn’t obvious at all. One steady state condition that occurs without regulation is a predatory monopoly and price gouging. And we aren’t even talking about fraudulent or harmful products reaching the market. No regulation just leads to a mafia state. Nobody wants it.
- specialist 5y agoWhat are some examples of CPG unregulated less expensive products?
- anonuser123456 5y ago>This is Reason. Ther good government policy would be doing nothing, which wouldn't help poor families get formula either. This is not quite true. There are plenty of libertarian thinkers that would be perfectly happy just cutting checks to poor people and letting them procure what the need.
- puffoflogic 5y agoIt's a good thing our leftist betters are always around to remind us that every time this has been tried, it has resulted in baby formula manufacturers switching to bottling pure toxic waste and killing millions of babies.
- kareemsabri 5y agoHow does that affect retailers being unable to get supply?
- cperciva 5y agoIt increases demand for that particular brand, but manufacturers don't want to invest in increasing their production levels in case they don't win the contract for the next round.
- ClumsyPilot 5y agoSo its not all government's fault
- mcguire 5y agoIt's always the government's fault.
- ClumsyPilot 5y agoEven if the government was not involved, it was government's fault for not being involved. Just look at the sister thread 'why didn't government stockpile my freemarket products for me'
- throwaway0a5e 5y agoOnly when the government specifies how things must be done. You break it you bought it.
- ClumsyPilot 5y agoSo we have the entire globalised supply chain of fast fashion, every time counterfeit goods or clothing made by slave labour is discovered, which corporation owns up?
- mcguire 5y agoDo you remember when some Chinese baby formula producers were including melamine powder to increase their apparent protein content, or was that before you were born?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- samsonradu 5y agoIt’s all explained here: https://mattstoller.substack.com/p/big-bottle-the-baby-formula-nightmare?s=r https://mattstoller.substack.com/p/big-bottle-the-baby-formu...
- robocat 5y agoMatt says ‘According to Healthy Babies Bright Futures, baby formula made by the big guys in the U.S. is full of dangerous brain-altering heavy metals. HBBF tested thirteen different baby formulas, and every single one had “detectable levels of arsenic, cadmium, lead and/or mercury,” which are all considered to be neurotoxic, interfering with brain development and “causing permanent IQ reductions in children.”’. Rather unscientific heavy breathing about heavy metals, since some level must exist in all foods. Matt even links to a mommyhood101.com article in the above, which I guess is the secondary source for his opinion? The question is: what are reasonable limits to exposure for babies? For example, what are the EU limits for baby formula? Here is the original “paper”: https://www.healthybabyfood.org/sites/healthybabyfoods.org/files/2019-10/BabyFoodReport_FULLREPORT_ENGLISH_R5b.pdf https://www.healthybabyfood.org/sites/healthybabyfoods.org/f... Healthy Babies Bright Futures (HBBF) paid laboratories to measure amounts, but superficially their analysis looks rather poor I think. Any good links to scientific critiques of their analysis?
- mherdeg 5y ago> The question is: what are reasonable limits to exposure for babies? For example, what are the EU limits for baby formula? Maybe the question I'd ask is "if you sample milk from 100 different human volunteers, what fraction of the samples also contain detectable levels of arsenic, cadmium, lead and/or mercury?" I do think that doing analysis of household chemicals and publishing the results is a great idea. A consumer-testing company did some great ad-hoc analysis of sunscreens and found higher-than-acceptable levels of benzene, leading to widespread recalls, which I thought was awesome: https://www.valisure.com/valisure-newsroom/valisure-detects-benzene-in-sunscreen https://www.valisure.com/valisure-newsroom/valisure-detects-.... Still confused about how they plan to make money from this (maybe they could lobby the government to mandate that labs like theirs must do testing on certain consumer products?). Also still confused about this led to regulatory action against them: https://www.consumerreports.org/product-safety/valisure-found-benzene-in-products-fda-inspected-lab-a7872407447/ https://www.consumerreports.org/product-safety/valisure-foun.... Some people in this space publish consumer advisory articles saying "we measured <X> in <Y> and found some <X>" and don't list a safe PPM, or their reasoning, and it's very tough to know what to do with this information. There's often extraordinarily little evidence about how much <X> is bad for you and sometimes we only get the evidence years after people have had hunches that it's not so good. (trans fats? https://www.vox.com/2015/6/17/8793937/why-fda-banned-trans-fats https://www.vox.com/2015/6/17/8793937/why-fda-banned-trans-f... ) So it's tough to know what to do when the pesticide-in-food people publish an analysis which "does not incorporate risk assessment into the calculations. All pesticides are weighted equally, and we do not factor in the levels deemed acceptable by the EPA." (https://www.ewg.org/foodnews/summary.php https://www.ewg.org/foodnews/summary.php). I guess this is one reason to have a doctor and a pediatrician you trust -- because part of their job is to sift through the latest available information and have reasonable heuristics about safety and risks.
- elihu 5y agoHere's the text: https://www.law.cornell.edu/cfr/text/7/246.16a https://www.law.cornell.edu/cfr/text/7/246.16a It's technically allowed to have some other cost-containment structure than a single-winner contract, but there a bunch of criteria that I don't fully understand that make it sound like it's effectively impossible to actually do. > "State agencies must support all waiver requests with documentation in the form of a State Plan amendment as required under § 246.4(a)(14)(x) and may submit such requests only in either of the following circumstances: > ... > The single-supplier competitive system would be inconsistent with the efficient or effective operation of the program. Examples of justifications FNS will not accept for a waiver, include, but are not limited to: preservation of participant preference for otherwise nutritionally equivalent infant formulas; maintenance of health care professionals' prerogatives to prescribe otherwise nutritionally equivalent infant formulas for non-medical reasons; potential loss of free or otherwise discounted materials to WIC clinics and other health care facilities; potential inability of a manufacturer selected in accordance with applicable State procurement procedures to supply contractually-specified amounts of infant formula; and the possibility of interrupted infant formula supplies to retail outlets as a consequence of entering into a contract with a single manufacturer." So, you have to able to make a case that a single-winner contract won't work in your case, but you can't use the argument that a single bidder makes the whole system brittle if the single winner becomes unable to produce product. Wild. I don't see any mention of breach of contract penalties if the supplier can't keep up with demand. Not sure if that means it's left to the discretion of the participating states. I was wondering what legislation created this regulation, and it looks like it dates back to the Child Nutrition Act of 1966, though perhaps it's been amended since. It looks like the concept of "single source" contracts was there from the beginning. https://fns-prod.azureedge.us/sites/default/files/CNA_1966_12-13-10.pdf https://fns-prod.azureedge.us/sites/default/files/CNA_1966_1... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Child_Nutrition_Act https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Child_Nutrition_Act