4 ms·
In any profession, if you want to be very successful, America is your best shot. But you can't have both cradle to grave security, and the opportunity for succ
by WalterBright 5y ago
In any profession, if you want to be very successful, America is your best shot.
But you can't have both cradle to grave security, and the opportunity for success. You can see that in the endless Progressive proposals to erase American billionaires in exchange for more security.
- bombcar 5y agoThere’s also something to not aiming to be very successful - or borrowing success and bringing it back. But if you move to the US for ten/twenty years to amass a pile of success and money, it may be very hard to move back afterwards.
- benditlike 5y agoWhat would make it hard to return to Canada after twenty years?
- pbourke 5y ago15 years here. There are a few things. Housing affordability: Canadian prices have skyrocketed in the past 10-20 years and have increased much more than the US. Cost of living: it’s generally higher in Canada. Where to live: there is much more variety in the US. For instance, there are few “quaint small towns” in Canada in comparison. The American small town/city with a historic Main Street has survived, whereas it’s a fast-vanishing thing in Canada. Much of Canada is starting to look the same in terms of the built environment and urban planning. Access to healthcare: Canada has universal healthcare, and the system kicks in if something serious happens. But for anything not at that level, there are serious issues. For instance, depending on where you live it can be hard to find a primary care doctor. There are waiting lists for many procedures, for imaging, etc. If you have an upper middle class type situation in the US your access to health care is much, much better. I can often get in to see my doctor within 24h. Employment opportunities: it’s much better nowadays, but the US is still the place to be in terms of variety of work and compensation. And finally, it’s hard to leave anywhere after decades - you get used to your life and your community. Canada will always be my homeland, but it’s starting to feel a bit alien to me, in subtle ways. Canada has changed over the past 15 years and you can’t step into the same river twice.
- bombcar 5y agoThe last part is really the hardest - it’s easier to move to a higher paying area when you’re young than it is to move back after you’ve grown connections to a community.
- mmanfrin 5y ago> Progressive proposals to erase American billionaires in exchange for more security. [citation needed]
- WalterBright 5y agohttps://twitter.com/berniesanders/status/1176481898685710337 https://twitter.com/berniesanders/status/1176481898685710337
- djenendik 5y agoi might not be at the top of my profession, but i have a better life here in canada than i had in the us. ymmv.
- wolverine876 5y ago> In any profession, if you want to be very successful, America is your best shot. Perhaps a bit exaggerated, but the big market helps a lot and also has a network affect, attracting other talented people and resources from around the world. > But you can't have both cradle to grave security, and the opportunity for success. People in many countries provide much more security (and investment, such as education) to themselves than the US and also plenty of success, including billionaires, including Canada. The main difference is that the US has a much larger market. Billionaires are of course a tiny portion of the population and not representative of the availability of success. For non-billionaires, many of whom can't afford an education or healthcare, success might be futher away because the Americans don't invest as much in themselves. > Progressive proposals to erase American billionaires in exchange for more security What does that mean, specifically?
- WalterBright 5y agoBernie Sanders, for instance: https://twitter.com/berniesanders/status/1176481898685710337 https://twitter.com/berniesanders/status/1176481898685710337 The American market is global.
- WalterBright 5y agoHave you ever wondered why the FAANG companies are all American? Why Elon Musk left South Africa to come to America? Why millions of people are trying to get over the border into the US?
- wolverine876 5y agoThe large market effect, as described in the GP. It can't be denied that it has significant effect. What do you ascribe it to and why? Less health care doesn't improve the economy directly.