3 ms·
Balanced budgets as a long term policy are a fine thing, and absolutely a good idea. Austerity in the face of recession is madness. This is the Greece/Portuga
by ajross 15y ago
Balanced budgets as a long term policy are a fine thing, and absolutely a good idea. Austerity in the face of recession is madness. This is the Greece/Portugal/Ireland solution, and it's a terrible one. Paul may be one of the few politicians to earnestly care about the first issue; but he's yet another tea party whackjob with his head in the sand about the second.
- brc 15y agoActually if you look at the economic growth of the 'austerity' countries it has been better than the economic growth of the 'stimulated' countries. They are both feeble, but Austerity is marginally outperforming stimulating at the current time, and down the track it will beat it hands down. Yes, it sucks either way, but when debt is the problem, more debt is not the cure. 'Stimulating' is just borrowing future funds to try and get things going now, which, at best, just moves the problem down the road. Many people are quick to try and string up politicians who point out the truth. Sadly this means the politicians who push the problem forwards and reassure people are the ones that get voted in. And the problem gets pushed further down the track and gets even more malignant.
- dasil003 15y agoCouldn't it go either way though? I mean ultimately it just depends on what returns they can get. My impression is that the New Deal in the Depression gave good ROI because the infrastructure improvements opened up new avenues of growth. However if you have massive corruption like in Greece then you're probably better off with austerity.
- brc 15y agoWhen you build the Hoover dam and the interstate system, yes. When you loan money to stimulate defense contractors, non-competitive solar manufacturers and for all sorts of other boondoggles and build bridges to nowhere, no. The problem is that the process of spending on infrastructure rarely is positive in most places for a whole host of reasons. Therefore, austerity is better because it avoids malinvestment. Doing nothing is better than wasting capital. If you borrow money to spend, the spending has to create more return than the cost of the borrowed money, or the money is wasted. This is true in the case of the individual, the company and the government. Individuals rarely invest money for greater returns (think : new cars), companies that last always invest for greater returns, but governments have few incentives to do so. They would much rather make a big splash and announce jobs now, than worry about whether or not they are creating something worthwhile. The problem, of course, is always in measuring the positive returns of large public spending. But again, in times of over-borrowing, governments should always err on the side of caution.
- ajross 15y agoThere were plenty of boondoggles in the 30's too. We remember the dams and highways because they were the successes, not because they were typical.
- handelaar 15y agoGreece is a smoking ruin and getting worse. The UK was outperforming Ireland until the new UK government started swinging a chainsaw around in an ideologically-based austerity drive, and now its growth has vanished. Ireland is improving (hello from Cork) in relative terms because it genuinely had nowhere further south left to go. 20% of the population is on the dole, property prices are down 60% from 2007 and are still falling, mobility of potential jobseekers has been curtailed by the fact that they can't sell up and move because their mortgages are worth twice what the house is. We also took the old government out back and swung an axe into its head in February. The party of government for 80% of the entire history of Ireland as an independent state is now polling in fourth position. Its erstwhile coalition partner is within the margin of error of zero. You cannot but imperil private sector growth by removing massive amounts of cash from the economy all at once[1]. Public employees spend that money they're paid. [1. Please note use of phrase 'all at once'.]
- nhangen 15y agoRon Paul is the only candidate in the election with a voting history to back his beliefs. He may say some crazy things, but at least he's honest, and on the up and up.
- ajross 15y agoI'll take a dishonest politician who votes for the right things over an honest one who is wrong any day of the week. Paul is a nut. The fact that he's right about a handful of things doesn't mean much: stopped clock, yada yada.
- nhangen 15y agoSo you'll take a liar, as long as he votes for what you consider 'right'...right? This is how we got here in the first place.
- cakeface 15y agoI don't think that someone is a liar because they don't always vote in line with their beliefs. There are good reasons for occasionally voting for things that are not 100% inline with what your goals are for one particular issue. Sometimes compromises need to be made in one area to make progress in another.
- rglullis 15y agoHonest question: why "austerity in the face of recession is madness" for the countries in Europe, but it is the only proposal given by the IMF to Mexico in 1996 and Brazil in 1996-2000? Austerity plans are always a tough pill to swallow, and they can cost elections - as it did to Cardoso's sucessor in 2002 - but I fail to understand what is this madness you are talking about. If it were not for the economic policy that forced a surplus in the Brazilian budget, I don't think they would be in the (calmer) situation they are today.
- hristov 15y agoThe IMF regime was utter madness and disaster for Brasil. It resulted in a freefall of the Brasillian gdp. GDP growth only happened after Brasil removed and loosened IMF restrictions in the mid 00's. I do not know much about Mexico.
- rglullis 15y agoWrong in all accounts. The GDP never actually fell. Average growth in 1994-2002 was actually just shy of 3%/year. Not good, but never negative. As for the boom that came afterwards: Lula kept the basis of the economic policy started by Cardoso. In was only in the last two years of Lula's second mandate (2009-2010) that they tried to loose a little bit on government spending (as a way to fight contagion by Housing Crisis), and inflation had shown signs on creeping up again. And even that increase in spending was only possible due to the austerity policies from the previous 15 years that allowed the country to grow their reserves. Had they not followed the IMF rules, they would be in the same situation that Greece/Portugal/Ireland/Italy are today.
- hristov 15y agohttp://www.google.com/publicdata/explore?ds=d5bncppjof8f9_&met_y=ny_gdp_mktp_cd&idim=country:BRA&dl=en&hl=en&q=brazil+gdp http://www.google.com/publicdata/explore?ds=d5bncppjof8f9_&#... Isn't it funny how the magical IMF benefits only come about after the IMF has been kicked out of the country.