3 ms·
Probably because IQ, while a poor measure of general intelligence, is a really good proxy measure for socioeconomic status.
by cratermoon 5y ago
Probably because IQ, while a poor measure of general intelligence, is a really good proxy measure for socioeconomic status.
- s1artibartfast 5y agoIq is a course and imperfect metric, but it is a decent proxy or general intelligence. Pick almost any measures that you think Define general intelligence and you will see stark differences between a group at 80 iq and 120.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- mdp2021 5y ago> Pick almost any measures that you think Define general intelligence and you will see stark differences between a group at 80 iq and 120 I am very curious to see those mappings. Can you point to some? I am especially unsure about what said «measures» can be, and if/which theories about them are developed.
- ZephyrBlu 5y agoThe point is not the specific measure and it's theoretical soundness, but that empirically you will see staggering differences in performance from people with different IQ for most measures you may care to use. In other words, most measures you might come up with are likely to be strongly correlated with IQ.
- barry-cotter 5y agoWhy g Matters: The Complexity of Everyday Life Personnel selection research provides much evidence that intelligence (g) is an important predictor of performance in training and on the job, especially in higher level work. This article provides evidence that g has pervasive utility in work settings because it is essen- tially the ability to deal with cognitive complexity, in particular, with complex information processing. The more complex a work task, the greater the advantages that higher g confers in performing it well. Everyday tasks, like job duties, also differ in their level of complexity. The importance of intelligence therefore differs systematically across differ- ent arenas of social life as well as economic endeavor. Data from the National Adult Literacy Survey are used to show how higher levels of cognitive ability systematically improve individuals’ odds of dealing successfully with the ordinary demands of modem life (such as banking, using maps and transportation schedules, reading and understanding forms, interpreting news articles). These and other data are summarized to illustrate how the advantages of higher g, even when they are small, cumulate to affect the overall life chances of individuals at different ranges of the IQ bell curve. The article concludes by suggesting ways to reduce the risks for low-IQ individuals of being left behind by an increasingly complex postindustrial economy. https://www1.udel.edu/educ/gottfredson/reprints/1997whygmatters.pdf https://www1.udel.edu/educ/gottfredson/reprints/1997whygmatt...
- s1artibartfast 5y agoA little bit more extreme but IQ of 70 to 79 is considered borderline retarded. These people Have difficulty with everyday demands like using a phone or address book. May not be able to learn to read bus or train schedules, bank, fill out forms, or use household appliances like a video recorder, microwave oven, or computer. They therefore require assistance from relatives or social workers in the management of their affairs. They can be employed in simple tasks but require supervision. This is not a matter of effort or exposure. Even with training these people may not be able to acquire these skills over decades. People with higher IQs simply do not have these challenges to the same degree.
- etempleton 5y agoI see IQ tests like the NFL combine. A battery of tests to demonstrate ability, but at the end of the day it doesn’t mean a whole lot beyond one’s ability to excel at specific tasks. Sure, someone who runs a 4.4 40 yard dash is fast, but sometimes they end up not having the same “game speed.” Likewise if someone is a genius IQ, but can’t turn that high test score into productivity then what does it matter? The tests, like the IQ, can flag potential problems that have gone over looked, but beyond that it doesn’t matter if someone runs a 4.3, 4.4, or 4.5 40.
- s1artibartfast 5y agoExactly. And if you look at the candidates that run a 4.3 and those that take 20 seconds, you'll probably notice some really big difference in physicality
- xorcist 5y agoThat doesn't make IQ a good proxy. There are a dozen proxy values just as good as or better than IQ. IQ is unscientific nonsense from the 60s that that been overstudied for cultural reasons. Any time you read it in an article you can substitute it for "socioeconomic reasons". Which is just as unclear but at least it is less of a smokescreen to cast doubt on causality.
- annyeonghada 5y agoThis is completely false propaganda. The scientific consensus is completely different. Here[1] some research. [1]https://www.reddit.com/r/slatestarcodex/comments/oh6115/performance_on_standardized_assessments_of/ https://www.reddit.com/r/slatestarcodex/comments/oh6115/perf...
- xorcist 5y agoThat page lists a number of studies that correlates IQ with a number of other lifestyle factors, and a few that postulates things like "well established in the psychological community". I haven't taken the time to read them thoroughly, but from a glance at the summary not a single one touches on the subject. No one disputes that IQ works, that is not the claim, just as the even more nebulous term "socioeconomic factors" works across wide field s of study. But it is not the best predictor we have. Not sure what types of propaganda you see in this, or who stands to gain from it. If any, it should be those heavily invested in questionable theories, perhaps even making money from peddling books and courses. If you really want to argue that IQ is a scientific measurement, start by explaining the scientific process that arrived at the particular method that is broadly used to measure it. Then, if you really want to convince someone, explain what the feedback process looks like that guides the continuing work to improve the measurement process. Because surely there is one, unless you want to argue that IQ is a perfect predictor that could never be improved? Many things from 60s psychology were quite extraordinary, and as the saying goes extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence. Efforts to reproduce these studies have had limited success, to say the least.
- s1artibartfast 5y ago
- chrisco255 5y agoHow do you distinguish cause and effect there? Assume intelligence is correlated with income and that intelligence is a heritable trait. On average, higher IQ people would achieve higher socioeconomic status and pass those traits onto their children.
- rjsw 5y agoCause and effect doesn't matter for the link that the parent comment describes.
- chrisco255 5y agoYes, it does.
- SamReidHughes 5y agoIQ does a far better job of measuring intelligence than it does social status or economic status. Or this obscurantist concept of "socioeconomic" status. If you're going to just make stuff up, at least be realistic.
- xcambar 5y agoIQ is regularly being dismissed as a poor measure of intelligence, mainly because it measures intelligence on a linear scale. It does not take into account perceptive intelligence, emotional intelligence, and others.
- smabie 5y agoNeither does the word intelligence? Seems fine to me
- skybrian 5y agoIt's not enough to say that a multidimensional scale might be a good idea. You have to decide how many dimensions there are, how to measure them, and gain consensus for the new way of doing it. Until there's a new standard, or they see a need to do something different, scientists interested in intelligence are going to stick to measuring IQ.
- xcambar 5y agoI read your contribution as "it's good because that's what we have", which I think is a fallacy. What we have can and should be discussed and challenged. Not having a complete, new and better solution, doesn't prevent us from pointing at flaws. All the while working on the new thing.
- barry-cotter 5y agoResearchers have been looking for a multi-factor theory of intelligence for a long time. People are extremely highly motivated both on a careerist basis and an ideological one to find a better model for intelligence than g/IQ. It’s been tried. The two most famous are Gardner’s Theory of Multiple Intelligences and Sternberg’s Triarchic Theory. The main fault of Gardner’s theory is that it has no empirical backing of any kind[1], which effects its popularity with Ed schools not at all. Sternberg’s theory at least actually works. It’s just that it is extra work and complexity for no increase in predictive validity. There’s no way to distinguish it from straight g. [1]According to a 2006 study, many of Gardner's "intelligences" correlate with the g factor, supporting the idea of a single dominant type of intelligence. According to the study, each of the domains proposed by Gardner involved a blend of g, of cognitive abilities other than g, and, in some cases, of non-cognitive abilities or of personality characteristics. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Theory_of_multiple_intelligences https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Theory_of_multiple_intellige...
- cornel_io 5y agoWhile IQ is a predictor of socioeconomic status, it's also actually a really good predictor of intelligence and almost everything else that we care about behaviorally, under pretty much every alternative measure that anyone has ever proposed. A lot of people are very anti-IQ, but frankly they're usually just mediocre humanities mucklers who don't realize or accept that true intelligence requires the ability to do math, even if it's not your specialty or interest (the math geniuses amongst us are almost without exception 95+% in verbal ability).
- vmception 5y agopast performance isnt a good predictor of future results, its just better than everything else thats where we are with IQ as well
- cornel_io 5y agoAnd it's still a good predictor, which predicts almost everything else. It's not like IQ is an intervention that we're considering...
- etempleton 5y agoDoes IQ tests require much math? I don’t think I have ever taken an IQ test that requires any math at all. Perhaps I am misreading your comment.
- ZephyrBlu 5y agoLow IQ probably means low socioeconomic status, but high IQ doesn't necessarily mean high socioeconomic status is a likely outcome.
- voldacar 5y agoWhat measures general intelligence better than IQ tests?
- wruza 5y agoRecently there was Norway Mensa test article on the frontpage. I went through 2/3 of it and got bored, short of 2 points to be a proud member. But if you give me a room with a crime and suggest to deduct it, I will fail, because my deduction sucks. If you give me 7x7 hard mathdoku, I will also fail, because permutations of 6 is my max capacity. If you give me your primitive 120iq business, it will fail, because I’m a silly perfectionist removed from reality. But I guess most top mensa members will also fail on something as simple as e.g. leetcode 85. I don’t know if any hypothesis in itt/tfa are true or false, but regarding IQ tests I’d like to see much more diversity than stupid boolean ops and rotation over and over.
- xorcist 5y agoThis is a definitions game trap. You can not measure what you can not define.
- annyeonghada 5y agoReally? Thermometers have existed since way before the introduction of the concept of temperature, as rigorously defined in Physics. You can measure "something" and notice that that X is correlated to Y and investigate what that X is.
- xorcist 5y agoNo, the concept of heat and temperature has been along for many millennia before any thermometers were available, along with completely workable theories of heat transfer. The thermometer as we know it didn't exist until the 17th century! Although the Chinese seems to have measured temperature with clay pots since at least the 6th century. The concept of an innate ability to be smart, however, is something else entirely. It is at best a question "I know it when I see it", but where two observers seldom agree. Compare the concept of "love". It is also an age old idea, a word that exists in all languages and used in conversation every day, but the vain of trying to get observers to agree on it has rightly been a trope for millennia. The similarities doesn't end there, with books and courses being peddled on the subject of quantifying and scoring it. Very few of these have any scientific ambitions to speak of however, even among the most grandiose of claims.