3 ms·
Fractional reserve banking directly inflates the economy via loans. If I deposit $1000 into my bank account, the bank will lend it to someone else instead of ju
by matheusmoreira 5y ago
Fractional reserve banking directly inflates the economy via loans. If I deposit $1000 into my bank account, the bank will lend it to someone else instead of just holding it for me. That loan is new money created out of literally nowhere. It only becomes real money when the borrower actually extracts value from this world and earns real dollars in the process. The loan's repayment makes it real. Until that happens, the money doesn't actually exist, it's completely made up.
So borrower goes out and buys the stuff they need to make it happen. That money eventually ends up right back in the bank as a deposit. Once at the bank, it is once again loaned, spent, deposited, loaned, spent, deposited... Quickly inflating $1000 into a whole economic system worth huge figures like $100,000, not one cent of it real until all of the aforementioned economic activity actually succeeds in generating some real value. Always at risk of the whole stack unwinding due to business failures leading to defaults on loans which could cause even more defaults and liquidations and foreclosures and losses and all sorts of problems.
Multiplying that by an entire country's polulation results in truly mind-boggling amounts of money generation and therefore inflation. The actual money supply doesn't actually matter since it's a small fraction of the amount of money that's actually circulating.
The funniest part is cryptocurrency exchanges have turned into banks. They offer bitcoin lending services, savings accounts. Finite bitcoin supply? It doesn't matter. Value can always be inflated away through loans.
- neilwilson 5y agoFractional reserve banking doesn't exist [0]. The Bank of England explained this in 2014. Surely the myth should have died by now. [0]: https://www.bankofengland.co.uk/-/media/boe/files/quarterly-bulletin/2014/money-creation-in-the-modern-economy.pdf https://www.bankofengland.co.uk/-/media/boe/files/quarterly-...
- matheusmoreira 5y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fractional-reserve_banking https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fractional-reserve_banking > Fractional-reserve banking is the system of banking operating in almost all countries worldwide > under which banks that take deposits from the public are required to hold a proportion of their deposit liabilities in liquid assets as a reserve, and are at liberty to lend the remainder to borrowers
- neilwilson 5y agoI quote the Bank of England, and you quote Wikipedia in response. Why not read the BoE report, and respond to that?
- thehappypm 5y agoI’m not really following this. Let’s say I secretly tag my dollars with a red mark. Deposit $1000 cash, and then my account shows a $1000 balance. My red $1000 is probably going to wind up being withdrawn in an ATM by someone else, or used in a mortgage, or something else, but my red tagged $1000 bills don’t suddenly become a multiplied amount of money!
- sumedh 5y agoThat is what the average person thinks what happens but in reality the bank does not even care about your deposit. What actually happens is that the bank just creates a new money from thin air by just adding another zero their account and then transferring some of that new money to the person who wants a loan. The US fed does this too, they add a zero at the end of the existing account and create more money. Its all in a database no cash is being printed.
- thehappypm 5y agoSo you’re telling me that banks routinely scam the ACH system? Pretty sure this is 100% FUD.
- sumedh 5y agoWhy do you think its FUD, what do you mean scam the ACH system?
- matheusmoreira 5y agoYou deposit $1000. The bank does the following accounting: accounts["thehappypm"] += 1000 accounts["reserves"] += 1000 Then I go to the bank and request a $900 loan. It knows it has $1000 lying around doing nothing useful so it just gives a fraction of it to me as a loan. The bank does the following: accounts["reserves"] -= 900 accounts["matheusmoreira"] += 900 So now we have three accounts: accounts["thehappypm"] == 1000 accounts["matheusmoreira"] == 900 accounts["reserves"] == 100 So the bank received a $1000 deposit, kept a $100 reserve and loaned out $900. That $900 is completely made up money. They just credited my account with that amount out of nowhere. I'm supposed to go out there and earn money to pay it back. If I do, all is well. If I default? The bank has its books showing they owe you $1000 but they only have $100 in reserve. The illusion is shattered the second you attempt to withdraw that money. In the real world, it's not just you and me. It's banks leveraging their massive reserves on risky loans and investments that fail, thousands of customers noticing and attempting to withdraw everything they have all at the same time, getting nothing, leading them to default on their debts and so on and so on until the government literally manufactures even more money to bail out the banks by "injecting liquidity" into them and restoring their reserves, putting an end to the bank run at the cost of even more inflation. So I decide to spend that $900 on a computer for software development in order to work remotely. I go to the store and buy one. accounts["matheusmoreira"] -= 900 accounts["store"] += 900 accounts["reserves"] += 900 accounts["thehappypm"] == 1000 accounts["matheusmoreira"] == 0 accounts["store"] == 900 accounts["reserves"] == 1000 The bank just received a $900 deposit, so its original reserves are restored. This means another loan is possible! This cycle repeats itself many times as money circulates until millions have been created out of thin air. Notice that the only way those accounts balance is if I pay back my $900 loan. If I lose my job before that happens? They won't balance and the bank will have to pick and choose who can withdraw and how much. Not too long ago, Binance had restrictions on bitcoin withdrawals. Unverified accounts could only withdraw a small amount per day, verified accounts could withdraw a larger but still limited sum. Hmm...