4 ms·
> a recent grad could easily ramp up to out compete them with about 1 year worth of training and investment. What about if you gave the veteran programmer 1 ye
by lapcat 5y ago
> a recent grad could easily ramp up to out compete them with about 1 year worth of training and investment.
What about if you gave the veteran programmer 1 year worth of training and investment?
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- Kranar 5y agoThe whole point is that I'm mostly indifferent about whether someone is a veteran programmer with 20 years of experience or is a recent grad with 2-3 years of experience. The number of years of experience matters very little to me. Both get the same technical interview, get asked the same questions, and are evaluated on the same basis.
- lapcat 5y agoI think it's reasonable to wonder if the interview process is actually "indifferent", or whether it's designed to screen out older people in favor of younger people. How exactly could you or would you "test" for the value of experience, or do you believe that experience never has any value?
- Kranar 5y agoI test for competency not experience. If your experience makes you competent then great, if it doesn't make you competent then so be it, I don't care one way or another because I'm not looking to hire experienced people but rather competent people.
- lapcat 5y ago> I test for competency Well, that's what everyone thinks they're testing for. The empirical evidence suggests otherwise. https://news.ncsu.edu/2020/07/tech-job-interviews-anxiety/ https://news.ncsu.edu/2020/07/tech-job-interviews-anxiety/
- hnfong 5y agoYou again. If what you're implying is that experience makes somebody anxious when performing under pressure, then obviously that's a rational reason to prefer those who have less experience. I don't think experience means more anxiety though. And you don't know what the interview process of the GP is like. Why assume they are not telling the truth?
- lapcat 5y ago> You again. Heh, I could say the same thing. You came in later and replied to several of my comments. ;-) > anxious when performing under pressure I have to repeat that I'm talking about job interviews specifically, which is not the same as "performing under pressure". Job interviews are unique in many ways and very different from having a job. This ought to be psychology 101 but somehow many techies don't understand it. The pressure of an on-the-job emergency is not the same as interview pressure. They are psychologically distinct. Anyway, I wouldn't make the general claim that experience makes somebody anxious in job interviews, but I would make the general claim that interview tests often don't actually test for the thing the designers think they do. How exactly does one test for the value of experience, for example? One thing worth noting though: people who have been out of school and on the job for many years may have become unaccustomed to taking tests, especially if they don't interview for jobs frequently. Fresh college grads are fresh from taking tests constantly in school. So test anxiety can start to affect long experienced people just because it's no longer natural for them compared to when they were younger and in school or new on the job market.
- hnfong 5y agoFair enough. There definitely can be and often is bias everywhere since people tend to gravitate towards others who are similar to them (i.e. young people might be biased to hire young, old people old, etc.) I can't imagine any reasonable team to take on somebody based on their CV alone though, you're almost guaranteed to hire somebody who doesn't match their own description. I've seen a couple first hand myself. As I replied to you on the other comment, if you personally have enough options, it's actually better to let some crap companies to have subpar interview processes so that you can detect and avoid them before you take the offer. Pointing out subconscious/unintentional bias is useful though, everyone is better off.