3 ms·
> People don't have a right to live in the US just because they decided to walk across the border illegally. This is invented nonsense. It would be just as re
by kelnos 5y ago
> People don't have a right to live in the US just because they decided to walk across the border illegally.
This is invented nonsense. It would be just as reasonable to say "People don't have the right to live in the US just because they were lucky enough to be born there" or "People don't have the right to live in the US just because their parents were US citizens" or whatever.
"Walking across a border illegally" is an imaginary thing we made up because some people (probably xenophobic people) thought it was a good idea at some point in the past. I don't think unrestricted immigration is necessarily the answer either, but the system as it is clearly does not work.
- teakettle42 5y agoNearly all laws are purely inventions designed towards a particular outcome. That doesn’t mean they’re nonsense, or that instituting the opposite of current laws would be “just as reasonable”. The system as it is does work. Could it work better? Sure. Perhaps we could actually strictly enforce immigration laws, and the result would be ideal. You can argue against the idea of community membership being predicated on more than just showing up, but simply calling it “xenophobia” isn’t an argument. Furthermore, when one side is doing everything possible to undermine the established laws, it’s not convincing when they point out the resulting reduced efficacy as if it were an inherent flaw instead of their own doing.