4 ms·
Stock buybacks aren’t spending money any more than putting it in your retirement fund is. They are value neutral.
by astrange 5y ago
Stock buybacks aren’t spending money any more than putting it in your retirement fund is. They are value neutral.
- JaimeThompson 5y agoThey aren't value neutral if you are spending money on buybacks instead of growing / keeping your factories in working order. See Abbott Labs spending 5 billion on buybacks instead of keeping their infant formula factories up to code.
- astrange 5y agoIt shouldn't have stopped them from maintenance though; they just didn't feel like doing maintenance. If a company wants to spend money on something they can always get a loan for it and consider issuing the shares out again later if needed. The problem with a share buyback is if you do it and then the share price falls again.
- gruez 5y ago>The problem with a share buyback is if you do it and then the share price falls again. how's that a problem? I get it might seem like you're back to square one if you did a buyback early this year, and the recent market crash brought the share price to before the buyback, but you still permanently: 1. paid out money to the shareholders who sold 2. increased the ownership stake of the remaining shareholders
- astrange 5y agoIf it falls again, it's not value neutral anymore - it's a transfer to whoever sold. So then the complaint that you could've used the money on maintenance against poisoning babies becomes true.