3 ms·
> Have you ever interviewed someone whose resume looked good but who couldn't code basic things? The kind of candidate FizzBuzz was invented for? It's a self-f
by lapcat 5y ago
> Have you ever interviewed someone whose resume looked good but who couldn't code basic things? The kind of candidate FizzBuzz was invented for?
It's a self-fulfilling prophesy, if you're using FizzBuzz to judge whether people are competent.
Programmers aren't stage performers, but companies treat interviews like auditions. Anyone with "performance anxiety" is assumed to be incompetent, which is silly. The tech interview/audition is unnatural and very different from normal work.
It's been shown by researchers over and over that interviews test for anxiety, not skills, but interviewers refuse to listen. https://news.ncsu.edu/2020/07/tech-job-interviews-anxiety/ https://news.ncsu.edu/2020/07/tech-job-interviews-anxiety/
- mlboss 5y agoWe all know interviews are unrealistic. But nobody knows an alternative way of testing a candidate in few hours.
- 0x20cowboy 5y agoIt doesn’t work, but we’re going to do it anyway. Science.
- lapcat 5y ago> nobody knows an alternative way of testing a candidate in few hours Why test? Seriously, why are interviews tests? Everyone seems very worried about incompetent job candidates, but what about incompetent colleagues and managers? We act like interviews are one-way when in fact they're two-way, and the candidate needs to decide if they actually want to work for the potential employer. Does the candidate get to test the interviewers? Nobody wants to work with incompetent colleagues, and especially not an incompetent manager, which is the worst. There are a lot of incompetent engineering managers, and indeed I would estimate that engineering managers are more likely to be incompetent than engineers, because engineers are frequently promoted to engineering managers despite having no background or training in management. It's ok though, I'll let the manager do a take home test in their spare time.
- paulryanrogers 5y agoCould tests be the least worst option? Onboarding is expensive. Contract to hire may be the next least bad solution, assuming one doesn't require the new person months to get up too speed.
- molsongolden 5y agoRigorous interviews are intended to reduce the number of incompetent colleagues and managers. All of those colleagues and managers went through interviews too. Sometimes candidates prefer rigorous interviews because it means the people inside the company all made it through those same hoops.
- lapcat 5y ago> Rigorous interviews are intended to reduce the number of incompetent colleagues and managers. All of those colleagues and managers went through interviews too. My point was that engineers get promoted to engineering manager without any kind of "manager test", so there's no assurance of competence at all. Also, I've heard of many cases where certain candidates are allowed to bypass the normal interview rounds, or get coached on the company's interviews, or get "softball" questions during those interviews, if the company wants to hire that person for some reason no matter what. Moreover, there's no guarantee that the current interview process is the same as the past interview process, especially for older companies. (Think Apple, for example.) Certainly the founders of a company never went through the process, and probably the initial employees didn't either. The founding of a company is almost always "informal", and only later is a more "rigorous" process imposed on newcomers.
- madeofpalk 5y ago> My point was that engineers get promoted to engineering manager without any kind of "manager test", so there's no assurance of competence at all. Of course they do - their entire experience with the company prior is the "manager test". A company that just promotes anyone to EM that just puts their hand up, despite demonstrating their not suitable, has other problems.