3 ms·
Maintenance is not "totally irrelevant" to people who have someone else do it. > This is true, but very, very few bikes ever get the kind of miles put on them
by kazinator 5y ago
Maintenance is not "totally irrelevant" to people who have someone else do it.
> This is true, but very, very few bikes ever get the kind of miles put on them to wear out a chain.
I suspect that is changing with e-bikes which are used for actual daily commuting. People buy those things to ride them.
In my experience, daily commuting of around 20 km on a non-powered ordinary bike all year round requires a yearly chain replacement. You can get away with a once per two years cassette job.
Now these e-bikes have serious torque and power. You regularly see them keeping up with cars going 50 km/h or more, even uphill. Yet may use use ordinary drive trains, such as entry-level Shimano cassettes, derailleurs and rings. The power of the motor can easily be expected to trash these components way faster than a human power.
> In the extraordinarily unlikely case that somebody manages to wear out the chain on a cheap bike, they're almost certainly as well off just buying a new cheap bike.
This is false, because chains cost something like $15-$30. Cheap chains and drive sets are still found on entry-level real bikes that might go for $600-$800 or whatever. You're not going to replace an $800 bike because of the chain.
It wouldn't make sense to replace even a $100 bike-shaped-object if all it needs is a $15 chain. There was a time when I rode crap bikes; I still maintained them, and replaced the chain.
> I've broken and replaced spokes. It's pretty rare.
During my daily cycling era when I didn't have a car for some 8 years, I fixed about 3 broken spokes per year. Almost always on the drive side of the rear wheel. So while rarer than a flat tire, it's not that rare.
I had no time for bike shops. They are too far away and have stupid hours like not opening until 10:30 on a weekday, and being closed Sundays. They will keep your bike for at least a day, and charge some ridiculous amount to change a part that costs a dollar.
Truing a wheel is not difficult (particularly lateral-only truing), and once you go to disc brakes, perfection is less important. The bike can even be ridden for a few days with a broken spoke: you just have to clip it off, because you don't want a broken spoke flailing around. It's not a great idea to ride a wheel with a broken spoke, but lets you schedule a good time to fix it, if you're busy
What I'd pay a shop to do would be axial truing: fixing the eccentricity of the wheel's circle. I asume that if I tell a shop to true a wheel, they are only going to care about left-right wobble, which "anyone" can do.
- mrob 5y ago>I fixed about 3 broken spokes per year. Almost always on the drive side of the rear wheel. This hints at one less obvious advantage of the drive system described in the article: no need for asymmetrical wheel dishing. Rear wheels for conventional derailleur systems have to be built asymmetrically[0]. This makes the wheel weaker than a symmetrical one, because the drive side spokes are under higher tension. I ride a hub gear bicycle with symmetrical wheels as my primary form of transport and I've never broken a spoke. Electric drive would allow the same wheel strength. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bicycle_wheel#Dish https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bicycle_wheel#Dish
- mauvehaus 5y agoLet me put it in programmer terms: you and I are like the 1% of browser users who open the developer tools. We exist, but to the larger bike industry the number of people like us rounds to zero. You also fall into one of the (as far as I can tell) two groups that skew heavily towards caring about end-user maintainability: hard-core transportation cyclists (you, and to a much lesser extent me), and people who bike tour (me as well, though not recently)
- kazinator 5y agoThanks to the recent proliferation of e-bikes, driven by battery tech improvements, many more people are looking at bikes as viable urban transportation. People who are relatively unfit, and would never commute on a human-powered bike, day in and day out, are zooming around town on these things, logging many miles. Maintenance issues are going to matter. People are not going to fork up two thousand dollars just to have the thing sitting in storage; they are looking to it to solve a transportation problem. Only the spoke-changing maintenance issue applies to hard-core DIY people; the remainder of the point is that the electric transmission likely requires next to zero maintenance. So for the non-DIY people who don't maintain bicycle drive trains themselves, this still means less downtime and expense. If a spoke is easier to change, that could make a difference to your bike shop visit: "sure, I have some time to do that within the next one to two hours" versus "I can have that ready by noon tomorrow".