3 ms·
Yeah, this looks like a way out of the deal. TSLA has a problem with its stock. It's way overpriced for the size of the company. For Tesla, the company, to gro
by Animats 5y ago
Yeah, this looks like a way out of the deal.
TSLA has a problem with its stock. It's way overpriced for the size of the company. For Tesla, the company, to grow into its stock price, it has to make more cars than Toyota, GM, Ford, Volkswagen, and the rest of the top 12 car companies put together. Toyota alone makes 5x as many cars as Tesla.
Which means TSLA is a meme stock. And the bottom is falling out of meme stocks.
- encoderer 5y ago> For Tesla, the company, to grow into its stock price, it has to make more cars than Toyota, GM, Ford, Volkswagen, and the rest of the top 12 car companies put together. You’re right that Tesla is valued on future performance but this part is just factually wrong. They will need ultimately to make more profits than those companies combined, but the number of cars is not that important. Apple has a ~25% share of the phone market but makes most of the profit.
- dlisboa 5y ago> They will need ultimately to make more profits than those companies combined, but the number of cars is not that important That climbs pretty linearly with car sales. There's only so much margin you can make with a vehicle in any market. Apple manages to have higher profit at lower sales because selling a phone for $1000 that cost $200 is possible since millions of people can afford $1000. Selling a $100k car that cost $20k is a much bigger margin than maybe Toyota has, but there are very few people who can afford $100k cars. Eventually you need volume. Apple itself has huge volume, they are outsold by around 20-30% against Samsung, not by 5000%.
- Animats 5y agoYes, automakers can push the "more car per car" thing. Luxury cars don't really cost that much more to make than low-end cars, and the profit margins are much better. But the market for high-price cars is limited, and there are too many companies in it already. The volume is in the low-priced cars.
- encoderer 5y agoNo. Tesla literally has sold for years the right to a software only $10k upgrade. Who cares if that’s crazy or not they’ve done it. And they have vertically integrated, after automakers spent decades spinning out. Much more value capture. And they have secured better rights to raw materials (lithium).
- TheDarkestSoul 5y agoThese sorts of discussions start to seem nitpicky when you're talking about the sheer magnitude by which they're overvalued. Whether they have to make more _profits_ or _cars_ than every other car company combined doesn't really matter because it's so ridiculous.
- encoderer 5y agoTruly, it’s not. Many industries have single companies making the majority of profits. It’s really not uncommon.
- strangattractor 5y agoCan you say "margin call". His tune has changed - he realizes he cannot do it with Tesla stock. Bringing in other investors now. They will want a return on their investment other than "freedom of speech" if you believe the BS he used for a reason in the first place. There are some things even the riches man on the planet cannot have.
- dahfizz 5y agoTSLA does make way more EVs than anyone else. They are valued on their potential as the clear leader going forward.