4 ms·
It should be pointed out that Bell's inequalities only rule out the existence of classical hidden variables being able to explain quantum effects, which if one
by jerf 15y ago
It should be pointed out that Bell's inequalities only rule out the existence of classical hidden variables being able to explain quantum effects, which if one understands the history behind the question makes sense. Technically it doesn't (and can't) rule out hidden variables that are "quantum" in nature (if you'll permit me the shorthand), but from our perspective those are the very definition of a needlessly multiplied entity in the Occam's Razor sense. Nevertheless, that simply means they aren't useful to us, not that they don't exist. It is certainly possible to imagine that we exist in a simulation in which the simulation is "quantum", but whenever a random number is needed, a psuedorandom and deterministic source is used instead. We'd never be able to tell from the inside, unless there was something very, very broken about the psuedorandom number generator, which given that we are talking about something with the capacity of simulating our entire universe seems unlikely (unless intentional).
Basically, our universe could be deterministic from the outside while being nondeterministic on the inside, in the sense that those of us on the inside will never be able to collect enough information to predict our own universe's evolution from the inside. (In other news, I'm in the camp that considers "randomness" and "lack of knowledge" to be two phrasings of the same thing, so it's sensible to talk about things being deterministic(/"not random") from one viewpoint but nondeterministic from another.)
This is just FYI since it's relevant, not disagreement.
- jessriedel 15y ago> It should be pointed out that Bell's inequalities only rule out the existence of classical hidden variables being able to explain quantum effects No, Bell's inequality rules out all local hidden variables, whether those variables are generated deterministically or not. Bell's inequality does not say anything about the existence of intrinsic randomness in the universe; it says something about locality. (Of course, the fact that quantum mechanics is intrinsically random as far as we can tell made it conceptually very difficult to formulate the correct inequality, although the math was simple. That's why the original EPR paper couldn't quite nail down what was so weird about QM, even though they were on the right track. It was an astounding feat by John Bell.)