4 ms·
It's not irresponsible to bid 20% over asking. Asking is deliberately underpriced, because it is excellent advertising in a hot RE market. It's irresponsible t
by vkou 5y ago
It's not irresponsible to bid 20% over asking. Asking is deliberately underpriced, because it is excellent advertising in a hot RE market.
It's irresponsible to bid 20% over what the house is worth (which has nothing to do with asking price), just because you got emotionally attached to the house, and started a bidding war with another person emotionally attached to the house.
- bombcar 5y agoWhich is exactly what the "ask below" is trying to get you to do; you act differently (emotionally) in a bidding war than in a price negotiation.
- s1artibartfast 5y agoI don't think it has to be emotional at all. There is what the house is worth to the seller, and what it is worth to the buyer, and the sale price is always somewhere in between. It is just taking advantage of an information asymmetry to get the sale price closer to what it is worth to the buyer.
- corrral 5y agoIt's not "emotionally attached", it's that it's been impossible to buy a house for a while if you're not willing to pay more than it will appraise for. You'll repeatedly lose to buyers who will do that, with cash offers to boot. This has been true even in many cities that aren't trendy, and have been building housing like crazy for a decade.
- s1artibartfast 5y agoIn what market? In the SF bay area 99% of houses appraise, even if they go 50% or $0.5m over asking
- corrral 5y agoBoring Midwestern City that's not even a 3rd-tier tech hub. Other boring Southern city that's also not even a 3rd-tier tech hub. Buyers are having to take on the risk of having to cover any extra over appraisal in cash, consistently, while that used to be rare (and, yes, usually for "I am super invested, emotionally, in getting this particular house" reasons). My unremarkable suburban house in a boring city that's been building housing constantly and extensively for the last 10 years, is up like 25% in value over the last 2 years. We thought, based on extensive experience in this market, that we were already paying a bubble-induced premium of 15-20% when we bought it (possibly no longer true—thanks inflation). WTF.
- s1artibartfast 5y agoI think Inflation scares are a big part of it - at least it was for me. If inflation is 8.5% and a mortgage is 3%, the bank is paying me to buy a more expensive house. At the same time, If I hold and wait to buy, my savings are evaporating while the price goes higher.
- otterley 5y agoI think the appraiser is doing you a favor by not appraising it for the contract price in this case. Why would you want to overpay for a house and have to cover the financing shortfall yourself? Especially in a market that traditionally has slow RE price appreciation. Let the cash buyers suffer the losses. You'll thank yourself later.
- s1artibartfast 5y agoYou're assuming that the deal doesn't go through if it doesn't appraise. In my market nearly all winning offers have waived the appraisal contingency
- otterley 5y agoNot assuming that at all. I'm saying that if the appraisal doesn't go through, then the lender won't cover the remainder of the purchase price, and then the buyer will have to make up the difference out of his/her own pocket. At that point, I'd bail, because the appraiser is raising a red flag. But since you mention it, in the slower market being discussed here, I would definitely not waive an appraisal contingency.
- hackerfromthefu 5y agoMaybe you could think of it like a PE on a growth stock - people expect the house to go up due to inflation of cost of goods as well as all the money that was printed - they are willing to take a punt on the house value in the future, similar to many stocks. There's also sunk cost in the effort of finding a house you want and reluctance to keep looking.
- monktastic1 5y agoIt bears repeating that there is no "what the house is worth" in the abstract. If you somehow know that other bidders will pay at most $X for it, then of course you'd never bid $X * 1.2 -- you'd bid $(X+1). And if lots of people are (or can be made) emotionally attached to a house and pay an apparently unreasonable amount, that is what it's "worth."
- vkou 5y ago> It bears repeating that there is no "what the house is worth" in the abstract. No, but there is a 'what was selling price for similar homes in this area' price in nearly every specific. Listing prices are intentially set to be much lower than selling prices. Selling prices are the real prices, listing prices are fiction. People paying 20% over listing usually means that listing was 20% under selling. Boring! And not financially imprudent! People paying 20% over average selling in the area, for an equivalent home is what raises my eyebrows as financially imprudent.
- gtowey 5y ago> Listing prices are intentially set to be much lower than selling prices. Selling prices are the real prices, listing prices are fiction I feel like this is only true in irrational housing markets, or at least those that have a chronic undersupply of housing . In my local non-insane market I went through two different purchases where I successfully bid less than asking. That's gone since the pandemic though since everyone tried to move out of cities and work remote in my town.
- s1artibartfast 5y agoIt is basically true for sellers markets, because it gives more advantage to the seller. being a sellers market doesn't make it an irrational housing market. During a buyers market, prices usually approach the list or go under. This reflects the fact there is how much the house is worth to the seller, and how much it is worth to the buyer, and neither of these are the sale price.
- cwilkes 5y agoNo broker in their right mind is deliberately underpricing the homes they represent. Why would they? A homeowner talks to another broker and they say they can get 20% more than the first one. Who is the seller going to go with? When we sold our house the broker put it at a fair price. Then along came a couple that’s been outbid a number of times and offered 30% over within 24 hours of listing. Was the home underpriced? Maybe, but the housing market is such that it doesn’t have to appeal to hundreds of people. Just one. Looking at the people going through the home most of them were using flyhomes.com (they operate as sort of a “we will pay cash for the house and then you pay us back”) and probably had no intention of living there.
- mancerayder 5y agoThey set the price well under market in order to generate interest and visits. Next, in the same time interval multiple people bid, and you get a bidding war. Alternatively, price it at what you want it, and let it sit however long it takes. For hot markets, the former is what is done, in the US at least
- sokoloff 5y agoIf you think the house will sell for $1.01M, you should absolutely list it just under $1M (so it hits the screens of shoppers who are only looking at $700K-1M houses).
- mancerayder 5y agoAnd you get more simultaneous bids. If one prices it high for the long term and prefers patience, there'll be sporadic bids and eventually low-balls.
- ploika 5y ago"Price to Entice" is a very real thing where I live. It's basically a way of getting your listing seen by more people, and increasing the chances of a bidding war pushing up the final sales price.
- robocat 5y ago> It's irresponsible to bid 20% over what the house is worth . . . emotionally attached If you are young it can be perfectly sensible to bid far more for a home you love. An “overpayment” is paid over many years of happy living, which can be a worthwhile trade. Living in a cheap economically sensible shithole for too many years is a bad idea, unless you have no other choice financially. The problem is making sure you buy a home that makes you happy. Overcapitalisation is sensible if you can afford it, and if you truely do get valuable pleasure from living in your home. Yes, do take care to avoid the mistake of buying a home and getting chained into a situation you end up hating.
- wing-_-nuts 5y agoTell me you're in real estate without telling me you're in real estate. I think most people are better off just renting until this madness blows over. God knows I am much better off for having rented and plowing my money into investments for about a decade before I bought my place. Houses keep up with inflation over the long run, while stocks have returned ~ 7% after inflation. If housing is an investment, it's a poor one, and you should invest only what is absolutely required to have what you need not want.
- robocat 5y agoHa ha! I completely loath real estate, and I think I am an engineer type on the spectrum. https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html I think you are committing the error I am trying to point out: don’t treat your living requirements 100% as an investment. That said, your living choice always has an investment decision component, because most of us need one roof over our head. If renting, you are shorting the home ownership market (a renter owns zero bedrooms but needs one bedroom). Making the decision to rent is either (a) betting against the real estate market (shorting), or (b) betting that one can make better returns through other investments. The deeper point is that we should try to optimise for our internal joy, and nobody should measure their success only in metric dollars.