4 ms·
Honestly, it's hard to believe that one person who isn't actually producing/outputting anything can create that much value, and that you can't fund someone to d
by giantg2 5y ago
Honestly, it's hard to believe that one person who isn't actually producing/outputting anything can create that much value, and that you can't fund someone to do the same work for half the cost.
- yowlingcat 5y agoIf you could find someone to do the same work for half the cost, you'd be able to make a pretty penny as a retained executive recruiter. Knowing a couple of friends who run such firms, let me tell you -- it would be hard to find someone of 25% of that caliber for even 75% of that price. Value is what the market is willing to pay. There is only 1 Andy Jassy in the world in the same way there is only 1 Jeff Bezos.
- jka 5y agoI'd be curious to see the results of (crowds of?) normal people paid to say what their responses would be in the type of situations that leaders on these pay packages have to deal with, when given similar levels of context. No doubt that's not the entire job: there's also networking, communication and thought leadership involved. But similar approaches could apply. Liability could be a trickier one.
- yowlingcat 5y agoOf those three, "networking" and "thought leadership" are more hobbies rather than concrete responsibilities of the job. There are actual concrete responsibilities that a CEO at that level needs to accomplish, a sample of which include: - fundraising - organizational structuring - hiring - strategic planning + competitive positioning - go to market motions - R&D - investor relations There's nothing fungible about any of these responsibilities, so no matter how many ordinary people you stack together, you'll never arrive at even a fraction of what a competent executive can do. Companies have executives for the same reasons countries do. Executives rotate in and out of power subject to the ongoing favor of their stakeholders, but the hierarchical structure of retaining an executive to represent the will of those stakeholders remains in place because there's no efficient way to operate otherwise.
- jka 5y agoThanks for the comprehensive response. > There's nothing fungible about any of these responsibilities, so no matter how many ordinary people you stack together, you'll never arrive at even a fraction of what a competent executive can do. I think I'd disagree with that - you state it fairly strongly, but I think that each of the items you mention is possible to delegate and distribute successfully, to varying degrees. Much of that is aided by referring to existing patterns that have succeeded elsewhere. > Executives rotate in and out of power subject to the ongoing favor of their stakeholders, but the hierarchical structure of retaining an executive to represent the will of those stakeholders remains in place because there's no efficient way to operate otherwise. That I do find harder to challenge (and I don't necessarily think it's worth challenging). Conversation and consensus can arise, but even then it's useful to have someone to canvas that and say "ok, I've heard the commentary on this topic, here is our selected outcome".
- yowlingcat 5y ago> I think I'd disagree with that - you state it fairly strongly, but I think that each of the items you mention is possible to delegate and distribute successfully, to varying degrees. Much of that is aided by referring to existing patterns that have succeeded elsewhere. I think we're getting a lot closer to the meat of the issue here. I agree with you that it is possible to delegate and distribute /most/ of what I mentioned successfully to varying degrees. But that leaves the "incompressible" part of the CEO, which is fundraising/investor relations and hiring/org building. Fundraising is completely impossible to delegate (if you delegate that to someone else, you'll alienate investors) and even with hiring/org building, you have to at least do the recruiting/candidate selection of top lieutenants yourself as a CEO in order to make sure that you are putting the right team of divisional heads in place to execute. You have to be a better coach than the vast majority of coaches out there to succeed in this endeavor, and to even attract and accurately assess the kind of talent that will set up the org for success. It is very easy to mess this up. On the whole, a lot of what I'm talking about is high stakes high rewards strategic dealmaking. This isn't a common skill for most people to have. It's a blend of analytical (determining leverage points, BATNA in negotiations) and creative (figuring out how to grow the pie) that is hard to practice unless you've done it before. Most decisions you make here are irreversible. The other challenge with this kind of dealmaking is that the stakes are so high and the counterparties so formidable that if you put anyone except an equally formidable party in place to negotiate with them, you'd end up in a bloodbath that ended up unfavorably for the company and favorably for the counterparty. In my opinion, that's why we end up at the steady state of executive compensation across most of the world that we see today. It's a miserable job unless you really enjoy it because everyone will (and should) blame you when things go wrong. That is made more challenging by the fact that by the time one becomes a successful CEO, one can generally retire off earnings and/or become an investor with much better WLB and risk adjusted returns. PS: I'm also realizing another interesting petri dish where we could see parts of what you're suggesting play out are DAOs in crypto. Theoretically, if we can arrive at a DAO that works efficiently, it would serve as proof that for certain kinds of commercial organizations, the chief executive role may be able to be diminished or even eliminated. I am very curious about whether these experiments pan out (and inside my heart hope they do) although I remain skeptical.
- jka 5y ago(...and perhaps that's what Hacker News is, albeit voluntary)
- giantg2 5y agoFrankly, that all reputation. It's like paying for a brand name. There are likely people who can do similar work for less money. It's just that the people putting up the money want the status that comes with the name.
- kevincox 5y agoI'm not sure it is "just" that. You are paying for the reputation. He has a proven track record of being incredibly effective. That is worth a lot. There are certainly people who can do similar or better work but how do you know who they are? Plus one false-positive here has astronomical impact. Not only but that reputation means that he can fetch huge compensation at competitors, so you need to pay to cover that as well.
- yowlingcat 5y agoIf that was the case, people would make money arbitraging by doing just that. Fortunately, we don't have to speculate here! One case where you can see how the results play out here are leveraged buyouts by private equity firms. In this case, the PE firm is incentivized to cut costs in order to magnify the returns on their leverage. Obviously, the largest line item in OpEx is generally compensation, and executive compensation the largest line item there. If PE firms could cut costs here without issue, they would, because they'd make a LOT of money doing it. But...they don't. Why?
- giantg2 5y agoWho says they don't? It's SOP for them to roll heads, especially at the executive level.
- yowlingcat 5y agoDoesn't mean they end up cutting costs. That's generally to make sure to make sure they get a pliant executor loyal to them.
- kbelder 5y agoI think, rather, that settling for somebody 95% the caliber of Jassy can cost far more than Jassy's compensation in a company as large as Amazon. In those sorts of companies, it's worth hundreds of millions of dollars to eke out a one percent gain in revenue.
- yowlingcat 5y agoA more eloquent way of putting it :) I agree!
- dasil003 5y agoWouldn’t it be harder to believe that an individual who does produce something could generate that much value? There’s a limit to what one person can do. However I’ve definitely seen projects fail with hundreds of high salaries wasted for months or years because of bad leadership.
- giantg2 5y agoHe still stands to earn a huge amount regardless of if he is a good leader or not.
- dasil003 5y agoOf course, but that's a different problem. There are plenty of engineers earning $250k at FAANG who were good enough at grinding leetcode to get their foot in the door but aren't producing anywhere near that much value. Or NNPPs hiding out in Fortune 500 companies quietly pulling in $120k for decades. Sure it's annoying CEOs can be paid so much while failing utterly, or conversely that they can succeed by luck or circumstance that they don't deserve credit for. At the end of the day though, a good CEO can be the difference between life and death for billion dollar companies often enough that the market is what it is.
- __derek__ 5y agoHe'll earn significantly less than the headline number if he turns out to no longer be a good leader, though, because the value of Amazon stock will (continue to) decline.
- maccard 5y ago> Honestly, it's hard to believe that one person who isn't actually producing/outputting anything can create that much value I'm not going to attempt to justify the number, but this statement is incorrect. Value is provided by working on the right thing. I work for a startup, and ~20% of my time is spent figuring out what we're working on/if we need to pivot, and the other 80% on doing some of that work (with other developers). The 20% of time that I spend choosing what we're working provides an order of magnitude more value to the company than the 80% of my time that I spend developing, and I suspect that as we grow that gap will continue to grow.
- giantg2 5y agoIf you're only picking what to work on, them how does anything get done? The people executing on that decision are the ones providing the tangible value. I may get downvoted for this, but I think it's stupid that people get paid obscene amounts for making some decisions and having fancy dinners with other big shots. Then they justify making 100x or 1000x what the actual workers do.
- maccard 5y ago> If you're only picking what to work on, them how does anything get done? The people executing on that decision are the ones providing the tangible value. The situation isn't quite as black and white as that. I'm not just sitting there picking randomly out of a list, I'm ensuring that the people who _are_ providing "tangibles" are providing tangibles in areas that are important to our company and team. Imagine a person can do 5 tasks per week, but they decide to focus on area A which is interesting to them, but not valuable to the project, and area B is something that actually benefits the team/project. By directing those people from area A to area B, you provide a huge value gain. Now consider the fact that I ensure that 10 people are working on area B insead of area A, not just 1. The value of my decision is proprtional to the value of the outcome of all of those people, and if I make a wrong call we're probably done for. > I think it's stupid that people get paid obscene amounts for making some decisions and having fancy dinners with other big shots. Then they justify making 100x or 1000x what the actual workers do. It's an enormous stretch to go from "people who execute those decisions create more value" to "people get paid obscene amounts for making some decisions and ahving fancy dinners/justify making 100x what the actual workers do". I did say in the comment you replied to that I'm not going to try justify the specific number, but as an early employee in a 25/30 person startup, you are not getting paid 100x what the people who do the work are for making some decisions.
- greatpostman 5y agoIt’s a scam and is basically stealing from the employees that do the hard work
- vba616 5y agoA theory I stole from someone is that he's not being paid for doing the hard work, he's being paid for not destroying the hard work (and the company). Like a driver of an armored truck that you pay extra, not for driving it being difficult, but due to the value of the cargo. Does that seem so weird to you?
- seanhunter 5y agoHave you met Andy Jassy? I have, and can say that the guy is a complete boss. I have no hesitation in saying that he would certainly create that much value. The idea that you can just get someone else to do what he does is patently ridiculous. That's like saying "Why should we pay for Lebron? My cousin is pretty good at basketball and would be a lot cheaper". Secondly why do you think he isn't actually producing/outputting anything? Just because you may not understand what a CEO does, doesn't mean he doesn't do anything. The guy certainly produces outcomes (after all, he grew AWS into a billion-revenue company faster than anyone else has ever accomplished that task as one simple example). Finally, the guy is already a billionaire because he's been with Jeff Bezos since the very early days of Amazon. If you want to retain someone like that the compensation is going to be high.
- fnordpiglet 5y agoYeah Andy is remarkable. He consumes incredible amounts of information and makes truly brilliant decisions. I’ll miss my time in the chop with him.
- choko 5y agoI feel like this statement undercuts the value of a good leader. I've worked under both good and bad management, and it's super frustrating and draining when leadership can't focus and prioritize for the best interests of the product. In addition, leadership skills appear to be much more rare than say, good coding skills. I've worked with tons of good programmers, but not very many good leaders.
- giantg2 5y agoTruly good leaders aren't paying themselves 100-1000x what their employees make.