8 ms·
The perception of urban blight is, to the best of my understanding, a mostly separate cultural phenomenon. It doesn't have to be the case for every city in the
by woodruffw 5y ago
The perception of urban blight is, to the best of my understanding, a mostly separate cultural phenomenon. It doesn't have to be the case for every city in the US to be a shining pillar of civic excellence (many of them aren't!) for it to be the case that suburban living drives alienation that feeds into statistically irrational fears of strangers.
In other words: we're talking about two separate things. You're describing an abstract quality of life concern, which is a valid concern that a lot of people share about major cities. I'm talking about a cultural zeitgeist around treating strangers as predators or latent criminals, which is statistically unborn.
(We can also play the anecdote game: I've lived in NYC my entire life, and I've never dodged human excrement or needles. I've seen needles and human waste, but they're a vanishingly small component of my experiences living here.)
- jvanderbot 5y agoLA /Minneapolis citizen here. Urban blight is so real it's a tautology to use two words. The lack of enforcement and the actual protests against enforcement of the most basic laws borders on satire.
- honkycat 5y agoNo. That's the point. The cops take all the money and don't fix the actual problems we have. Do you think cops should be responsible for finding homeless people homes? You can't just throw them all in jail. Being poor isn't illegal yet.
- xyzzyz 5y ago> Do you think cops should be responsible for finding homeless people homes? You can't just throw them all in jail. We used to do just that, and it worked just fine.
- honkycat 5y agoWe have never done that. It is also extraordinarily expensive to do that.
- xyzzyz 5y agoYes, we had and enforced vagrancy laws. It didn’t use to be expensive.
- cafard 5y agoVagrancy laws were ruled unconstitutional by the Supreme Court almost 40 years ago: https://www.washingtonpost.com/archive/politics/1983/05/03/supreme-court-strikes-down-vagrancy-law/a3fc2b52-f0f2-4f42-82a0-0b64836fe685/ https://www.washingtonpost.com/archive/politics/1983/05/03/s.... A bit of reflection will suggest the possibilities of abuse under them.
- boppo1 5y agoFind them homes or throw em all in the clink?
- jvanderbot 5y agoPerhaps greed is a factor in non-enforcement, but I suspect in LA it's more of a "overly humanitarian" subculture. See Echo Park protests. bodies were turning up in that park, and it was unusable for local residents due to a massive encampment and rampant drug use. When the police showed up to clear it, they met actual protestors from outside the neighborhood who thought it was inhumane to force the campers to move on. I lived in Studio City for a bit. We had a well-known vagrant who lived under a local bridge who regularly accosted women, including assault, groping, etc. The nice walking paths along the LA river, and the immediate neighborhood around them were completely unsafe even during daylight hours for my wife and daughters to walk along. What could be done? I lived in mount washington for a bit. There, the citizens would quietly organize, bring lots of shovels, and go "clean up" even the smallest encampments. I suspect if that word got out, they'd meet protestors, or even police. I'm all for helping those who need and want it. The trouble is, there's a significant enough population that doesn't want help, and wants to camp and live among drug use wherever they choose. This is the only case where "Not in my backyard" makes absolute sense. Police can and should protect the safety of neighborhoods and parks which are funded and occupied by tax payers. Go to venice. It looks like a third world country. Last time I went to the beach, none of the shops were open and obviously-mentally-ill people were sitting in their own filth on residential and commercial doorsteps. One obviously intoxicated person was holding a can of gasoline on the sidewalk, and swaying between cars he didn't own. What good can come of this? The rights of the people in that area need to be balanced against each other through the use of local laws and law enforcement. We've gone way too far past "balanced" towards an ideologically-forced tolerance of vagrancy. It is not the job of the average citizen to come up with solutions, it is normal and fine for citizens to collectively demand change from their government and to weigh the outcomes during the next election cycle. My own lack of ingenious ideas for it does not mean I need to be silent and tolerate the solution.
- eropple 5y agoSimilarly, I've lived in and around Boston my entire adult life (I'm 34) and I don't think I've ever seen needles on the street. I've seen what was probably human waste two or three times. It seems like San Francisco and Portland in particular are pretty bad, from talking to folks who live there and from visiting both. But most urban areas I've been to in the United States are fine. (Now, are American cities kind of dirty? Yeah. There's a ton of people who travel through every day. But Americans, as a rule, seem to not like paying that much for other folks. Certainly not enough to pay for the kind of urban cleaning that'd be necessary.)
- don-code 5y agoAs a Bostonian myself, I'm getting used to the idea that we're the exception, rather than the rule. I typically _do_ see these things when I travel within the country. But I'm increasingly seeing it as a "Boston success" rather than a "San Francisco problem" or "Austin problem" or "Seattle problem", because it seems more like a default state, given the current way of things. That said, I'm not sure what to attribute that to. It could be the broad availability of drug rehab and housing services. It could be that the climate is inhospitable to living on the street for the majority of the year. For all I know, it could be an aftershock of the city's love affair with redlining, effectively putting me away from where I would see it.
- erosenbe0 5y agoIt's just a mix of climate and policy. In Milwaukee you can see some serious blight but they don't even allow overnight parking on the streets without a permit, let alone overnight pooping.
- vrc 5y agoDTX is regressing in the last 5-10 years. Not to combat zone levels, but certainly not the calmer place it was becoming
- M5x7wI3CmbEem10 5y agoeven the wealthier areas? southlake, prosper, parks, celina?
- beaconstudios 5y agoAlso, presumably the issue of needles and human waste can be resolved with further prosocial investments in harm reduction facilities for drug users and housing for the homeless. These problems aren't intractable. The UK's hardly a haven of social democracy, but I've never seen human excrement on the street and only seen needles off the beaten path. We don't do a very good job helping our homeless population though.
- erosenbe0 5y agoIn terms of urban detritus, some of the colder US cities might have comparable counterparts in the UK, just with shotspotter and much larger jails.
- dylan604 5y ago>harm reduction facilities To those unsympathetic to addiction being a medical condition, these facilities are just seen as legalization which goes against everything they've been fed. This isn't even a NIMBY thing as they don't just not want it in their area, they don't want them to exist at all. Showing how they have worked in Europe, then they will just write it off as socialist policies run amok.
- beaconstudios 5y agotherein lies the rub.
- tekknik 5y agoIn Europe do they give the users needles and drugs or do they actually fix the problem?
- beaconstudios 5y agogiving people needles and drugs is called harm reduction for a reason - it's to reduce the risk of dirty needles and street drugs, these policies don't solve drug addiction, they just keep drug addicts safe(r). Solving drug addiction is actually a tremendously hard problem but it starts with helping rather than punishing addicts. Portugal is a good example of doing this right: drugs are broadly decriminalised and the government provides help to addicts. Here's an article on drug policies across Europe (and some other countries): https://www.foundationswellness.net/drug-abuse/do-other-countries-treat-addiction-like-us-and-see-it-as-a-global-disease/ https://www.foundationswellness.net/drug-abuse/do-other-coun... Portugal: https://deserthopetreatment.com/addiction-guide/drug-industry-trends/other-countries-addiction-treatment/ https://deserthopetreatment.com/addiction-guide/drug-industr...
- tomcam 5y agoIt’s good to be you. https://pavementpieces.com/on-the-front-line-of-the-heroin-epidemic-in-washington-heights/ https://pavementpieces.com/on-the-front-line-of-the-heroin-e... https://www.nbcnewyork.com/news/local/rockaway-beach-needles-syringes-116-street-queens/1948525/ https://www.nbcnewyork.com/news/local/rockaway-beach-needles... https://nypost.com/2021/09/25/nyc-drug-users-shoot-up-in-broad-daylight-in-midtown/ https://nypost.com/2021/09/25/nyc-drug-users-shoot-up-in-bro... https://nypost.com/2021/08/07/new-records-reveal-rampant-drug-use-at-bronx-park/ https://nypost.com/2021/08/07/new-records-reveal-rampant-dru... http://bronxink.org/2019/09/19/28351-a-zone-of-neglect/ http://bronxink.org/2019/09/19/28351-a-zone-of-neglect/ https://patch.com/new-york/new-york-city/these-are-nycs-poopiest-neighborhoods https://patch.com/new-york/new-york-city/these-are-nycs-poop...
- woodruffw 5y agoIf you're trying to call me a liar, it's better to not be oblique. I've lived in three neighborhoods for my entire life: Bloomingdale (now called "Manhattan Valley"), South Harlem, and Bedford-Stuyvesant. The only one that I regularly saw needles in was South Harlem, and that was only by one apartment where we had a guy dealing on the corner. That was a pretty unpleasant situation. I only saw needles once or twice in Bloomingdale, and I've yet to see them anywhere in my current parts of Brooklyn. As for the poop: NYC has a big dog poop problem, which is what that article is about. I don't think anybody has ever contested that.
- not_really 5y agoI'll call you a liar. Or at best, someone who could be more observant.
- woodruffw 5y agoOf all of the positive and negative things I've been called in my life, "not observant" has never been one of them! We have crime here. But this isn't a superhero comic; it's just not an overriding feature of life. I'm sorry if that's difficult for you to believe.
- jimmytucson 5y agoToday, I walked a couple blocks west of where I work to grab a slice of pizza and while I ate, a dude just hauled forth his member and urinated in the gutter, not 15 feet away from me. I felt bad for the tourists and their kids, but only because the pizza was overpriced and tasted like Digiorno. Usually I find defecation is easiest - not for me, but for the unfortunate souls without access to privacy - at the far end of a subway platform, away from the glare of publicity.
- Groxx 5y agoDepends on where you are. San Francisco absolutely has a real, extremely-visible problem in a number of places. In a "walk from transit to work, you'll see it quite literally every day for years on end" kind of way. When it rains, a significant amount of the Market Street area (and surrounding blocks) smells like pee for a day. --- Part of the issue with the "perception vs reality" claim in big cities is that people who live near-ish to places with issues like this avoid those places, either consciously (x area is dangerous so don't park there) or subconsciously (none of your friends go there, so you don't know anything there, and have no reason to go randomly). Visitors and new arrivals are pretty often more likely to encounter it at a more accurate rate.
- escapedmoose 5y agoAfter regularly getting catcalled directly outside my door and being followed at night, I said “fuck this” and moved to a small walkable town not far outside the city. It’s much easier to not treat strangers as predators here, because they generally don’t act like predators. I still enjoy a day in the city, but at home I can take nighttime walks with no worries. I do feel a little bad that I couldn’t stick it out like other people can.
- tnel77 5y agoI don’t feel it’s fair to criticize someone explaining why they live the way they do when you where the first to criticize said group: >>The communities that hand-wring the most about predators and risks to children tend to be middle class, suburban, and white. The presence of this comment purposely invites controversy. If these people are supposed to behave differently (from a cultural standpoint), there are issues that need to be resolved first. These “two different topics” are heavily intertwined.