12 ms·
This is going to be a polemical comment, but I feel compelled to share it: It's my opinion that a great deal of the blame (if not the outright majority) for th
by woodruffw 5y ago
This is going to be a polemical comment, but I feel compelled to share it:
It's my opinion that a great deal of the blame (if not the outright majority) for this state of affairs can be levied against suburban culture (and, by extension, car culture).
The communities that hand-wring the most about predators and risks to children tend to be middle class, suburban, and white. They drive their children everywhere, and thereby are (somewhat) alienated from the idea of a "local community" beyond the immediate neighborhood (which can only be entered or exited by car.) Things like childcare are purchasable services, not kindnesses that you or your neighbor do for each other when the other's in a pinch. When this is your bubble (or, for the rest of us, the dominant cultural metaphor for responsible parenting), it's hard not to see the world as a foreign and scary place, with unknown levels of unknown danger.
- nr2x 5y agoI lived in NYC for years and saw dicks all the time in public. It is a real problem, and very good reason to shoo away even potential creeps.
- woodruffw 5y agoI grew up in NYC, and saw lots of things as a kid, including very mentally unwell people running around naked. Is it a problem? Yes. It's a problem for them; they were very clearly unwell. Was it a problem for me? I didn't really know how to react as a kid, and more than anything else I remember being sobered rather than traumatized by what I saw. If anything has maladjusted me, I don't think that was it.
- alistairSH 5y agoNo, it isn’t. We aren’t all guilty of perversions because a few guys can’t keep their dicks in their pants. The solution isn’t treating us all like criminals, it’s to get those few perverts psychiatric help.
- denkmoon 5y agoHow much damage did that cause? Seeing people's penis, that is. Can you quantify it for us?
- nuclearnice3 5y agoHow would you expect someone to quantify something like that? These kind of quality of life things are naturally fuzzy subjective and individual.
- deleted 5y ago[deleted]
- twoxproblematic 5y ago
- mayregretit 5y agoIt's like claiming that something from 0 to 100 should be treated as 100. Maybe, but maybe it's more correct to treat it as 0, or as 50. But in this case it's a way to to shut down discussion.
- denkmoon 5y agoTell me where the damage is. Show who has been hurt by seeing a penis, how they were hurt, and how that impacted them. This is puritanical shit. Seeing a penis will not hurt you.
- TedDoesntTalk 5y ago> Seeing a penis will not hurt you. Thank you for making me laugh the hardest i have all week.
- nr2x 5y agoI’m still blind in one eye.
- 5y ago
- simplehuman 5y agoSo the solution is to restrict the lives of kids?
- LAC-Tech 5y agoGreat, just make the city centres safe, clean, friendly places so that people who are "middle class, suburban, and white" want to live there. Then we can all live in four story walkups and ride our bicycles and eat fresh baguettes...without having to dodge heroin needles or human excrement or have abuse hurled it us or be assaulted. I'm being genuinely serious here. I used to love the concept of relatively high density living. For years I walked or rode my bicycle everywhere in cities. But I got sick of the fights and the filth, got too many concussions, and now I'm out here in the country side where I "see the world as a foreign and scary place". Make it nicer and we'll come back. If that doesn't happen, don't complain when we make rational decisions for ourselves and our families.
- resonious 5y agoI moved to Tokyo a few years back, right before the pandemic. Seeing comments like this makes me feel very lucky that I didn't instead choose a large US city.
- daveidol 5y agoI wonder if some of the people commenting here have ever been to a city like Tokyo. It is a great example of what is actually possible when it comes to cleanliness and safety in a massive urban environment.
- Rapzid 5y agoYeah, just move to Japan! Osaka, Kyoto, Tokyo, take your pick! Good luck with the visa and cultural barrier if you like families.
- wincy 5y agoIf Pewdiepie, a man worth millions of dollars can do it after four years of Byzantine bureaucracy can do it, anyone can! Seriously though, he documented just how difficult the process is on his YouTube channel. Moving to Japan is insanely difficult.
- yupper32 5y ago...Car culture is to blame? Suburban culture? We've had "car culture" and modern suburbs for many many many years, including a very large time period where none of this was an issue. Blaming it on "car culture" is completely off.
- lelandbatey 5y agoWe've had "car culture" and suburban culture for less than ~80 years at most. It's only been increasing and spreading in that time. Likewise, the growth in insular suburban culture has been on the rise over a similar time period. I don't think it's accurate to say either is a brand new problem that's existed without the other for the majority of it's existence.
- Schroedingersat 5y agoCloser to 40 years. The worst effects only came with the dismantling of transit and moral panic about letting kids have agency.
- woodruffw 5y agoTwo points: * It's a complex of things. I identify suburban culture (and car culture as a constituent element) as one member of that complex, but there's plenty of identifiable factors: increased passive awareness of our areas (24 hour news that chiefly spotlights crimes), passive surveillance of children (always available via cell phone, locatable via GPS), and so forth. It wouldn't be polemical if I didn't start with the controversial ones, though! * Car culture and suburban culture are not things we've had for "many many many years." They're shockingly new, even by American cultural standards: modern suburbs are a postwar invention, and the cultural lodestone of being stuck in traffic on an interstate beltway somewhere outside of a major city is only a generation or two old. There are, similarly, external factors that have historically masked some of the more deleterious effects of car culture: redlining kept suburbs racially homogeneous for the first half of their history, and over half of women didn't enter the workforce until the late 1970s.
- 5y ago
- Gatsky 5y agoThere are an excessive number of people with untreated mental illness walking around in the USA. This may not be obvious if you haven’t lived elsewhere or can’t tell the difference between psychosis and alternative lifestyle choices. Untreated psychosis is dangerous, delusional people do harm others and themselves. It’s relevant because it is a real medical problem that the US fails to deal with, as opposed to a less well defined cultural issue.
- zdragnar 5y agoWe used to deal with it, but it was considered inhumane (forced care). A social worker I know does her best to get homeless people into mental health care, but most refuse either out of fear of being locked up, or fear of having to quit their addictions.
- hedora 5y agoRegan made it illegal to address this in California while he was governor, but the voters keep passing more mandatory spending on it, so we're in this screwed up situation where overfunded programs have stranded resources, and the problem keeps tailspinning, leading to more stranded resources. $60K/year tent, anyone?
- throwaway0a5e 5y agoThis isn't a physical outlay of towns or a cars problem. This is a people with no real exposure to "real crime" problem.
- koboll 5y ago>They drive their children everywhere, and thereby are (somewhat) alienated from the idea of a "local community" beyond the immediate neighborhood (which can only be entered or exited by car.) I see your point, but I think it's broader than something that can be attributed solely to cars. I've lived in apartments and condos in the hearts of major American cities my entire adult life, and I'm surrounded by the same phenomenon in different form. I know maybe 3 of my neighbors in the hall from walking past them and saying hi once in a while, but besides that, I have basically no contact with them. My partner grew up in an eastern European country and she tells stories of how, on holidays, people would go out to the hallways of her apartment building to congregate and drink and hang out. This concept seems totally alien to me. I'm pretty sure if a resident tried congregating in the hallways of any of the buildings I've lived in, security would be called to clear them out. I've only lived in urban well-off-millennial type places. Maybe this is something unique to the upper-middle class and above. But I don't think it's entirely about suburbia.
- eropple 5y agoMy experience is similar to yours, but I wonder how it's different when you aren't "just passing through". The way that we have structured the mix of movement-for-career and rental precarity (at the lower end) suggests that we disincentivize "putting down roots" in the way that normalizes that kind of behavior.
- woodruffw 5y agoI think this is a great observation, and I agree that it can't be attributed solely to cars. This is a little bit of what I was trying to get at with the "dominant cultural metaphor": the US has undergone a fundamental cultural shift around strangers for the last 50-70 years. I attribute a decent amount of that to the alienation afforded to us by driving everywhere, but it has lots of other root causes: the steady erosion of local businesses in favor of chains, the professionalization of familial and community responsibilities, and (more recently) social media's affordance of cheap engagement. And here's the thing: a lot of those root causes are good, or (at the very least) unavoidable! Our society is still pretty unjust, but it's a lot more just than when there was a uniform expectation that women stayed home and raised children. Social media poisons our discourse, but it's also made local organizing and event planning easier than ever.
- tamaharbor 5y agoAs an example, how many children have actually been injured by razor blades in Halloween apples?
- woodruffw 5y agoGreat example. I'll never forget the Strawberry Quik[1] one -- my parents warned me about it! [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Strawberry_Quik_meth_myth https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Strawberry_Quik_meth_myth
- TrispusAttucks 5y agoThe media, the decay of social culture norms, defuned the police, release of violent criminals, the states failure to keep cities safe and clean. Those are the culprits.
- woodruffw 5y agoWith the exception of the media, I don't think you could draw a consistent chronology for any of these things across the last 30-40 years of moral panic over children's safety. US crime rates, for example, are markedly lower than they were in the 1990s, and we probably spend more on the police now as well.
- TrispusAttucks 5y agoThe last decade statistics disagree. Country wide there is a reduction but within the some big cities it has increased significantly. "On average, violent crime has climbed by 12 percent in U.S. cities, while property crime has declined by 33 percent since 2010. Robbery rates fell in the average U.S. city by 23 percent, while murder, rape, and aggravated assault all climbed by 25 percent or more." Scroll down on that link and check out the crime change over the last decade "2010-2020 change". It does look like a handful of cities are really really bad and may be skewing things. [1] https://www.safehome.org/resources/crime-statistics-by-state/ https://www.safehome.org/resources/crime-statistics-by-state...
- JKCalhoun 5y agoSuburbs? I grew up in the suburbs and biked/walked everywhere. We were working-class/poor though and this was the 70's. Maybe it's socio-economic and recent. Sure smells like fear though, probably too much cable news spooking the parents.
- ALittleLight 5y agoSeems opposite to my experience. I lived in Seattle for a while. Mentally ill, drunk, or intoxicated homeless are pretty common on the street. I witnessed shoplifting pretty often, threats and screaming people often, and people smoking crack pipes and injecting themselves pretty often. My wife was harassed or threatened multiple times by homeless people. We moved out to the suburbs. Here, we see crowds of kids in the afternoons. They are playing in the park, roller blading, scootering around, running to one another's houses. Most of the kids are unattended and running about their own business. It seems much more natural and healthy than the environment of the city, where, not incidentally, kids were rare. The "foreign scary place" was the city. The small community of neighbors who know one another is a friendly safe place. I would not want my kids running around the city by themselves - I don't mind it here. I don't think the reason is because of "hand wringing" or baseless worries over safety. I think the reason is that the city is overrun with mentally ill drug addicts who make a dangerous environment for unattended children.
- Fargoan 5y agoIt's been years since I've been to Seattle, but most of the city seems pretty chill. It's just around downtown that's "scary"
- xyzzyz 5y agoMore places are really bad now, not only downtown. Chinatown is really bad now, Ballard is bad (the walkable part of it, that is), South Seattle is bad.
- closeparen 5y agoThere is no world where the children of the middle class share a community and public space with untreated mentally ill homeless people who have full and equal rights to that space. We don’t want to violently oppress people over bourgeois norms of behavior but we do want to live in communities that adhere to such norms. That is the real social function of car dependent geography.
- Schroedingersat 5y agoThen treat the mentally ill for free and give them houses. How is this hard?
- closeparen 5y agoBeing a tolerable neighbor involves skills, habits, and self control that are far from universal. Showing up to appointments and taking your meds every time is hard for yuppies with mild depression, let alone people with much looser holds on life. Inpatient mental health facilities are necesarily more coercive and less fun than the outside world. The mentally ill have civil rights too and can check themselves out unless their situation continues to meet a high bar for imminent risk of serious harm. People in between “cannot manage own life” and “imminent danger to self and others” are a tricky proposition for the mental health system. It only takes a handful of such people wandering around your city center continuously (seriously, it’s the same dozen faces over and over in SF) to completely change the kind of place it is.
- jhugo 5y agoWhy is this such a uniquely American problem? Large, dense cities in the rest of the world don't face these issues.
- np- 5y agoLarge dense cities in certain parts of Europe and east Asia don’t face these issues (and even then, there isn’t really the same concept of large and dense in most of Europe), but I would say chaotic unfriendly cities are the default in most of the world. In a sense, many American cities act as a bridge between these two worlds. It also doesn’t help that you can fall much farther in the US than other places before anyone even begins to notice.
- tomcam 5y ago> The communities that hand-wring the most about predators and risks to children tend to be middle class, suburban, and white. Racist much? Have any receipts to back that up? I live in a predominantly Asian neighborhood and it turns out they like living in a safe area too. Weird, huh?
- woodruffw 5y agoHuman beings, as a rule, like safety. And you're reading too much into the white part: the history of middle class suburbia is the history of America's white middle class, which is in turn more or less the history of America's race politics. It's not a particularly searing or piecing observation on my part.
- tomcam 5y ago> It's not a particularly searing or piecing observation on my part. No, just racist.
- woodruffw 5y agoThis is an attested piece of American history. I don't know what makes it racist, unless using the word "white" taints it for you.
- thraway3837 5y agoIt does, I believe they believe in reverse racism too. HN crowd isn't the best place for intelligent discussion beyond the weekly jq/sql/crypto/mobile apps as a business. And even then, most of the riff raff makes really stupid comments.
- tomcam 5y agoThe term “reverse racism“ is nonsensical. Judging people based solely on immutable racial characteristics is racism.
- trinovantes 5y agoPeople living in gated communities have a higher perceived level of crime [1] than those who don't so it's not that surprising that the more isolated you are, the more you see the rest of world as dangerous [1] https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S1877042812003758 https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S187704281...
- pojzon 5y agoIt may be true OR the world crime rates are increasing, dense population causes violance and ppl are just realistic and want to avoid problems. The later in USA is not hard to see even as a foreigner.
- trinovantes 5y agoMaybe absolute number of cases but I highly doubt crime per capita is higher in denser locations. If anything, dense population should deter crime. I suspect it's harder to break into a home or kidnap someone when there are more people around to see or hear.
- pojzon 5y agoThis highly depends whether you count Riots as crime or not.
- woodruffw 5y agoThis is a bizarre view. Even if you go 100% reactionary and treat every 2020 protest as a "riot," the entire year pales in comparison to a single riot in a single neighborhood during the 1960s[1]. Our modern protests (including the "violent" ones) are downright bucolic. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Watts_riots https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Watts_riots
- elzbardico 5y agoA study in Malaysia found that result. It is very strange to automatically assume this is universal. Have you ever been to SE Asia?
- quantified 5y agoI grew up in a major city and was only mugged four times and assaulted (like hit or abused) four times by randos on the street before graduating high school, starting in second grade. All with racial overtones, very explicitly so on the assaults. Yet we (me, my parents, my educators) wouldn’t have dreamed of behaving like these school workers. I don’t think it’s the suburban white folks, though it might be. I think it’s people who buy into an everything is too dangerous mindset. That they go to suburbs is effect, not cause. Figured the author was a dude from the title, totally surprised it wasn’t. I too suffer from the fear that if I’m around anyone’s kids other than my own, especially at a park, I’m at risk.
- ryukoposting 5y agoThis reads like the opinion of the wealthy white urbanite who has never experienced anything resembling the average lifestyle of a resident in the very city they claim to know so much about. The thing is, I like this article. I agree with it. There just isn't a correlation with helicopter parenting and statistically-average suburbs. If anything, NIMBYism/helicopter bullshit is most prevalent in wealthy urban areas.
- LigmaYC 5y agoNot exclusive to sub-urban. Viewing childcare as a "purchasable service" aplies to pretty much the whole country except rural.
- sunjester 5y agoThat's obviously racist, even if you aren't.
- registeredcorn 5y agoI'm not entirely sure why you hate people different from yourself, but I do hope you are able to get past it at some point. I've been there myself.
- MisterBastahrd 5y agoI grew up in the suburbs and your diatribe is utterly foreign to me. As kids we were expected to get out of the house and not return until it was dark. I spent many days fishing in a river pond that was almost 2 miles from my house, secluded in the woods. Maybe you need to get out more. The City(tm) is not a panacea. There's no place that people are strangers with each other more than apartment complexes.
- woodruffw 5y agoI'm glad it's not your experience. It wasn't meant to be a blanket claim about the quality of peoples' lives in the suburbs; it was a general sociological claim about how suburban construction (and car-driven socialization) in the US fosters alienation (and how that alienation turns into latent hostility to strangers).
- MisterBastahrd 5y agoYou haven't thought about the possibility that it's not the suburbs but instead 24/7 news media combined with social media that might be a tad bit more to blame? Cars didn't make parents afraid for their kids. Lots didn't either.
- thraway3837 5y agoExactly this. I agree 100%. A lot of responses are triggered folks who highlight exactly what you're saying. How dare you call suburbs sheltered, boring, and fake. A lot of responses cry about urban places being dangerous hell holes, when in fact it highlights exactly what woodruffw was saying. No one in the suburbs gives a shit about each other, because there is no sense of community. Karen in the HOA cares more about what color your door knob is, and the kids sneak to the basement when the parents are out to try out exotic drugs. Let's not kid ourselves and compare urban centers "as omg, I can't even walk my kid to school without a homeless person that molests them". Hyperbole at the best. Stay in your suburbs, and don't use urban tax dollars to fund your lifestyle choices. And while you're at it, when you visit an urban center, learn to drive and parallel park, or does that scare you too?
- tomcam 5y agoOne thing I can say about you is that the depth of your tolerance is certainly on display here. Impressive.
- mayregretit 5y agoNo, it's news media's sensationalization of exceedingly rare yet awful events (for profit! More at 11). Consuming that poison turns neighbors into strangers and strangers into criminals. How else would disconnected suburban communities be getting the same message that their kids are in danger from something as specific as trench-coated deviants or razor blade apples? We know it started before social media but as it often does, social media has amplified the problem. I'm not sure how much blame Hollywood shares in spreading this fear.
- throwaway48375 5y ago
- heavyset_go 5y agoA trend I've noticed in the suburbs is the paranoia and suspicion of others, and the amount of people who fantasize about society collapsing so that they finally have a reason to shoot their neighbors, should they come knocking for help. One suburban prepper told me that they stockpile weapons for exactly that reason, because when society collapses, they know they'll be ready, and they're willing to shoot anyone who wasn't prepared, even their hungry neighbors. I've heard the same and similar from others with the same inclination to lust for collapse.
- eweise 5y agoI'm not familiar with New York City but is Queens part of suburbia? Also, I live in suburbia and its nothing like what you are describing.
- greenyoda 5y agoQueens is one of the five boroughs of NYC - so it's officially a part of the city, not a suburb. It's a very large and heterogeneous place though, with housing ranging from multi-million dollar mansions to high-rise public housing projects, and neighborhoods ranging from luxury to poverty (and everything in between). Parts of it do look fairly suburban, with big areas of private houses that can be a fairly long walk from the nearest store, where everyone owns a car.
- saeranv 5y agoYes, you're correct. Jane Jacobs[1] in "The Death and Life of Great American Cities" wrote about how dense, walkable environments with storefronts, residents on porches contribute to the concept of friendly strangers that make areas safer. The isolation of the suburbs creates danger. [1] Who unfortunately then proceeded to lock others out of also having this kind of quality of life by becoming a NIMBY...
- desireco42 5y agoFor a long time I didn't understand what is wrong with suburbanites and why I just can't fit in there ever. I love living in the city and raising kids in the city is not easy thing, quite the opposite. I think you summarize and highlighted what I was not able to understand. Thank you!
- renewiltord 5y agoThis doesn’t really match my experience. The axis is different. Grover Beach is suburban and has kids flying down the sidewalks doing jumps without helmets and it’s suburban. Marin is suburban and is full of those loony racist over-concerned mums. SF has hyper-concerned people all the time and it’s dense. There’s a panicky streak kind of person. You see them on the Internet more, I think, telling you how random things are DANGEROUS and stuff like that. It’s not an urban/rural divide. It’s a risk tolerance thing. And since it is so common among Democrat voters (who are massively urban) it doesn’t strike me that dense urban environments relieve someone of the curse of constant fear.
- spicyramen_ 5y agoThis is racist, why you attack white people?
- lelanthran 5y ago> The communities that hand-wring the most about predators and risks to children tend to be middle class, suburban, and white. It's got nothing to do with race. Anyone who has the ability move out of a dangerous space does so, regardless of their race. Getting them to move back in when they are perfectly fine where they are is the problem - they have no control over when and how the city may deteriorate again, and they don't want to have to take the chance of a large financial risk to move again. It doesn't matter if cities are safe now; the suburban folk who move back in realise that they have no control over how safe it will remain.
- cuttysnark 5y agoIt's my opinion that you live in a bubble and see the rest of the world as a foreign and scary place, with unknown levels of unknown danger (a polemical comment, but I felt compelled to share it) > I've lived in NYC my entire life. > hEre's mY taKe on what's wrong with more peaceful, orderly places. Very cool, thank you!
- FooBarBizBazz 5y agoYou say this, and I hate suburbs too, but this story takes place in Queens. It's a bigger issue with the culture.