2 ms·
Without relitigating Citizens United, I would think that content moderation is far less worthy of speech protections than the political movie in Citizens United
by rayiner 5y ago
Without relitigating Citizens United, I would think that content moderation is far less worthy of speech protections than the political movie in Citizens United.
Content moderation is basically house cleaning. Companies do it to make their platforms more pleasant for customers, the same reason stores sweep the floors. But that makes it less deserving of speech protections because it’s not expressive. Put differently, when the ACLU publishes something, people attribute that to the ACLU and the ACLU has the right to control its message. But nobody attributes things people post on Twitter to Twitter.
- dctoedt 5y agoISTM that you're putting the cart before the horse: We don't need to be discussing whether content moderation needs speech protection, because the people who advocate for government regulation of content moderation haven't proved up the need for, and appropriateness of, such regulation. (In litigation terms, since we're both lawyers: It's premature to focus on whether to give platforms free-speech protection for their content moderation would be akin to an affirmative defense: The question doesn't need to be reached unless and until those urging regulation of moderation succeed in making a Twombly/Iqbal plausible case, which in my judgment they haven't.)
- dctoedt 5y agoI edited my #2 in my GP post because we might be talking past each other in the second graf of your parent post above.