5 ms·
> I also think the proposal to have Twitter allow all content that is "legal under US law" is a dangerous idea for the platform being a healthy community that m
by pessimizer 5y ago
> I also think the proposal to have Twitter allow all content that is "legal under US law" is a dangerous idea for the platform being a healthy community that most people actually want to participate in.
I'd counter that platforms like Reddit, Youtube, or Facebook grew into institutions with extremely light content moderation, and it's only after they were successful and were targeted by politicians and media panics that they moderated heavily, and with that moderation their growth slowed.
- unethical_ban 5y agoCorrelation doesn't imply causation. They didn't /need/ to moderate heavily because they didn't attract legions of bad faith actors when they were small, and they stopped growing because growth isn't infinite. And the Internet is a lot different in 2022 than it was in 2007.
- oarsinsync 5y ago> and it's only after they were successful … their growth slowed. Could this simply be because it’s easy to sustain a high rate of growth when you’re small, and harder to sustain that same rate of growth when you’re large? See Apple, as another example of a firm who’s growth rate has slowed, as a natural result of their scale.
- Karawebnetwork 5y agoReddit always has had community moderators which ensured that the subreddits were respecting the rules of their communities. For example, on LGBTQ issues subreddits telling people that they are groomers is not tolerated. If it was, people would quickly go away. While on some other subreddit, it might be tolerated but the targeted people are not present and will not see those messages. It is similar on Facebook where people will gather in groups that have their own moderation. This is different on a public platform like Twitter where everyone can see everything. If users can hate-speech each others within the confines of the law, it will not take long until a lot of people leave. I use hate-speech as an example because the "groomer" as a slur issue is at a peak right now and is fresh in my head. But the same concept applies to a lot of topics.
- fleddr 5y agoNot sure what you're talking about because this kind of hate speech is very common on current day Twitter. The "grooming" remark typically coming from right-wing accounts is very common and as far as I can tell, not moderated. Likewise, left-wing "woke" accounts openly hating whites, men in general or white men specifically is also "just another tuesday".
- the_doctah 5y ago>I use hate-speech as an example because the "groomer" as a slur issue is at a peak right now and is fresh in my head. Mm. I think the problem is that censorship advocates like you try to add words like this into the lexicon of "hate speech" and try to have it censored. It's not, and it shouldn't be, and you should be ashamed of even thinking it. It is not other people's responsibility to stay up to date on what may or may not be triggering you on any particular day.
- nickstinemates 5y agoon top of this, there is approved hate speech, you just have to use different words/dogwhistles like justice or privilege to activate it
- myko 5y agoCould you share an example in a sentence? I'm having a difficult time seeing this as hate speech as written.
- chrsw 5y agoWell, it depends. I've never heard this term "groomer" before. I don't even understand the term but it sounds like there's a community or subculture out there that takes it very seriously. So, if I were in public spaces where people from that community where known to communicate with one another I would absolutely want to know if something I said was offensive or hateful. I would expect to have the issue brought to my attention if I inadvertantly said something problematic. I'm not trying to hurt anyone, I just want to talk with people. I don't feel like my free speech is being impinged upon either.
- KaiserPro 5y ago> Facebook grew into institutions with extremely light content moderation Facebook used to have a strong social cost to being a dick. Then as photos started to explode, they stopped nipples pretty quick. in 2009 they had a fully formed photos policy and moderation system. Moderation has been there since the start and its there to stop normal people getting barraged by niples, pictures of dead things, and spam. Self moderation doesn't really scale when you go over 400 people in a group. After that its drama, then after that it turns into 4chan.