2 ms·
>What? You lose nothing but a perception of privacy in the theoretical case of a backdoor to encryption, we have rule of law ffs. We lost that perception years
by lotsofpulp 5y ago
>What? You lose nothing but a perception of privacy in the theoretical case of a backdoor to encryption, we have rule of law ffs.
We lost that perception years ago when Snowden revealed it was all backdoored anyway. I do not know what rule of law you are referring to.
>If we ban cars tomorrow society grinds to a halt, there will be mass starvation. If we ban e2e encryption in consumer products tomorrow nothing changes.
I do not think anyone serious is referring to banning all cars period. The discussion is more like creating more spaces where large vehicles are de prioritized or not allowed and walking and bicycling are prioritized such that there is greatly reduced risk of being run over. Also included are probably returning cars to smaller sizes and to reduce the severity of injuries and increased visibility.
Banning e2e does change something. Maybe not visibly, and not exactly tomorrow, but it certainly enables and progresses the mission of those wanting to limit civil rights.
- riversflow 5y agoShow me where completely innocent US citizens have actually been imprisoned as a result of PRISM et. al. To the best of my knowledge the US security apparatus is benevolent towards peaceful civilians, and all the hand ringing about the invasion of privacy is just that. This isn't to say that I support the Patriot Act, only that our rights have already been taken away. > I do not think anyone serious is referring to banning all cars period. And in my view E2E encryption doesn't have to be banned outright, it just needs to be treated as the dangerous tool it is. Making it the default for all communication is like making tanks the standard mode of transportation. How about a encryption registry, like a gun registry? SiValley is currently giving military grade tools too rapists and slavers and then saying that telling them to stop will result in 1984; I just don't buy it. As you pointed out, those in control in the US already have all the tools they need to destroy your life thanks to the Patriot Act and poor judicial enforcement(Stingrays), meanwhile technology has progressed in a way that makes a very marginalized group, poor young women, much more vulnerable. Instead of providing a tech solution for a tech problem, the call from the encryption community is to solve it with the same way we always have. Easy for some rich tech bro to say, but if encryption was really just a shitty tool, I don't think the US security apparatus would have invested so heavily in it.
- rysertio 5y ago> SiValley is currently giving military grade tools too rapists and slavers and then saying that telling them to stop will result in 1984. Unfortunately we live in a world where most data that isn't E2EE is up for sale. Without making E2EE the default for all communication will result in anyone with money the power to know everything about your life. If E2EE is not the default 'poor young women' will be much more vulnerable now, because their abusers will have access to more information about them.