3 ms·
The point is that if physical law is deterministic, then none of these experiments are going to tell you anything about free will that you didn't already know.
by jessriedel 15y ago
The point is that if physical law is deterministic, then none of these experiments are going to tell you anything about free will that you didn't already know. Yes, they tell you that people are confused when they say "I decided to do X" when, in fact, the normal decision making part of the brain wasn't involved with doing X because X was actually artificially stimulated by the experimenter's electric probe. But if you believe in determinism already, what does this tell you about the possibility of free will? Given determinism, we already know that all actions and choices can be traced back to previous causal events, so we already know people are confused when they think that their choices are somehow not caused by previous events but come from their soul or whatever.
So none of the empirical facts are under dispute. The question then is a purely philosophical one: is there a sensible notion of free will given determinism? Should (normative claim!) we treat people like they have free will, i.e. punish/reward them for their actions?
- nooneelse 15y ago> "The point is that if physical law is deterministic..." Under current QM, it doesn't appear that things like alpha decay happen predictably or at one time vs another for any reason. And that isn't simply a problem of not knowing the state of the system; hidden variable theories have not met with empirical success. So, imagine we could have two universes, both with our laws of physics, and identical up to time=0. Current QM allows that at t=1 in one universe radioactive decay occurs which then produces chain of events A, while in the other universe at t=1 there is no decay and thus chain of events B. Why then call these universes and their physical laws deterministic? They seem rather not.
- jessriedel 15y agoI'm a physics grad student doing work in quantum decoherence, so I'm aware of all this. When discussing free will, "determinism" really is shorthand for the idea that the cause of all events can be traced back to previous events in known physics, including fundamental probabilistic events. The key claim is that there is no "soul" (or any other causal source which cannot in-principle be explained by known physics) producing choices. (Yes, you bundle up all the probabilistic quantum events which occur in your brain and identify that as "free will", but I don't think most people would find that compelling. Not the least of which because then it seems like a plutonium atom has just as much right to the term "free will" as you do.)
- nooneelse 15y agoWell, I'm glad then that we get to skip the bit were I have to spell out the facets of the argument I made. (Over on reddit bringing this up usually means me having to gently prod the other person to read up on hidden variable theories so they can tell me if that is what they meant by phrases like "something determines it we just can't see what".) I'm actually a compatibilist about "free will", so I've no need for a ghost in the machine or to be flipping quantum coins in my head. The point of my comment was simply to point out that "our universe is deterministic", full stop, isn't a warranted premise by current evidence. If you only meant "adequately deterministic" by "deterministic", fine and dandy. However, I don't know anything that actually stops the two causal chains A and B in my thought experiment from being macroscopically very different. So skipping the "adequately", I feel, gives those not familiar with the details a misleading impression that we can unproblematically think of ourselves as just in the old clockwork universe. (Thus the kinds of phrasing I see a lot on reddit from the loosely-informed on such matters.) (Edits: silly grammar and spelling stuff.)
- jessriedel 15y agoOK, I support being precise with our terminology. What I was trying to emphasize is that, with regards to discussion of "free will", the important thing about "adequate determinism" isn't predictability. It's that we can trace back all causes to known (possibly intrinsically probabilistic) physical "stuff", with no room for a soul.
- jaylevitt 15y agoSomething I've been wondering, and I'm way out of my depth here - would determinism be something that could eventually find an explanation in information theory? My layman's argument against determinism was something like: OK, even if my biological self is making my decisions for me, how does it get the inputs that drive those decisions? Imagine a simple exercise study, conducted without face-to-face contact. Half of the participants are told to exercise, and half are told not to. At the end, the half that is told to exercise will have exercised more often than the half that did not. Therefore, if the world is deterministic, what's "sending" that determinism from the study to the participant? My conclusion was: I dunno, information is flowing? Though I guess that's where quantum mechanics comes in, and I guess there's probably also an information-theoretic aspect to that.
- joeyo 15y ago> So none of the empirical facts are under dispute. The > question then is a purely philosophical one: is there a > sensible notion of free will given determinism? Should > (normative claim!) we treat people like they have free > will, i.e. punish/reward them for their actions? Thanks for your reply jessriedel. In my opinion the two outcomes that make sense here are to declare that free will makes no sense to apply to any entities at all, or to apply it to literally all entities in the universe. I'm not sure which is more palatable. Regarding the normative / moral / legal issues, I don't think rejecting non-causal free will necessarily has any immediate implications. Patricia Churchland's writings on this topic very persuasive to me.
- jessriedel 15y ago>Patricia Churchland's writings on this topic very persuasive to me. Any particularly accessible works of hers you would recommend?
- joeyo 15y agoHere is a short article of hers that was published in New Scientist: http://www.philosophicalturn.net/intro/Freedom/Churchland_Free_Will.pdf http://www.philosophicalturn.net/intro/Freedom/Churchland_Fr... Here is a lecture of hers on the topic: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=opM7E6ty28A http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=opM7E6ty28A
- jessriedel 15y agoThanks.